Nightingale's Tale - [Game Over]

[GuyInFreezer]

I don't think anyone has presented a strong case so far, even muffin's reason is your case is bad therefore your scum isn't strong case.
I make bad cases all the time.

I may join sukura in no longer making a point anymore since people seem to always hate my cases

[farside22]

I don't think anyone has presented a strong case so far, even muffin's reason is your case is bad therefore your scum isn't strong case.
I make bad cases all the time.

I may join sukura in no longer making a point anymore since people seem to always hate my cases

:shrug:

@kag: I like sarcasm. It's my second lanuage.

[GuyInFreezer]

Dunno. Post like those eat up my motivation for playing.

[GuyInFreezer]

Specifically the second paragraph.
If more people do that it makes this game harder and harder to me needlessly

[Kagami]

Fwiw, my agreement is largely in zmuff's appraisal of players' posting, of which the farside scumread is a minor point. I have some pride in my votes outside of RVS.

The GiF post is completely unrelated to the otherwise coherent 195. You recognize what GiF was saying, right?

[Mac]

I didn't tell you to drop it after you called me scum farside, merely pointed to a post where I said that before you had a go at me.

[Sakura Hana]

Why is this bit of sarcasm interesting?

More Kagami votes pls.

[GuyInFreezer]

The GiF post is completely unrelated to the otherwise coherent 195. You recognize what GiF was saying, right?

What

[Mac]

I think he's scum because of the tunnelvision on gif which lacked a real sense of reasoning

meh

i don't really agree with brian's reads but i don't see scum agenda in his posts

also don't think he's spent that much time talking about gif so uh

also like half the game has claimed or softed stuff - it's not like brian is alone in that regard

I think if you remove the fluff the majority of his posts are about gif. And I said the claim was stupid (not alignment indicative, this goes for everyone) and that I didn't believe it which is more in line with alignment.

[farside22]

Dunno. Post like those eat up my motivation for playing.

Specifically the second paragraph.
If more people do that it makes this game harder and harder to me needlessly

Sorry for me it is pretty demotivating to be asked why I think someone is scum just to have people scum read me for responding to the question and yet people don't respond when I ask why someone is a scum read to them.

Plus cases are a bit blah right now. I hate the sheeping without responses. I hate vague, I could go on a long list of dislike's that people do that people give to figs about and eat my soul alive when it happens.

Fwiw, my agreement is largely in zmuff's appraisal of players' posting, of which the farside scumread is a minor point. I have some pride in my votes outside of RVS.

The GiF post is completely unrelated to the otherwise coherent 195. You recognize what GiF was saying, right?

I have no clue what you are referring to. I thought he was talking about your post.

I didn't tell you to drop it after you called me scum farside, merely pointed to a post where I said that before you had a go at me.

okay

I probably missed that in my tunnel and outrage moments.

So why is Brian a scum read?


Oh and I forgot that gif asked me who else was defending sukura and that was NS.
yes 2 people defending quickly a soft scum read early was a bit odd for me.

Right now I'm a bit bugged that muffin defends Brian. I do have a peeve with people defend others because I typically see scum hide behind those that defend them.

[GuyInFreezer]

Hmm k

Unvote
Vote: Kagami

I mean I already acknowledged notsci.
Who's the other one?

[GuyInFreezer]

Uh that quote shouldn't be there and idk why it's there.

[Kagami]

@farside

It was, he was making the point that 188 sounds to him like a "trying to be helpful" scum-post.

195 is a post that is about muffin's scumread on you, and how bork and I agree with it. It's a fairly straightforward post with obvious intent. You are upset that you are being scumread for what you consider a weak case, and further upset that people would agree with the scumread. It was posted with a defensive mindset that didn't consider the possibility that I didn't vote you because I'm less swayed by that particular aspect of muffin's haiku-wall. I don't consider any of that to be especially alignment indicative.

I'm not entirely sure what to make of the kastuki/kagami thing other than that farside-scum implies katsuki-town.

I was curious why GiF's post was thrown in there, given it's unrelated to everything else, and is supportive of you given the kagami-thinks-I'm-scum PoV. I still am, in fact; it looks like an intentional inclusion.

[Mac]

I think he's scum because of the tunnelvision on gif which lacked a real sense of reasoning, I haven't played with gif in a long time but iirc quick reads is kinda how he plays? he has paid very little attention to anyone in the game not named gif and I think his gaiden hop is poor.

also the claiming already is a bit stupid and I don't believe it

@farside, this explains why I think brian is scum

[farside22]

Vote: kag

[farside22]

I think he's scum because of the tunnelvision on gif which lacked a real sense of reasoning, I haven't played with gif in a long time but iirc quick reads is kinda how he plays? he has paid very little attention to anyone in the game not named gif and I think his gaiden hop is poor.

also the claiming already is a bit stupid and I don't believe it

@farside, this explains why I think brian is scum

Thanks, sorry I missed that as a response to me. I tend to look for my name more then read everything.

That makes sense, I did wonder why bk claimed when he did. I didn't notice the tunnel he had on gif.

[Mac]

it wasn't a response to you, was to muffin but you both asked the same question

[GuyInFreezer]

I was curious why GiF's post was thrown in there, given it's unrelated to everything else, and is supportive of you given the kagami-thinks-I'm-scum PoV. I still am, in fact; it looks like an intentional inclusion.

What is so wrong with including a jokepost in the middle of the post?

[Kagami]

If she's town, it's irrelevant. If she's not, it isn't.

Why are you saying something is necessarily wrong?

[GuyInFreezer]

I mean every case is irrelevant if the target is town and is relevant if the target is scum so what's the point there?
fmpov, you're lashing too hard at something that's a jokepost, so there must be something wrong with that jokepost no?

[Kagami]

When people include joke-posts in the middle of a post, it's typically because they're going through the thread and addressing posts as they read them.

195 is not such a post. It's farside addressing a specific point, and two posts directly related to it.

If this is lashing, and if that was a case, I hate to imagine what I'll be doing when I actually place a vote.

[GuyInFreezer]

So it's about consistency.
Meh. My posts are not always consistent with posting order so it's something I can't wrap my head around with.

[farside22]

When people include joke-posts in the middle of a post, it's typically because they're going through the thread and addressing posts as they read them.

195 is not such a post. It's farside addressing a specific point, and two posts directly related to it.

If this is lashing, and if that was a case, I hate to imagine what I'll be doing when I actually place a vote.

I was addressing things in order as I read them.
My last post in 195 was directect to Bork's post here
How do you get that it's not in order of things I'm reading along the way?

[borkjerfkin]

When people include joke-posts in the middle of a post, it's typically because they're going through the thread and addressing posts as they read them.

195 is not such a post.

I think it actually is, in fact, such a post. posts that she responds to are in chronological order.

Let's pretend that isn't true though: what exactly are you trying to say here?

[borkjerfkin]

And I said the claim was stupid (not alignment indicative, this goes for everyone)

Ok

and that I didn't believe it which is more in line with alignment.

Why do you not believe this claim in particular?