Open 144 - Near-Vanilla - GAME OVER!

[Kdub]

I'm trying to look for any holes in what Al just proposed, but I can't find any. I think it works.

Vote: AndyTony

[saberwolf]

if you don't mind, I'd like to be the hammer, so I'll hold off on my vote

[MadCrawdad]

vote: Andy Tony

[MadCrawdad]

forgot to unvote...

unvote, vote: Andy Tony

[saberwolf]

vote:AndyTony

For the hammer

[AndyTony]

No, I'm not Doc.

Would have posted sooner, site was down, couldn't access it.

[saberwolf]

so are you scum?

[AndyTony]

Nah, man. I think Kdub took a page out of your book.

[saberwolf]

well I can't say I'm completely sad.

I really wanted to see you go over me just to show that people who can't do postage diarrhea can make it in this game too

[AndyTony]

In all fairness, Saber - - the only reason you're alive right now is because a JK targetted you. The JK targetted you to avoid a mislynch. We had to work harder to avoid a mislynch, because without the help of a better player, you sir were doomed to die.

But hey. You've won every chess game you've played against RayFrost. You know what you're doing

Don't need any reassurance for your insecurities as a poor player, mate lol

[saberwolf]

Hey give me some credit. I had a hard time catching up on 70+ pages so I figured pulling a gambit was much easier. It's much easier for you cause you've been around the whole game.

Poor player huh? Check my most recently updated sig. A lot of those new wins were due to me.

[Crazy]

Vote Count:

Alduskkel (0)

AndyTony (4)

- Alduskkel, Kdub, MadCrawdad, saberwolf

Chinaman (0)

Kdub (0)

MadCrawdad (0)

saberwolf (0)

Not voting (2)

- AndyTony, Chinaman

With 6 alive, 4 votes will achieve a lynch.

Deadline for Day 5 is

November 1st

.

AndyTony, the last

Mafia Goon

, has been lynched.

TOWN WINS! CONGRATS ALDUSKKEL, KDUB, MADCRAWDAD, SABERWOLF, CHINAMAN, D3X, DEATHROWKITTY, HOHUM, ODDIN, AND CEPHRIR!

[Crazy]

Mafia - AndyTony, OccamR/Kise, Khamisa

Jailkeeper - dejkha/Alduskkel

Doctor - MadCrawdad

Vanilla Town - Cephrir, ODDin, hohum/dcorbe, hewitt/Seryna/lobstermania/DeathRowKitty, Pitstop/The Replacement/d3x, Kdub, The Corporation/pablito/saberwolf, Zer0ph34r/Chinaman.

Night actions are as follows:

Night One:

Alduskkel jailkeeps AndyTony
MadCrawdad protects The Replacement
AndyTony kills hohum.

Night Two:

Alduskkel jailkeeps d3x
MadCrawdad protects Kdub
Kise kills ODDin

Night Three:

Alduskkel jailkeeps AndyTony
MadCrawdad protects Alduskkel
Kise kills DeathRowKitty

Night Four:

Alduskkel jailkeeps saberwolf
MadCrawdad protects Alduskkel
AndyTony kills d3x

[saberwolf]

Ha! Gut didn't fail me after all! I totally knew it was you, and I'm glad as the person who was the biggest pusher for your lynch, that I was right

[saberwolf]

to clear things up as well: I was totally gambiting the whole time. I had no intention of killing myself, and I deliberately dumbed down my playing in this game. If you looked at my first posts however, I claimed that I thought Kise and AndyTony were scum. Eventually I decided the gambit would have to change, so I started contributing, then pulled back to the gambit when necessary. I do have a hard time retaining 70+ pages as a replacement, but I knew in my head what was going down and found myself to be a better contributor in the logic department.

GG guys.

[Crazy]

For one thing, in all my future games, I am going to add a rule that "You may not replace yourself with an alternative account of yourself." In retrospect, I probably shouldn't have allowed it in this game. (I was about 95% sure that dcorbe was hohum's alt.)

And AndyTony did mention in a PM that he could have still won had he not NKed d3x and chosen to not kill. Saberwolf probably would have been lynched Day 5 after Ald's JK, and then if AT killed MCD the following, and then Alduskkel the final night. However, this would still require d3x and Kdub to both be lynched before AT (since likely Ald would still JK Chinaman the next night, thus confirming him).

If that had happened, that would have been epically awesome, and AT should've been nominated for a scummy. But it didn't happen.

The other possible win for AT was if he had killed MCD Night 4.

I found it funny when Chinaman said there would have to be at least one scum in the following, and then listed everyone except Ald and himself, lol.

And yeah, maybe I should start mentioning the number of pages in PMs that I send out for replacements. Sorry, saberwolf, but you still could have checked to make sure the game wasn't impossibly long.

Thanks very much to all the replacements in this game; fortunately that was enough to get it running up to speed again.

[ODDin]

Wee, victory is ours!

I admit to not really following the game after I died, though. (I checked to see who was lynched / NKed and what the general status of the voting was, but didn't actually read through it - had lots of exams going.) Anybody care to briefly summarise what happened after my death?

I did notice hohum replacing himself, though. That's one big mental note right there.

[Kdub]

GG guys. This game started out somewhat boring, but ended up being really fun. Thanks for taking over the modding Crazy.

I was able to catch Khamisa pretty early, but AT had me completely fooled, and Kise had me somewhat fooled. Had AT managed to kill the doctor on N4, I think he could have won the game because both Chinaman and I were convinced he was town for pushing Kise's lynch. Bussing Kise at that point was a very bold move.

I did see through saber's gambit, but I didn't figure it to be a town gambit.

I'll post individual player comments later when I have more time.

[d3x]

Holy...freaking...crap! Lol!

So, the whole reason I went after Kise was my read on AT. If AT hadn't started in on Kise in p2041 I wouldn't have been on him at the end of D4, we probably would've lynched CM or saber, and we'd have gone into Endgame with a significantly weaker chance of winning. 2 Scum means that you can't really confirm anyone with the JK. *Whew* Thanks for that bus, AT!

gg all. Thanks for the replacement Mod, Crazy. And the PM Invite to join up.

[MadCrawdad]

Last night, after him getting hammered, I was wondering if AT was posting so many walls of text, in response, that he actually crashed the server.

GG, all.


Thanks to Crazy and all the replacements.

[AndyTony]

Good game, everyone.
===============
My single regret was the D3x NK.

Had I not been so rushy, and waited - - had I chosen to not do a NK, saber wouldn't have been confirmed town.
===============

@MCD
- Thanks for the kind words?

@Town
- It was fun, hope to play with you all again

@Scum
- Khamisa: We didn't get to know you, sorry for the bus.
- Kise: It was inevitable. It was either me distancing from you if

I

got lynched, or you securing my town immunity for being on two scum wagons.

I spoiled it with that bloody NK.
==============================================

6 Months down the drain... lol

[MadCrawdad]

@MCD
- Thanks for the kind words?

Nothing but, man. You played a great game.

Once you bussed Kham I couldn't do much but sit and bite my tongue. And then when you bussed Kise I really thought you were probably innocent then.

Hey, in that recent post on D5 where you referred to me an 'operator,' were you trying to signal to me that you knew I was doc?

[Alduskkel]

Didn't see AndyTony scum coming. I thought he was scum earlier, but by the end I was pretty convinced he was Town until he reacted so poorly to the winning plan, at which point it didn't matter.

Can't say my play was that great this game, but at the very least I was suspicious of Khamisa and Kise -- even if I wasn't on their wagons. And I think I made good JK choices.

I wish I had kept tunneling on AndyTony. Oh well.

@AndyTony: If you had just no-killed then you would have probably won.

[DeathRowKitty]

Man was I off...I'll just blame it on my lack of an attention span and my tendency to skim long posts in re-reads (or in tthis case, my first read). Well-played AT. After the Khamisa wagon, I stopped paying attention to you almost completely.

[Chinaman]

yeah, makes my post about betting the game on AT being town kinda really effing stupid. Good job AT, but see what happens when you mess with the d3x?

Anyway, good game, pretty crazy at the end.