Your Idea Mafia 2! Day 1 9/9

[Jackel98]

Because Childkiller and Kingmaker.

[Bert]

Hello Anatole!

Town died in one of my past Lucky games (been 4-5 months though) before they had a chance to say what role they discarded, and thus Scum was able to really easily fakeclaim without needing verification that said role actually existed. Here, with claims they'd be pigeonholed into fakeclaiming within a pool of claimed submissions.

I had no intention of claiming submissions until I saw that claiming scum submission plus perhaps more worked in a past game I didn't participate in.

VOTE: Who

Who is scum? Yes, yes he is.

[Anatole Kuragin]

VOTE: Who

[kabooooom]

I summited alien mass redirector.
also the guy who claimed he did too, is lying.

and can anyone list all the scum roles submited till now?

[kabooooom]

vote:siveure

[Guyett]

I summited alien mass redirector.
also the guy who claimed he did too, is lying.

and can anyone list all the scum roles submited till now?

why is he scum for claiming submitting that too?

[All is Who]

Scum roles claimed so far:
Alien Psychotrooper
Alien Mass Redirector
Vanilla Alien
One-shot Goomaker
Lyncher
Mafia Lover
Mafia One-shot Dayvig (Shinobi said he submitted 3 dayvigs, and it's the only scum dayvig)
Werewolf

People who have yet to claim their submission: Guyett

And now time to claim our town submissions: Childkiller and Black Goo

[Guyett]

I submitted mafia day vig, town day vig and bloodhound. Same as last game

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

Okay.

I got the roles that screw with ICs (like everyone else) and kings.

Also kabooom, why do you think I'm lying?

Idk what I mean by anyway. Probably nothing.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Whoops, I forgot I had to get rid of lyncher for a town role because I had that and alpha werewolf.

My scum role submitted is actually alpha werewolf, not lyncher.

[OkaPoka]

pgo and vengeful

[kabooooom]

Okay.


Also kabooom, why do you think I'm lying?

.

cos you are. More later.

and why are many players saying their send town roles?!

[Jackel98]

Some could really mess with town.

[Anatole Kuragin]

It's dumb to tell mafia we have most of these. Really shit play to spell out all of the town's weapons.

[Shinobi]

Hello Anatole!

Town died in one of my past Lucky games (been 4-5 months though) before they had a chance to say what role they discarded, and thus Scum was able to really easily fakeclaim without needing verification that said role actually existed. Here, with claims they'd be pigeonholed into fakeclaiming within a pool of claimed submissions.

I had no intention of claiming submissions until I saw that claiming scum submission plus perhaps more worked in a past game I didn't participate in.

VOTE: Who

Who is scum? Yes, yes he is.

Why is he scum?

Some question directed at you, Anatole.

[Shinobi]

*Same.

[All is Who]

and why are many players saying their send town roles?!

It limits the scum's options when fakeclaiming. Also, the negative utility submissions (For example, Childkiller) should definitely be claimed for obvious reasons.

~Armageddon

[Anatole Kuragin]

Hello Anatole!

Town died in one of my past Lucky games (been 4-5 months though) before they had a chance to say what role they discarded, and thus Scum was able to really easily fakeclaim without needing verification that said role actually existed. Here, with claims they'd be pigeonholed into fakeclaiming within a pool of claimed submissions.

I had no intention of claiming submissions until I saw that claiming scum submission plus perhaps more worked in a past game I didn't participate in.

VOTE: Who

Who is scum? Yes, yes he is.

Why is he scum?

Some question directed at you, Anatole.

a) because bert is a hero
b) these guys are the most obnoxious kind of hydra

[Anatole Kuragin]

that doesn't make them scum, but it does make them annoying.

[Shinobi]

UNVOTE: Bert
VOTE: Jackel98

[OkaPoka]

I like my submissions.

[Jackel98]

@Shinobi: Why vote me over Bert?

[Shinobi]

I was going to say that you were putting too much emphasis on setup stuff, but I realized that wasn't true and that I should've read the first page.

Do you believe that Bert is a good vote at this point? Why?

[Jackel98]

I don't think that Bert is a good vote at this point. I also don't think I am a good vote. Bert's reasoning is sound, and it also seems to me to be town. There are other, better votes, such as Anatole, for putting at All is Who at L-1 with no reasoning, warning, or telling us that it was L-1.
UNVOTE: Guyett
VOTE: Anatole Kuragin

[Shinobi]

I'm okay with this new wagon. I can also point out that Anatole doesn't even believe that Who is scum, but still thinks it's okay to do all the things Jackel listed.

UNVOTE: Jackel98
VOTE: Anatole Kuragin