Song Contest U-Pick - GAME OVER

[notscience]

Why are they not in your strongest townreads then

[notscience]

^@morph

[Desperado]

But T-Bone sounds so genuine here...

[50 Shades of Purple]

But T-Bone sounds so genuine here...

[50 Shades of Purple]

Don't you dare, Desperado.

[T-Bone]

Then what? If 50 Shades isn't scum then what happened? I feel like I am reading all my information correctly. To me, nothing about what I know suggests I am wrong on this.

[Desperado]

Don't you dare, Desperado.

Why is scum T-Bone gambiting here? When they can just kill you at night and he isn't in danger of being lynched.

[Garruk Relentless]

I'm with Desperado here.

[Garruk Relentless]

I need both of you to fullclaim though.

[morph the cat]

Why are they not in your strongest townreads then

Their placement was part tactical, part annoyance. Seeing t-bone's claim crystallized some stuff that didn't really require crystallization.

[Desperado]

You tease

[morph the cat]

Then what? If 50 Shades isn't scum then what happened? I feel like I am reading all my information correctly. To me, nothing about what I know suggests I am wrong on this.

Sanity, maybe. hidden miller maybe.

I spun through possibilities and scenarios when a player I was pretty sure was a town PR faked a guilty on me recently. My willingness to consider those possibilities, including that he was town, faking, and had that much arrogance and hubris about his ability to read me vs the ability of the other town players to correctly sort me, and not scream from the rafters about lynching his lying ass contributed massively to my mislynch.

I was right. He was faking a guilty He was a town PR, though not a cop. I was mislynched.

I'm not getting a faking-the-guilty vibe from you so I'm thinking even harder about mechanics that could lead to your result.

[Desperado]

This is definitely not Space Mafia II: Wake's Revenge.

[notscience]

This is definitely not Space Mafia II: Wake's Revenge.

I laughed so hard at this

[T-Bone]

And then in that game you(them) lynched the fake-claiming player afterwards right? Which accomplished net-zero for the town. If you fake-claim you might as well be playing against your win condition.

[Generic]

Let's just fucking mass claim and end this nightmare of 'meh'.

Most of the supposed town PRs are outed and if we see a number of roles that don't balance in a game like this we know something if amiss. Otherwise we will have a list of claimed VTs and the supposed town block can start to fucking show me they are worthy of all this faith and trust.

Because right now we are mid swirl in the toilet of our chances of a win, how about we avoid the courtesy flush and ducking ndil a scumbag to the wall, unless snyone sees reason to cry... I mean object?

I AM A VANILLA TOWN. Hello.

[DeasVail]

As for DV today, his insistence of waiting for 50 Shades to do stuff this day phase suggested to me that he is with 50 Shades, and was trying to encourage them to get back here and start defending themselves. If he's scum with 50 Shades he would know about the night actions 50 Shades was doing and thanks to our argument Day 2 would be in the best position to try and cast doubt on anything I might try to do.

I think it was obvious that I knew you were crumbing something and was waiting for Purple to come back so that they could say what they did last night, but whatever. I feel like T-Bone was being incredibly dense about my reaction to him early Day 3 (again I thought it was very obvious that my uncertainty came about because of his 'share to the class' question), moreso than I'd expect from a PR who'd normally watch out for people picking up on their crumbs, but I'm not in the state of mind to decide what to do now, so I'll have a think tonight.

I'm very sorry to everyone for being so disconnected lately.

[morph the cat]

This is definitely not Space Mafia II: Wake's Revenge.

Don't say stuff like this. PTSD is a thing.
]

And then in that game you(them) lynched the fake-claiming player afterwards right? Which accomplished net-zero for the town. If you fake-claim you might as well be playing against your win condition.

Yep. Town lost at lylo. I don't think town could have pulled it off, but without that bullshit at least one scum player would have been lynched.

Which is why this makes no sense for you to do as scum. So, I'm thinking about how we test this without risking a mislynch of a town asset if there are role mechanics involved in a bad result.

Hi, this is ffery, who places strong reads ahead of nearly everything else in a game state.

Cabd is yelling at me about bastard roles. He'll probably make a post shortly and then we'll be dissonant for a while.

[T-Bone]

As for DV today, his insistence of waiting for 50 Shades to do stuff this day phase suggested to me that he is with 50 Shades, and was trying to encourage them to get back here and start defending themselves. If he's scum with 50 Shades he would know about the night actions 50 Shades was doing and thanks to our argument Day 2 would be in the best position to try and cast doubt on anything I might try to do.

I think it was obvious that I knew you were crumbing something and was waiting for Purple to come back so that they could say what they did last night, but whatever. I feel like T-Bone was being incredibly dense about my reaction to him early Day 3 (again I thought it was very obvious that my uncertainty came about because of his 'share to the class' question), moreso than I'd expect from a PR who'd normally watch out for people picking up on their crumbs, but I'm not in the state of mind to decide what to do now, so I'll have a think tonight.

I'm very sorry to everyone for being so disconnected lately.

I suspected you picked up on it. Most everyone else seemed oblivious or not noticing what was going on, so I was very interested in what you were going to do about it. I explained what I thought you were doing about it. So what were you trying to do about it?

[Porkens]

I'm a doctor. I saved Majiffy night 1. I saved Desp night 2.

[morph the cat]

Cabd is yelling at me about bastard roles. He'll probably make a post shortly and then we'll be dissonant for a while.

Is it possible your game has any of the following: cults, mid-game alignment changes, moderator lies that cannot be reasonably anticipated (for example, Godfather, Tailor, Miller, Ninja, and mechanics like that are generally fine. Telling someone they are a reflexive doctor when they're actually a PGO is not), secret win conditions, un-divulged non-randomness in player role/alignment generation, direct moderator influence during the game? - No.

[Generic]

unvote

Vote will fall on a VT.

[Generic]

Would scum have day chat?

[Generic]

Hang on... Majiffy night 1?

Majiffy?

[notscience]

If Porkens is legit scum have a RB andor ninja