Doctor Who Mafia 2- GAME OVER!

[Battle Mage]

I take note, Axel, of you leaving me to flop in the wind as ABR claimed "the Doctor".

But I dont blame you. Your role was good to keep hidden at that point and I was definitely expendable.

Yeah, at the time i was impressed by the way Axelrod handled the situation. I reckon most lesser players would have directly pushed for an ABR lynch, but Axelrod almost seemed to defend him! That was pretty inspired.

As for extra role info, Caps was a normal Doctor. Pooky was killed when he tried to recruit scum (Yos2).

for the record, the Sonic Screwdriver had additional uses than bringing the masons together. Had you targetted Korlash (The Master) you would have been informed that he is a TimeLord. Had you targetted anyone who has travelled in the TARDIS, youd have been told that thay were a companion.

BM

[cicero]

And just to confirm: I was CPR variant Quack, right? i.e. If Fonz and I targetted someone on the same night, I would protect them.

[Battle Mage]

And just to confirm: I was CPR variant Quack, right? i.e. If Fonz and I targetted someone on the same night, I would protect them.

No lol. You were Quack variant Quack. If you target someone, you kill them. If Fonz targets them aswell, they die twice as painfully. lol

BM

[Xtoxm]

I probably mislead you by claiming vanilla.

[Shanba]

I probably mislead you by claiming vanilla.

Yers...

All credit to Axelrod, his actions directly led to the damage limitation of the townies fakeclaiming.

[Shanba]

Oh, on a sidenote, did the scum have safeclaims? It looked like it right up until Yos screwed up his claim.

[cicero]

And just to confirm: I was CPR variant Quack, right? i.e. If Fonz and I targetted someone on the same night, I would protect them.

No lol. You were Quack variant Quack. If you target someone, you kill them. If Fonz targets them aswell, they die twice as painfully. lol

BM

Well then, I don't know what your reasoning was behind our conversation. I also dont understand the reasoning behind your draconian deadline enforcement.

Good game but I recommend you be much less stringent with night choices in future. In games where I am scum, 48 hours is barely time to get my scumbuddies onto the Quickboard once.

[cicero]

I shouldnt end on the "but" though. I thought it was a good fun setup. I'd like to play another BM run game. It's the kind of game I like. Lots of powers and kills.

[PokerFace]

Yes I too enjoyed this game and its pension for bloodshed.

1 Cultkiller, 1 SK, 1 Mafia Group, 1 Vig, 1 Vengeful Townie, 1 joat, 1 quack doc and a cult recruiter that died if he recruited scum.

This game needs anger management for its incredibly violent nature.

[cicero]

It made the game move quicker. That's why I liked it.

[Kison]

How wild would it have been if two of those other night one kills had hit scum? Ending a huge game like this after one day of playing would have been awesome/crazy.

[Adel]

I totally thought I was going to be able to go the distance as scum in this game. Who killed me?

[cicero]

I did.

You couldnt account for a townside quack doc who thought you were the one most worthy of protection.

What did your encripted PM say? Did you two have safe claims?

[PokerFace]

How wild would it have been if two of those other night one kills had hit scum? Ending a huge game like this after one day of playing would have been awesome/crazy.

hmm. Could it have ended in 1 day?

Hypothetical Example

Night 0

Cultkiller hits Mafia Goon 1
SK hits Mafia Godfather
Mafia hits SK
Cult Recruiter recruits Mafia X
Joat hits Mafia Goon 2
Vig hits Mafia Doc
Quack Doc hits Cult Killer
Mafia doc protected the only mafia that did not get targeted
Doc and jailer don't effect any of this

Day 1

We lynch Mafia Goon 3.

Holy Crap! It could have ended in one day!

[Kison]

Throw in a modkill and it could've ended before it began.

...Only in a Battle Mage game... HAHA

[Erg0]

Wow, it feels like ages since I've actually lived to the end of a game. Even though this was a bit flukey, I'll take it.

I had great fun in this game, the setup was certainly conducive to drama. I don't know whether to be happy or sad that I targeted scum for the double vote three times - although I was trying to use it more as a pressure tool (i.e. bringing focus on a player) than as an actual benefit. Maybe my instincts are better than I thought.

[PokerFace]

I don't think your double vote choices were too bad.

Using the double vote to test people is not such a bad idea. Its "kinda" like being a kingmaker.

[Yosarian2]

MY VISION IS IMPAIRED
I CANNOT SEE
MY VISION IS IMPAIRED

(cough)

Good game, everyone. Yeah, we were in pretty deep trouble after Caps double-crossed us back on day 1; that prety much took out eveyone in the scumgroup except me. And man, but I got unlucky on that claim, considering that there were only two people left who hadn't claimed, heh. Oh well; I could have arranged it so I claimed last, but I was pretty much doomed no matter what at that point, I think.

[cicero]

Yeah, Yos. You were in a no win situation regardless. But the luck on that claim was ridiculous. I can understand you not wanting to bother after getting screwed over by the somethingawful jackasses.

[Shanba]

So you didn't have safeclaims?

Wow, talk about ballsy scumplay from Adel, then. Kudos.

[Battle Mage]

And just to confirm: I was CPR variant Quack, right? i.e. If Fonz and I targetted someone on the same night, I would protect them.

No lol. You were Quack variant Quack. If you target someone, you kill them. If Fonz targets them aswell, they die twice as painfully. lol

BM

Well then, I don't know what your reasoning was behind our conversation. I also dont understand the reasoning behind your draconian deadline enforcement.

Good game but I recommend you be much less stringent with night choices in future. In games where I am scum, 48 hours is barely time to get my scumbuddies onto the Quickboard once.

Draconian? 0.o
If you mean strict, i like to play by the rules to set an example for players. And i hate games that grow stale.

Fyi, had there been a scumgroup remaining, id probably have kept the deadlines at 72 hours.

BM

[cicero]

Even as it was the deadlines were just a bit two short. I would have been happier with 72 hours. If that's the norm, all the better.

[Battle Mage]

Throw in a modkill and it could've ended before it began.

...Only in a Battle Mage game... HAHA

rofl!

[Battle Mage]

Wow, it feels like ages since I've actually lived to the end of a game. Even though this was a bit flukey, I'll take it.

I had great fun in this game, the setup was certainly conducive to drama. I don't know whether to be happy or sad that I targeted scum for the double vote three times - although I was trying to use it more as a pressure tool (i.e. bringing focus on a player) than as an actual benefit. Maybe my instincts are better than I thought.

lol yeh i noticed that too. Me and Jordan spent many an afternoon chuckling over a cuppa about your choices

BM

[Battle Mage]

MY VISION IS IMPAIRED
I CANNOT SEE
MY VISION IS IMPAIRED

(cough)

Good game, everyone. Yeah, we were in pretty deep trouble after Caps double-crossed us back on day 1; that prety much took out eveyone in the scumgroup except me. And man, but I got unlucky on that claim, considering that there were only two people left who hadn't claimed, heh. Oh well; I could have arranged it so I claimed last, but I was pretty much doomed no matter what at that point, I think.

Yeah, i thought you did well considering. I mean, you had already been OUTTED by your buddy, and yet i think the rest of the town just forgot to look back. You were never really going to win unless you hit perfect night choices and a perfect safeclaim. lol
It was a more a case of making a game of it.

And some scum had safeclaims, some didnt.

Pooky/Adel had the safeclaim 'Ricky Smith', and Korlash had the safeclaim 'Rose Tyler'.

BM