Mini 1578: Lord of the Rings!! - GaME OVeR

[Freja]

@Bulbazak: I think one of the scummiest things you have done after the wagon is your attempts to discredit people who disagreed with the Reinoe lynch. For example, you go after Proto for his "lack of experience" and insist he listen to the "more experienced" players who know how obvscum Reinoe's claim was.

So, I have 3 statements/questions for you:
1) I have WAY more experience than most of this playerlist, and yet I see the wagon as incredibly shitty. Additionally, I think town would admit that they fucked up, and try to move on from it, rather than do their utmost to prove to people that "you were in the right," so to speak. Anyone who was actually right about Reinoe becomes suspicious (which is idiotic for numerous reasons), and anyone who was wrong is "justified."

2) Who the hell are you to dictate what a player ought to think? Who the hell is Guyett to try to get me to move onto a vote I disagree with? Trying to convince someone of the value of a lynch through case work is fine, but not when it becomes a

demand.

3) Since when has just listening to people with "experience" been a good strategy? Seriously, its like newbie game 101 to challenge people and their beliefs regardless of their alleged skill.

[Guyett]

Who the hell is Guyett to try to get me to move onto a vote I disagree with? Trying to convince someone of the value of a lynch through case work is fine, but not when it becomes a

demand.

That was my bad, when I first read the following post I assumed the but at the bottom was referring to the post immediately before it which was a Proto post.

sigh...I didn't sign up for a troll game, people.

Firstly, Dr. Pants and I will be writing as a unit. If there is a sudden change in tone/writing style, its probably because a different person is writing. But we will be collaborating before submitting things.

@Reinoe: I have been at L-1 in almost every game I've played, and I rarely get lynched. Your attitude is bull, and unless you have a good reason for it role wise, you should be getting modkilled.

@Bulbazak: Please stop with your "I will not explain anything I do, but I will declare the allignments I think people have. Without any reasoning." And if you complain about how its your play-style, then you should change your play-style. A failure to explain ones reads only results in an inability for town to judge intent/motivation behind a read, and a lack of knowledge as to why a person may be considered scummy

Also, why did you respond to feel the need to respond to Reinoe's questions with something that can be summed up with "I disagree?"

Lastly, Reinoe's role claim was obviously idiotic, but for you to immediately react with "oh, this guy's lynch can help scum!" VOTE, without even the consideration that 1) its Reinoe we're talking about here, 2) it could be a gambit, 3) he may actually

want

to get lynched (think "the One Ring" in some of the other LOTR themed mafia games), warrants suspicion. Same goes for Aronis.

@Toogeloo: Neither of us do meta, so fuck that. Also, no. We do not know if Frodo is or is not in the game, and there is no point trying to break via flavor D1. Scum could have Frodo as a fake claim, scum could have

all

the hobbits as fake claims, or they could be a horde of nameless orcs--my point is, its irrelevant and idk why this discussion is coming up.

Proto is scum, btw.

Maybe, but you certainly are.

PEDIT: omg. Pants and I both agree, that last post is SCUMSCUMSCUMSCUM

[Guyett]

the bit at the bottom not the but at the bottom

[Guyett]

But I strongly disagree that I

demanded

you move your vote to proto

[Guyett]

That is a fucking misrep

[Dr Pants]

this is the other head, but the "demand" bit was more in context with Bulba, not you. that being said, an argument could be made where you saying "you should join the proto wagon, staying on the bulba wagon is unwise" is a bit of a threat, but it makes more sense when you read our "SCUMSCUMSCUM" as being directed towards Proto when we intended it to be directed towards Bulba.

[Freja]

this is the other head, but the "demand" bit was more in context with Bulba, not you. that being said, an argument could be made where you saying "you should join the proto wagon, staying on the bulba wagon is unwise" is a bit of a threat, but it makes more sense when you read our "SCUMSCUMSCUM" as being directed towards Proto when we intended it to be directed towards Bulba.

@ mod: please delete previous post

[Guyett]

why do you assume I'm townreading bulba?
How well do you know LOTR

[Guyett]

Like I've been dropping all sorts of hints as to who I am... and I really don't care who knows

[Freja]

lol i know who you are, you're right that its pretty obvious

tell me, what good is a phone call when you are unable to speak?

[Drew-Sta]

I sware to god this town is so fucking stupid. So is the goal to get as many mislynches as possible as fast as possible? Because I must say, you're doing pretty good.

Why are you referring to town in the third person, somewhat indicating you aren't part of them?

Why the face palm?

BTW, much hangover. Wow.

[Toogeloo]

Context of the word town. Townspeople and Mafiaosi are all a collective of the "Town."

Elrond could be a fake claim being sowed early to buy credit later. Not gonna use hints as a way to justify towniness.

Rach still avoids being proactive, so I am still confident in my stance.


I haven't yet felt that Proto is scummy. His behavior about WKing Reinoe seems fine enough given the time frame at which it happened, after Reinoe self hammered,
I also haven't yet seen the case on Bulba being scum. I feel like it's basically town v. town here, especially considering how stale the rest of the content seems to be.


At least one Scum lie within here, and I wouldn't be surprised if more:
RachMarie ***
snscompt1 **
FailHydra *
ThreeToMango *

*s represent my confidence level.

I feel as though the above list consists of the least proactive players currently. Since I feel like Proto v. Bulba is town v. town, I get the impression these less proactive players are biding time.

[Guyett]

lol i know who you are, you're right that its pretty obvious

tell me, what good is a phone call when you are unable to speak?

If you knew why did you think I was threatening ? I was obviously paraphrasing an Elrond quote

[snscompt1]

Prod dodge because technically Im not V/LA, just on mobile til tomorrow night. I hate reading walls while on mobile.

[Freja]

If you knew why did you think I was threatening ? I was obviously paraphrasing an Elrond quote

I knew but my other head didn't, and he's who made that statement. This is where hydras get kinda confusing. He asked me about it last night after I replyed. My reply btw was a quote from Agent Smith from the Matix, who is played by the actor who plays Elrond.

[Drew-Sta]

You're claiming Elrond, eh Freja?

[Freja]

no, Guyett is

[Protogonos]

May we please stop discussing roles? May we also vote Aronis, please?

[Guyett]

What roles have been discussed?

[Toogeloo]

Now that I've got your attention....
...vote RachMarie please.

[Freja]

@Guyett: Maybe demand wasn't the right word, but it was still coercive. And that was sort of the point of that point. Instead of trying to prove your reads, you and Bulba are both being manipulative.

And yeah, I have much less LOTR knowledge than Dr Pants. If you were bread-crumbing, it doesn't change my point.

@Toog: no. RachMarie's annoyance to the questions about her reads genuine town. I also disagree with your FailHydra read. I can see Mango or sns being scum, though.
Also could you not with the bouncing tits? I know it was in good fun and I'm sure someone here appreciates it, but if I wanted to see that right now I'd go watch some porn.

[Guyett]

@Toog that sure sounds like someone

demanded

you stop posting bouncing boobs.

It kind of does as the quote you took offence too was a fucking breadcrumb not me threating you to move your vote

[Toogeloo]

if I wanted to see that right now I'd go watch some porn.

Just come back later when you're ready for porn.

[shos]

boobs!
eh, I mean, bump.

[shos]

whoopsiedaisy, anotherbump