Mini Normal 608 - Game Over

[Gimbo]

okay, i am gonna do a read of the entire game and see what i come up with

[Gimbo]

After reading the first 6 page, my conclusions:

skitzer - most likely not scum, he voted for Slaine in the beginning of Slaine's wagon, which would seem out of place if skitzer is scum

Corinthian - generally uninterested in helping town find scum....possible scumtell?

Cavebear, big

FoS

-you claimed jokingly in the beginning of Day 1 Slaine is obv. scum (post 35) and then after that, you completely ignored Slaine in your discussions, which is really weird....you also happen to be on my wagon since the start. and also you asked me to claim at L-3 and when I asked what you will do if i did claim and my claim is cop/doc, you failed to give a reasonable response. i realized i've FoSed you before, there must have been some good reasons....

Gojira/FFB - need to post more stuff.

so right now IF Dattebayo is telling the truth, I want a

Cavebear lynch

also...

Wow, that was a quick day 2. Not like I'm compaining, though....

I'm happy enough to go with Dattebayo today, especially given how well we're doing.

Vote: Dattebayo

minorFoS:Gojira

[Gojira]

...Gimbo, Cavebear died two nights ago. He was a vanilla townie.

I'm the doc.

Easy enough claim to make... I doubt we'll hear a counterclaim, as that'd be exposing the doc for any remaining scum, but I wouldn't think we'd have two docs. Also conveniently an unproveable claim...

[XReyoX]

Dattebayo (3): Gojira, Corinthian, Gimbo

Not voting (4): Phoebus, skitzer,FlyingFoxBat *, Dattebayo

4 votes to lynch

[Corinthian]

Skitzer, I'm a him.

I don't like Dattebayo's doc claim.

Easy enough claim to make... I doubt we'll hear a counterclaim, as that'd be exposing the doc for any remaining scum, but I wouldn't think we'd have two docs. Also conveniently an unproveable claim...

QFT

Also, remember there was no guarantee that this game was balanced. We might not have a doc at all. (It could even be a safeclaim for scum.)

I'm keeping my vote on Dattebayo. He's been scummy from the beginning, and I think this doc claim is a trick.

[Dattebayo]

I'm keeping my vote on Dattebayo. He's been scummy from the beginning, and I think this doc claim is a trick.

Um. I don't think you said I was scummy before. I'd also appreciate the chance to respond to a case.

[Corinthian]

Dattebayo was scummy all D1. His vote for Slaine was an obvious bus.

As to his doc claim:

vote: #44

Tomorrow = Dattebayo

Why the hell would Dattebayo choose to protect Phoebus N2?

[skitzer]

Gojira, I reckon Gimbo meant Corinthian. They both start with Cs.

But Corinthian makes a good point.

[Gimbo]

...Gimbo, Cavebear died two nights ago. He was a vanilla townie.

I'm the doc.

Easy enough claim to make... I doubt we'll hear a counterclaim, as that'd be exposing the doc for any remaining scum, but I wouldn't think we'd have two docs. Also conveniently an unproveable claim...

lol, i feel sooo retarded right now.......anyways

Unvote Vote:Dattebayo

[Dattebayo]

Why the hell would Dattebayo choose to protect Phoebus N2?

Most of the town thought he was town which would make him an optimal NK target.

[Dattebayo]

His vote for Slaine was an obvious bus.

How so?

[Corinthian]

I think Phoebus said it best.

dattebayo agrees with me re Slaine.
However, he sticks with a FoS on him. Throws one out at Cave for good measure.
he agrees with my thoughts on Slaine and those thoughts include my statement regarding Gimbo.
yet....dattebayo is still voting Gimbo but points FoS at Slaine.

So easy to bus him with...at a later point...when Gimbo turns out pro town.
But then...1 for 1 might not be a bad deal...
Eh dattescum?

Dattebayo voted Gimbo, whose meta is apparently always scummy, and switched to Slaine when it became clear that the town was turning in that direction. He's seemed eager to join whatever wagon he can.

(Where is Phoebus anyway?)

[Dattebayo]

Dattebayo voted Gimbo, whose meta is apparently always scummy, and

switched to Slaine when it became clear that the town was turning in that direction.

He's seemed eager to join whatever wagon he can.

You forgot to mention that I caught him lying.

[Phoebus]

Phoebus had to move unexpectedly and is ill... so bear with him.


Corinthian...are you contesting the claim that Dattebayo has come up with?
This appears to be an extremely normal game...from where i stand...and with no one counterclaiming...despite his scuminess....can't really fault dattebayo for now

yes, I'm 2 on 2 for evil but my connection hypothesis was slightly incorrect.

at this time...i'm going to

vote: skitzer

for his "his claim sounds iffy' bit - what was that about? please explain... 44 had claimed Sk...

Following skitzer on the list is Gojira.


This might not be a bad time for a cop to reveal innocent targets, if they are still alive.
if we can confirm what stands around in this game...we could wrap it up outright...

of course

if cop targets are dead, he should

keep quiet

don't want anyone missing the obvious...

[Corinthian]

Okay, let's do this thing.

I am a cop.

Night One I investigated skitzer, because he was suspicious of me early on. Result: INNOCENT

Night Two I chose Dattebayo, because the general town consensus was that he was scummiest. Result: GUILTY

[Gimbo]

yeaa!!!, but IF Corinthian is the scum, what are the repercussions?

How close are we to LyLo ??

otherwise okay, Dattebayo's dead.

[XReyoX]

21 days remaining

Dattebayo (3): Gojira, Corinthian, Gimbo
skitzer (1): Phoebus

Not voting (3): skitzer,FlyingFoxBat **, Dattebayo

4 votes to lynch

FlyingFoxBat has been prodded

[skitzer]

at this time...i'm going to vote: skitzer for his "his claim sounds iffy' bit - what was that about? please explain... 44 had claimed Sk...

Any anti-town claim is usually really WIFOMy...ths one wasn't, but still, It kind of stirred my thoughts a little bit.

How close are we to LyLo ??

I'm looking at it this way: So far we have lynched a Mafia Godfather and a Serial Killer. An average Mini game, with a serial killer, has approximately 2-3 Mafia.

So, looking at the worst case scenario, which is 3 scum and an SK, still living are:

2 Scum
5 Town

So If we lynch incorrectly and there is a night kill:

2 Scum
3 Town

which is Lylo. But then we'll lynch obvscum Corinthian, and if suffer another night kill:

1 Scum
2 Town

But if we look at 2 scum and an SK, things are way different, living are:

1 Scum
6 Town

Lynching incorrectly and a nightkill would put us at:
1 Scum
4 Town

And then another lynch and Nightkill would put us at LyLo.

On the Corinthian claim: If there are multiple scum, (no offense to Corinthian here) but I don't think they would have the time to think it out and weight their chances. Of course, If Corinthian is the only scum left, It wouldn't make sense because after we lynch Dattebayo today and he turns out to be a doc or town of some sort (which wouldn't make sense because he lied about his claim if he's not doc), Corinthian is our prime target tomorrow.

So, I'm going to say that Dattebayo is probably scum. If not, Corinthian is either lying or random, because I know I'm innocent.

So with that, screwdriver, saw, wrench....HAMMER!

Vote: Dattebayo

[XReyoX]

Day 3 Final Vote count

Dattebayo (4): Gojira, Corinthian, Gimbo, skitzer
skitzer (1): Phoebus

Not voting (2): FlyingFoxBat **, Dattebayo

4 votes to lynch

---

Dattebayo [Mafia Roleblocker] has been lynched

---

Night 3

Please send in your night choices, if any, in 72 hours.

[XReyoX]

---

Phoebus [Mason] has been killed

---

It is now Day 4

24 days remaining

---

[Gimbo]

shit Mason-Pheebz is dead, nooo!!!!!!

FlyingFoxBat didn't vote, something still isn't right about Gojira...maybe his avatar ? lol

Anyways, how is Corinthian not dead, did a doctor protect him? is there even a doctor?

Anyway

Vote:FlyingFoxBat

[Gimbo]

I've looked at the last 4 pages and FlyingFoxBat hasn't made a single post, despite not being replaced.

Looking back, its weird to see that Dattebayo was on Slaine's wagon extremely early on, so I think the scums in this game could be distancing via killing each other so that only one remains. In that case, Corinthian is still not off the hook yet.

I doubt Gojira being scum, and skitzer's case is only a bit stronger than Gojira but most likely not scum (based on my overall feel of the game; last few pages)

That leaves Corinthian, I'm still VERY puzzled how he is not dead..

I say we give FFB a chance to defend himself and ask Corinthian about his last night's investigation.

[Gimbo]

mod: please prod FFB

[XReyoX]

FlyingFoxBat has received a prod on Day3, Gimbo.

[Gimbo]

ok, sorry, lets hammer FFB, that lurking mothafucka.