Mini Theme 2158: Cards of Destiny Mafia Game Over

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

Kaname Date has died during the night.

Spoiler: “You will come to know that what appears to be a sacrifice will prove instead to be the greatest investment you will ever make.”

Welcome Kaname Date you are

The Hanged Man

You are a Suicidal doctor/conditional cop sided with with the Town

Abilities:

You start the game with a counter of 5 The counter will go down by 1 every night
Every night you may protect a player. If you choose to do the counter will go down by 1
When you die you may pick a player you have previously protected. Their alignment will be revealed to the public.

Flavor Leaf has been revealed as aligned with

the Mafia

Day 4 will end in: (expired on 2020-10-03 04:00:00)

Kaname Date has died during the night.

Spoiler: “You will come to know that what appears to be a sacrifice will prove instead to be the greatest investment you will ever make.”

Welcome Kaname Date you are

The Hanged Man

You are a Suicidal doctor/conditional cop sided with with the Town

Abilities:

You start the game with a counter of 5 The counter will go down by 1 every night
Every night you may protect a player. If you choose to do the counter will go down by 1
When you die you may pick a player you have previously protected. Their alignment will be revealed to the public.

Flavor Leaf has been revealed as aligned with

the Mafia

Day 4 will end in: (expired on 2020-10-03 04:00:00)

AHH man 112 pages read, this was my verdict too

VOTE: Flavor Leaf

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

Sorry jjh, I thought KD had the high priestess card, so probably FL has it then. FL killed Amy btw, so your 3P scim theory was wtong.

~Mars

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

You hear something in the middle of the night:

I'm hiding behind the fool. If I die, that can only be because either FL lied (unlikely here) or because FL got killed. In that scenario, Kaname Date is scum.
My unlikely death aside, KD and FL are probably my POE. Woulda hid behind KD if I knew their arcana.
It's talk like a pirate day now. Arr

You and Amy are the main reasons we won this. Brilliant strategy but KD was bleeding obvtown. I don’t know why she suspected you though. Had I had the hanged man card, I would have 100% known that FL was scum, so that was my main reason I thought it was you. FL has scum high priestess, bank on it.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

You hear something in the middle of the night:

I'm hiding behind the fool. If I die, that can only be because either FL lied (unlikely here) or because FL got killed. In that scenario, Kaname Date is scum.
My unlikely death aside, KD and FL are probably my POE. Woulda hid behind KD if I knew their arcana.
It's talk like a pirate day now. Arr

You and Amy are the main reasons we won this. Brilliant strategy but KD was bleeding obvtown. I don’t know why HE suspected you though. Had I had the hanged man card, I would have 100% known that FL was scum, so that was my main reason I thought it was you. FL has scum high priestess, bank on it.

~M

Sorry @KD, I just woke up.

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

Do you think we could have more than 3 scum?

No, me matey, FL is the last

Yep, Gamma claimed town devil on D2 and no one CC’d them and FL killed Amy, sp he played well around the anti-partnery thing but Amy was the actual target but Tris also was the one who killed her.

I got that mixed up, FL killed Pooky, Tris targeted and killed Amy.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

FL’s medium role is probably fake and I did get an actual guilty on him. I almost seriously considered TAing him again to test it to see if he suddenly got a negative and then we’d also know it was fake but he was aligned with DnD and Tris. @jjh I knew your 3P scum theory made no sense because of only 1 kill per night.

Who wants to take bets on which doppelgänger arcana FL is? Can’t wait for that. I’m actually going to guess hanged man, since it’s closest to fool.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

Do you think we could have more than 3 scum?

No, me matey, FL is the last

Yep, Gamma claimed town devil on D2 and no one CC’d them and FL killed Amy, sp he played well around the anti-partnery thing but Amy was the actual target but Tris also was the one who killed her.

I got that mixed up, FL killed Pooky, Tris targeted and killed Amy.

~M

Tris knew Amy was self-redirector, because she also rolecopped Amy.

Tris neighbourized Alonzo/Hya, rolecopped Amy and killed Amy, that’s how we know FL killed Pooky.

I understand now why he wanted Gamma dead and tried so hard to save NM.

I think I should probably just assume FL is scum in every damn game going forward

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

When you die you may pick a player you have previously protected. Their alignment will be revealed to the public.

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

I think FL fucked up by killing KD regardless, because as soon as I saw his Arcana flip, I would have realized that jjh is town and FL scum. I thought KD was town high priestess, which was the main reason I wrongly suspected jjh, so Idk wtf FL was thinking here. KD was hands down the worst kill for scum to make here for that specific reason, so FL 100% sealed his fate with that kill.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

I think FL fucked up by killing KD regardless, because as soon as I saw his Arcana flip, I would have realized that jjh is town and FL scum. I thought KD was town high priestess, which was the main reason I wrongly suspected jjh, so Idk wtf FL was thinking here. KD was hands down the worst kill for scum to make here for that specific reason, so FL 100% sealed his fate with that kill.

~M

Iow, KD flipping anything other than high priestess would have confitowned jjh and confiscummed FL to me.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

I think FL fucked up by killing KD regardless, because as soon as I saw his Arcana flip, I would have realized that jjh is town and FL scum. I thought KD was town high priestess, which was the main reason I wrongly suspected jjh, so Idk wtf FL was thinking here. KD was hands down the worst kill for scum to make here for that specific reason, so FL 100% sealed his fate with that kill.

~M

Iow, KD flipping anything other than high priestess would have confitowned jjh and confiscummed FL to me.

~M

FL should have also realized that scum!jjh never kills KD here, not after Amy/Tris flips + Gamma town!devil claim proves my doppelgänger scum theory and FL is 100% based off of my Tris coroner results, a scum doppelgänger arcana and I’m guessing it very likely is hanged man.

~M

[Venus Mars and Pluto]

oh and thanks KD, nice pick.

If KD was actually pretending to suspect jjh and actually pulled another baby sitter on FL, that would be epic.

KD was bs in Boon TBoNTB which would make this especially ironic.

~M

[jjh927]

I feel like you got a lot of things confused and are making a lot of assumptions but we still win so w/e

[jjh927]

You're right that FL isn't the fool, which honestly I feel is a pretty dumb lie unless it's confirmed somewhere that duplicates are bad
And if all scum are duplicate arcana then that's kinda hmm for setup

[Nancy Drew 39]

I feel like you got a lot of things confused and are making a lot of assumptions but we still win so w/e

No, what things? DnD flipped scum devil, Gamma claimed town devil on D2. Amy flipped town lover, Tris flipped scum lover, so when KD strongly suspected tp you but didn’t want to reveal his arcana, I incorrectly assumed it was because he was exactly town high priestess.

The scumteam are 100% doppelgängers, bank on it. I just don’t know which one FL is yet but KD claiming anything other than exactly high priestess, would have made me realize that my solve was wrong and it 100% had to be FL because KD/Fish/Gamma was 99.99999% clear for different reasons and of course me/Alonzo were mech clear after Tris flip, so I would have correctly nailed scum!FL had I known he wasn’t actually high priestess.

[Nancy Drew 39]

You're right that FL isn't the fool, which honestly I feel is a pretty dumb lie unless it's confirmed somewhere that duplicates are bad
And if all scum are duplicate arcana then that's kinda hmm for setup

Which is exactly why, KD was absolutely the worst kill for FL to have made. Any other kill would have been better including a no kill. I think he didn’t kill us because he kbew we were coronering Tris, which would have obviously debunked your 3P scum theory.

Just to be clear, my Tris coroner results confirmed a 3 person scum team because Tris did not kill Pooky. That’s why I’m so convinced on the doppelgänger scum thing.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I think cards do have at least a loose tie to role, based on my own

Mechanics cleared Pooky.
In many ways actually.

I honestly would have townread them just because of play differences to another game

Also, just gonna put this out there that I have the same flavor as D&D, so flavor has no meaning.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I think cards do have at least a loose tie to role, based on my own

Mechanics cleared Pooky.
In many ways actually.

I honestly would have townread them just because of play differences to another game

Also,

just gonna put this out there that I have the same flavor as D&D

, so flavor has no meaning.

If FL isn’t a scum doppelgänger than Tris/Amy/DnD flips + Gamma town devil claim doesn’t really make a lot of sense.

[Flavor Leaf]

Lol, I no killed last night.

VOTE: Flavor Leaf
VOTE: Flavor Leaf

I was hoping Gamma Emerald would get revealed as town, because he was already getting confirmed because I roleblocked there, while hoping BEF commuted JJH.

I was gonna kill Nancy tonight, then do my best in a BEF/Hayasaka/FL world.

But yeah, this game was fun, but idk. I don’t necessarily feel it was too balanced.

[Flavor Leaf]

I killed Pooky because he was shredding my momentum day 1, and he made it obvious he was a confirmable townie.

We killed Kaname Date Night 2, but Ampharos redirected Tris.

[Flavor Leaf]

I did not kill Amy.

[Flavor Leaf]

I am the Fool.

[Flavor Leaf]

I am the Fool.

Let’s end this game. Kill me.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Had Amy also not have flipped scum redirector, I would have also suspected FL because of his medium claim and scum not killing him after that but Amy redirector thing, ironically deprived of us of that info, so it bit Tris in the butt either way but I would have been far less likely to tr FL if it weren’t for that because of the Tris neighbourizing both Alobzo/Hya and us, I thought there was a really decent chance that FL could have been the N2 NK, so Amy redirector flip actually helped FL.

[Flavor Leaf]

Super town sided, but yeah, fun nonetheless.