Mini 1452 - Inevitable Mafia (Game Over)

[DCLXVI]

No attempt to defend yourself?

Pedit., last words without a claim?

[Yates]

Last words:

lynch Rob13 and DCLXVI. Gorckat is town.

What do you think about TMT and CoolDog?

[RadiantCowbells]

TMT is town. Cooldog is probably scum.

Pedit., last words without a claim?

I am a compulsive JOAT with one commute, one nk, and one cop invest.

Town sucks dick though, so I am unmotivated to play this out.

[DCLXVI]

Anyone know if that qualifies as normal?

[DCLXVI]

@radiant why were you so concerned with getting me lynched when you could have investigated me? Or shot/commuted later on?

[BROseidon]

Compulsive and JOAT are both normal, although commuter is not listed as a normal role. It's also not listed as an explicitly not normal role, so I don't know what to actually make of that.

[DCLXVI]

Ignore the commuter part, I forgot how it worked.

[RadiantCowbells]

@radiant why were you so concerned with getting me lynched when you could have investigated me? Or shot/commuted later on?

hurdur

Dont like the lack of dcl lynch selling being done. Lots of focus on others

game too hard

[DCLXVI]

Not sure how that was supposed to my point.

[RadiantCowbells]

I did stop being "concerned with getting you lynched" with the intention of investing tonight, so I start looking for the scum on my wagon, then Gorckat votes for me because I'm apparently ignoring my scumreads.

logic.

[Rob14]

That role makes no sense.

First off, I know that it is all normal from past experience. Commuters are a normal role.

Second, think about balance. A commuter shot would be put in to limit kills. A vig shot would be put in to increase kills. These are two opposite goals. In order to put this role into a setup, you would need to balance the entire setup around it - it would not help to balance anything. I'm thinking especially about the compulsive modifier. The only reason to tack on compulsive is to force the vig shot to be used. The goal of doing this is to weaken town power by removing the choice of whether or not to use the shot. BUT, if you seriously wanted to weaken town power, then you would never put the compulsive vig shot into a JOAT. It's very likely that the shot would never be used due to, well, exactly this. It would be much better to just remove the compulsive vig shot and take off an ability from the JOAT, making it just a 1-shot role, or reduce town power elsewhere.

This claim is not a role that would fly through a review process.

[roflcopter]

vote: rob

[roflcopter]

radiant is town, gorc is town, admiral is town

mason partner should claim today

[BROseidon]

rofl, can you give reasons for your anything?

[Rob14]

What led you to the conclusion that Radiant is town? I want a SINGLE thing that makes him seem even the SLIGHTEST like town.

P-edit: Yeah, that.

[jmo16mla]

My day one game sucks more than *insert favorite pornstar name here*

Il see what I can do.

[gorckat]

Radiant- I again request you replace out.

You don't want to play the game? Fine.

Stop being an ass and get the fuck out.

[RadiantCowbells]

Roflcopter seems awesome and his presence has reinspired me to work for the town win.

I'll post

role suck blah blah

More likely, the save is balanced around the shot and the invest going off, which would explain why commuter is in the list; if a claim is forced d1, I'm still not an obvious target. If you don't like the amount of power put onto a single role, take it up with kitoari, but if DCL really is a mason, my role probably exists for the purpose of confirming the masons. There are also likely no doctors or jailkeepers.


roflcopter seems awesome and his presence has reignited my interest in the game. I'm going to post my full ISOs of Rob13 and Cooldog to explain why I support their lynches.

VOTE: Rob13

For now. Get your votes off me and TMT, please.

[RadiantCowbells]

@Gorckat if I'm scum then my replacement will be scum too so your vote would stay where it is, and since you want me lynched you shouldn't care if I get replaced, no?

[roflcopter]

What led you to the conclusion that Radiant is town? I want a SINGLE thing that makes him seem even the SLIGHTEST like town.

P-edit: Yeah, that.

1) you railroading him

[BROseidon]

TMT wagon isn't going anywhere. I like the CoolDoG wagon more than the Rob one, though. Everything with how he's handled the DCL situation has been bad and scum motivated..

VOTE: CoolDoG

Pedit: What does railroading mean?

[gorckat]

@Gorckat if I'm scum then my replacement will be scum too so your vote would stay where it is, and since you want me lynched you shouldn't care if I get replaced, no?

Principle.

Explain your flop from 'masons no name partners Day 1' before DCL had even claimed to 'DCL name partner or die' recently.

[RadiantCowbells]

Quite frankly, I have never actually played with masons in a serious game, and how I felt they should be dealt with when potentially seeing them in action was different then how I actually felt about it.

[TMTOLBTWNTOF]

Because I am relatively new to me, explain to me the concept of doomed people getting reads.
If they are town, are we to trust them? If they are scum, are we to trust them?

TMT wagon isn't going anywhere. I like the CoolDoG wagon more than the Rob one, though. Everything with how he's handled the DCL situation has been bad and scum motivated..

Cooldog > Rob.

I want a vote count

[DCLXVI]

unvote

You know what, scum don't get extra kills. Radiant will have a chance to prove that she is who she says she is. I don't believe he, but two kills would prove that she isn't mafia.