In post 290, Mathdino wrote:
Riabi
: You already admitted that everyone is trying to scumhunt, so why does being willing to change opinions and have spot-on analysis townish exempt one from scummy behaviour? Check mastin's and 2birds's ISOs if you want to see the main issues people have with TGS.
I'm not saying that it exempts one from scummy behavior, but I feel like in this case, TGS's townish behavior outweighs his scummy behavior.
Probably town-ish? Not a strong read, but, he reads like the guy at the poker table who's really quiet and that you know if you're going to push him, you'd better have the cards. He seems confident, which seems to me to be out of place if he were a new-to-the-site scum. I know he's played other places before, but there's still a lot of cultural differences from playing in-person to playing here (or other sites, for that matter).
In post 296, guille2015 wrote:... The problem is that Oilura's hammer wasn't what was scummy, but rather Oiluras attempt to defend it. The hammer was simply bad play...
I think our views on Oilura's play are largely subjective (other than the fact we both agree it was bad). I think Oilura's hammer was scummy. I think the defense of it only made it worse, but I absolutely think the hammer itself was scummy. To me it felt like Oliura didn't like the way the discussion around the lynch was going, and wanted to end it before mastin or someone else had the chance to move the wagon somewhere else.
Hmmm, something pinged me as town on him earlier, but, he's one of the few I didn't actually ISO when I made my previous read post. Now that I've ISO'd him, I have to agree with you that he didn't contribute anything. He's now on my "probably scum" list. Not because of the frequency of the posts, but, the lack of content in what few posts there are. I'm guessing he'll be replaced soon (based on the fact that he's been prodded and we still haven't heard anything), so hopefully his replacement can help us shed some light on that slot.
So, to be clear, here is my current list:
Probably town: Mathdino, TGS
Leaning town: 2birds, Nova
Can't Tell: NJAC,
Leaning scum: Guille, dragonspawn
Probably scum: Oilura, Clusk