Two of the people who said they were most suspicious were wolves.In post 3472, Persivul wrote:I really don't get the D4 play. You guys took the time to vote on a claim order; put Ranger first, indicating that she was considered most suspicious; but then, when she was CC'd...you didn't lynch her...
You were right in my play was vastly different from other games but wrong in my alignment. I got lazy this game so I guess I deserved some of the scum reads towards me.In post 3470, mhsmith0 wrote:I guess I was right that duppins ranger vote was distancing after all, but I don't think we could ever have gotten all the way there. Solid job wolves selling the "camp a vs camp b" structure. I was trying to think through other options but that was super hard to figure out. Sorry town
+100000In post 3472, Persivul wrote:I really don't get the D4 play. You guys took the time to vote on a claim order; put Ranger first, indicating that she was considered most suspicious; but then, when she was CC'd...you didn't lynch her...
Well done! Flavor is eh for me so I give it 10/10 Pers!In post 3469, Persivul wrote:This was my first time modding. Please let me know if I could improve in any way.In post 3467, Shadow_step wrote:Thanks for hosting Persivul.
Well I was correct in that ploben/ranger wasn't t/t, so "if panther lynch ploben instead" I think was still fair...In post 3477, ploben wrote:+100000In post 3472, Persivul wrote:I really don't get the D4 play. You guys took the time to vote on a claim order; put Ranger first, indicating that she was considered most suspicious; but then, when she was CC'd...you didn't lynch her...
In fact, I got scum read for vote parking on Ranger, lol
For real, though. Granted two of the three players town reading me were scum so there's that. But you did give Panther AMPLE opportunity for those town posts of mine.In post 3479, mhsmith0 wrote:Shit happens. I've tunneled before I'll doubtless tunnel again. I tried, REALLY tried to get anyone to make a case on you town since I wasn't seeing it at all. I don't know what (other than "read better" I actually could have done better here).
You never really made me notice you - that, in and of itself is pretty excellent praise for a mod.In post 3469, Persivul wrote:This was my first time modding. Please let me know if I could improve in any way.In post 3467, Shadow_step wrote:Thanks for hosting Persivul.
Again, preach it. An even player day start totally puts town in the hole. I suppose the balance rests in the fact of no mafia PRs without an extra TPR.In post 3482, mhsmith0 wrote:Also game setup was "first to three lynches"with a bodyguard and tracker (unless wolves shoot traitor). That's BRUTAL for town. Panther ran it as 10v3 w free day talk on MU, IMO that was better.
Gah! After you started reconsidering the game you should have pushed me harder to look at Dunn. If you did, my bad. I got lazy in the middle of the game. But I think I reconsidered your alignment somewhere in D2.In post 3486, karnos wrote:ploben, duppid, dunnstral. 2/3 isn't bad.
Ploben, I asked you why dunnstral was buddying up to you so much. Blah, I was so sure you were scum because you saw nothing wrong with that.
You did fine. You seems to ask the right questions. You needed info you never got. You might be leaning a bit heavy on game meta but I might be biased so...In post 3488, mhsmith0 wrote:Also given how badly I shat the bed here, I'd LOVE some advice on what I could/should have done better.
I actually disagree - except for the last phase and some Day 1 lethargy I found the posting to be generally in line with scumhunting and game progression.In post 3485, Persivul wrote:I also think town was hurt by the volume of posting. I believe there were 5 players with over 400 posts each - 4 town plus the mafia traitor. Which that much to analyze, it was fairly easy for the scum to just ride along for the win (and I don't say that to take away from mafia, that's a valid strategy).
Remember Day 1 when I said that there wasn't a Thor case nor a Ploben case - and you disagreed?In post 3488, mhsmith0 wrote:Also given how badly I shat the bed here, I'd LOVE some advice on what I could/should have done better.
I need to stop spammingIn post 3485, Persivul wrote:I also think town was hurt by the volume of posting. I believe there were 5 players with over 400 posts each - 4 town plus the mafia traitor. Which that much to analyze, it was fairly easy for the scum to just ride along for the win (and I don't say that to take away from mafia, that's a valid strategy).
Town lynches me or chip under "well one must be scum" theory most likely.In post 3495, ploben wrote:Even if we got Ranger today and she flipped goon, what the hell would've happened next day?
I mean do you think I would be that obv as scum to gloat?In post 3498, mhsmith0 wrote:@ploben: chips point about you gloating was I think fair. Your late game to e was really weird for someone who's spent all game as the counter wagon to town wagons. Like, if btd6 was scum, gloat away, but since they weren't, that meant that you'd had a legit issue.