I'm not going to respond quote by quote because that would be a bunch of clutter...
1. This is a good rebuttal. I have my activity set on invisible so no one knows when I've last logged in, so this shouldn't have been a factor. And yes, SnowStorm comes from a site with 2-8 hour nights. That he would miss a 48 hour night is bad. I think this is the only game he's playing at this site so his user posts wouldn't show him online during the night; therefore, the lack of a night kill had to come from something else. Even if he didn't log into mafiascum during that time, we all are on each others aim accounts and could have easily directed a kill that way.
2. I'm not really sure what I can say about this point because whatever I say is self-serving to me. But, I think the point he's trying to make is that if EP is town, then I'm more likely scum. Which to me makes sense as a hypothetical although it's not concrete. I was vanillad last night. Vanilla-izer's are a pretty anti-town role as you wouldn't really expect a town role that could get rid of other town roles, which would make him more likely scum, but if he's town then it's a town role and his suspicion of me was genuine. I don't know if I'm making sense here.
3. Your point about Yates is where I'm having trouble. Why would he, as scum, claim to have not seen anyone visiting Maestro on night one and fake that to get a lynch on himself when no one was suspecting him day two. I've read through and I don't see any suspicion on Yates on day two. I don't see him nearing a lynch at all, so I don't know what his point would have been to fake claim voyeur when it would come back to him today. Though the quick lynch on piggy before she got a chance to say anything is
rage
cringe worthy. Basically, what I'm looking for is the scum motivation.4. This point is good. I need to finish my re-read on day one and two. Unfortunately, since day one was sucked up by the shos debaucle there was nothing I could really gain there. I've just been writing off much of day two as overeagerness. The backtracking of the vote on NS as being a joke is bad. The thing is in a game this small you don't joke vote on day two when there are such a small amount of votes needed to lynch.
-Yates, why are you acting as if EP didn't name claim already if in Post 315 you asked piggy if she was claiming magenta who was the other alien? And he name claimed in Post 303
Okay, I'll be around off and on tomorrow. But, I will submit that if we no lynch it won't be horrible. I hate that Maestro went V/LA and can't give input. But we're at 6, so we're at evens. I don't know how that works if we're at LyLo as Yates suggests, but we would probably no lynch today or tomorrow at evens, so let me know what you guys think.
). It's ridiculous that he actually means it.
