I'm arguing that either:In post 5968, Ranger wrote:No, that, by definition, is wifom.Dwlee wrote:Can't the reason be: To frame a town I want to mislynch in lylo?
Which doesn't exist in kills.
The simple explanation for why Dunnstral dies with Dwlee as mafia: "Dunnstral is thinking about Dwlee = mafia, he needs to die".
The explanation you're presenting for why Dunnstral dies with Ranger as mafia: "Dunnstral thought Dwlee = mafia. Ranger chose to throw that away, in spite of Suzune having shown no indication at all from budging her Dwlee-town position. This, because Ranger thought the value of a wifom kill would outweigh the value of a person who would likely side with her."
You believe suzune will think I made the kill (but by you it is just "wifom" so I'll ignore that)
You are unsure how dunnstral might react to nosferatu's end of day posting, he might be convinced you are scum after that
Dunnstral is a more useful poster (sorry suzune but it is true) Dunnstral has been analyzing things and been much more active than suzune, therefore he would be more likely to come to the conclusion of you being scum with more time spent into the game
Suzune is townreading you
etc., etc.
You continue to do this thing where you push things as validating some argument when in reality they're bull crap. It is like the titus not providing meta thing, it is like your "this is my town meta" thing, these things are not alignment indicative and yet you push them as though they are alignment indicative because you have no real arguments that can validate yourself as town or me as scum so you use these bull crap arguments.
You actually just proved what I've been saying. Dunnstral has the ability to read you properly, you said it in this paragraph (more implied it but it is definitely there). With dunnstral being able to properly read you you kill him as scum because he'd figure out you were scum. Derp don't prove me right when trying to argue.Except, I do. He posted. Noteworthy also, is that I wasn't around to post during that time. He'd see my response, in comparison to Nosferatu's points. And he'd recognize that there's a difference between Nosferatu's relationship to me and his relationship to me: Dunnstral and I have high synergy and when a team can work together well. Nosferatu can't read me. He thinks he can, but consistently he's wrong. The difference between Dunnstral's ability to read me, and Nosferatu's ability to read me, is night and day, so Dunnstral would know to go with his own judgment on the matter.You don't know how dunnstral would respond to nosferatu's continued posting about your slot.
P sure suzune already responded to thisExcept, Suzune specifically said multiple times, at every stage: lynch Ranger > Dwlee. Nosferatu was in front of me, yes, but consistently, Suzune has said I'm a lynch over you. Suzune said it yesterday, Suzune's even said it today if I recall correctly.Maybe you think that suzune would lynch me over you because they stated at some point they had a town read on you (and thus refused to hammer you yesterday).
No, it leaves dunnstral alive who knows how to read you. You even fudging said it.The difference is really simple.
If I were scum, killing Suzune leaves me with an even playing field, one I might have a slight advantage in.
No, as suzune is pretty clearly undecided between you and I.If I were scum, killing Dunnstral leaves me with an uphill battleat best, an unwinnable game at worst.
Okay probablyWith you as scum, killing Suzune leaves you in a position where you're not certain of things, and you might have a disadvantage.
But.. it doesn't. Suzune is undecided between us. She has been since yesterday. She p clearly thought it was nosferatu and was hard townreading both of us.With you as scum, killing Dunnstral all-but secures the win.
Again, trying to argue not-alignment indicative things as alignment indicative. Could I have made the dunnstral kill? Yes. Would it make sense for me to kill dunnstral? Probably. But it also makes a ton of sense for you to kill dunnstral because as you've said HE CAN READ YOU. No fricken duh you're gonna be killing the player in the game who can read you properly before lylo.
