Mini 1489 - VisCon: Murder at Wingate Mansion [Game Over]

[Bert]

As far as my actual reads:

empire, bert, nacho, mara, generic, garantula and maybe llamarble and shadoweh are town.

gaiden is mhrmhmrh and lynchable. his replace out is null.

besides that are the peacebringer, purple shoe.

I would most like to lynch peace bringer if i were to change my vote at this time or purple shoe just because i cant' remember a damn thing he did and he's not in my town list.

I agree with you that that's too many townreads.

There is something wrong, and I hope you find what you're missing. That's why I feel like at least one of the rather strong players with competent scum games may be universally misread this game. And the paranoia over not having enough people in the pool being genuinely, genuinely scummy to the generic scumhunter like myself. Which is why I'm so paranoid.

[Bert]

I wasn't

Ohey

why are you avoiding interacting with the game, and why are you only responding when called upon by Nacho

anyone can answer for you since you probably won't friggin answer *shrug*

[Ms Marangal]

UNVOTE:

[The Purple Shoe]

No idea Mr Bert. Just sort of let this game flow by what with all the arguing etc

[Bert]

vote generic

, either scum or a policy lynch one or other.

I hate your policy lynch idea. Seriously???????? NOOOOOOOOOOOO

Gaiden replacing out after a vote from PB feels like giving up.

Happy to save waiting on a replacement who then has to catch up also.

vote gaiden

You don't read his replace-out as null? Don't you think giving up can go either way....so it would be null

[Bert]

No idea Mr Bert. Just sort of let this game flow by what with all the arguing etc

Vote: The Purple Shoe

[PeaceBringer]

vote generic

, either scum or a policy lynch one or other.

I hate your policy lynch idea. Seriously???????? NOOOOOOOOOOOO

Gaiden replacing out after a vote from PB feels like giving up.

Happy to save waiting on a replacement who then has to catch up also.

vote gaiden

You don't read his replace-out as null? Don't you think giving up can go either way....so it would be null

realized it was simply modkill offense... it is what it is.

[Nachomamma8]

so what do you think of the rest of the game in the meantime?

[The Purple Shoe]

It's just flown me by, pretty sure gaiden is scum though

[Ms Marangal]

Nacho

I think Shoe could be scum, but it isn't because of the fact that he lied nor it isn't because of the fact that he isn't following the Meta of his main. I don't really see the difference between 355 and 594

although, I do find it sus that he isn't engaging in the game, only comes in when is called upon, and is laying back period.

Do you still think Shadoweh is town?

and what do you think about Llamarble because I think that he could be scum, I'm not entirely fond of any of his posts thus far and 508 doesn't strike me as very helpful to anything

I do agree with the bottom three of his list though, which I think is interesting

PEdit: why do you think Gaiden is scum shoe?

[Nachomamma8]

It's just flown me by, pretty sure gaiden is scum though

that was to PB.

[The Purple Shoe]

Huge gut feel on his post, like huge huge huge.

What would you say my meta is?

[Ms Marangal]

Trolltastic

[Nachomamma8]

Do you still think Shadoweh is town?

and what do you think about Llamarble because I think that he could be scum, I'm not entirely fond of any of his posts thus far and 508 doesn't strike me as very helpful to anything

I think Shadoweh is town still although that townread slowly erodes.

Llamarble could be scum but probably isn't.

[The Purple Shoe]

Trolltastic

Just my town meta?

[Bert]

Llamarble's #508 is a good start.

Llamarble is leaning town but seems like easy lynchbait.

Nacho can tell you what happens to scum who try and lynch me <3

Desperado has been very cool, calm and collected. Even when pressured or pressed for expanding on his points he has obliged... [] he seems to be town in his mindset.

Good observation; questionable deduction.

Tammy and Generic and Empire have all townsploded at different points, so that's helpful.

It's definitely not sheeping if I don't even know another vote has been placed.

I AM CURRENT. Well, on events more than who is scum, but that's step 1.

Town:
Llamarble
Generic
Tammy
Nacho
Empire
Bert
Garantula

Mara
PB
Gaiden

Purpleshoething
Shadoweh
Desperado

I am not impressed with Llamarble's post, but Nacho is apparently.

It's just a grocery list that's quite vague, to be honest.

[Nachomamma8]

I am not impressed with Llamarble's post, but Nacho is apparently.

Llamarble has a process, this is a step in it. The next ones are much harder to fake as scum, I promise.

[PeaceBringer]

SXTLHGaiden- want to hear more from
Llamarble- no idea
TheGarantula- seems basic noob
PeaceBringer- Good Guy, Town
Empire- too much meta for me, but seems townish to me
Nachomamma8- pushing and prodding- townish
Tammy- gives me the heebies
Bert- a fisherman-town
Ms Marangal- town
Generic-probably is as claimed at this point- modkill
Desperado- eye brow raising, not quite alarming
The Purple Shoe- heebie jeebies, lurking, not engaging
Shadoweh- seems to be working for town

[TheGarantula]

Is basic noob an alignment?

[Nachomamma8]

There you are! What do you think of what you missed?

[TheGarantula]

I'm sad that Generic broke his promise to not mention his baggage again.

Also, Bert is looking pretty good.
Purple Shoe is annoying. I wish that was an alignment tell.
Peacebringer is seeming scummy to me.
Ms Marangal seems town. I get the feeling that the argument earlier was town vs town, but we might find out for sure if this mod kill actually happens.
Nacho is still town.
Shadoweh is null.

I'm going to ISO llamarble, Desperado and Tammy.

Until then: VOTE: PeaceBringer

[PeaceBringer]

Is basic noob an alignment?

it is null

[Bert]

I'm sad that Generic broke his promise to not mention his baggage again.

Also, Bert is looking pretty good.
Purple Shoe is annoying. I wish that was an alignment tell.
Peacebringer is seeming scummy to me.
Ms Marangal seems town. I get the feeling that the argument earlier was town vs town, but we might find out for sure if this mod kill actually happens.
Nacho is still town.
Shadoweh is null.

I'm going to ISO llamarble, Desperado and Tammy.

Until then: VOTE: PeaceBringer

1) Why is Shadoweh null and not leaning either way?

2) What's your read on Purple Shoe; as you remarked yourself, annoying does not equal scummy. Do you think what Purple is doing is just an act to avoid having to express him/herself and give away too much

3) it's not "we might find out," it's "we will find out if he is modkilled"

4) Why is Nacho town to you

[Bert]

Is basic noob an alignment?

I think PB is implying that you're basic noob and pretty transparent, but I beg to differ

Plus, I don't think you're a newb. Maybe aspects of your playstyle seem to be from a newer-ish player? But I don't think you're a newbie, by any stretch of the imagination.

Do you feel you're a basic noob, and if so why

Are you still having trouble getting into this game for your reasons?

[PeaceBringer]

Is basic noob an alignment?

I think PB is implying that you're basic noob and pretty transparent, but I beg to differ

Plus, I don't think you're a newb. Maybe aspects of your playstyle seem to be from a newer-ish player? But I don't think you're a newbie, by any stretch of the imagination.

Do you feel you're a basic noob, and if so why

Are you still having trouble getting into this game for your reasons?

no it means null, as in not put a lot of time sorting out or thinking about the giant spider...he is after all a giant spider-- (oh wait I am at mafia scum that will be frowned on)