Lost Season 5 - Son of a bitch...

[totallynotmafia]

What's your justification for putting Plum at L-2?

I think she's scum.

One would think that was self evident, what with the vote switch. Why aren't you voting?

Oh, I'd forgotten you were in Lost S4 for a bit. It wasn't the OMGUS, that's a crap scumtell.

[Callandor]

So, you're saying you and TMN are mafia? But I had him as town

[Lady Lambdadelta]

What do you think of her first post? That was the one I found scummy.

How many scum do you think are likely to be in the group though? I mean, what are the chances the mafia are going to pile on straight away for an easy lynch on a townie? It's an objection that in theory might happen, but never will in practise.

This could have been explained by "gut"

if not for

Maybe I'll explain later.

Implying that you have a reason beyond Gut that requires explanation.

[Callandor]

Since when is gut not an explanation?

[Callandor]

Well okay, it's a reason, technically, but they're almost interchangable.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Well okay, it's a reason, technically, but they're almost interchangable.

You never said it was gut.

And if it was "gut", you could have said it. You wouldn't be so evasive in answering our questions.

THEREFOR,

If you are town, Gut cannot be your reason! There must be a more complicated answer, otherwise you would not hold back your answer!

Red Truth.

[Callandor]

Well okay, it's a reason, technically, but they're almost interchangable.

You never said it was gut.

And if it was "gut", you could have said it. You wouldn't be so evasive in answering our questions.

THEREFOR,

If you are town, Gut cannot be your reason! There must be a more complicated answer, otherwise you would not hold back your answer!

Red Truth.

It's hilarious that you managed to botch the red truth here, since it's a naive thing to say and quite factually incorrect.

I never said it wasn't gut. I never explained it all. I could have said it of course, but maybe I chose not to? I don't see how me having a reason makes me MORE likely to be evasive, it looks like TMN actually thinks the opposite.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I double clicked, sue me.

And as for your reasoning, that's BULLSHIT.

We're lynching this scumbag today.

[Callandor]

Yet you're vote is on town. Funny.

[Callandor]

oh god your*

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Yet you're vote is on town. Funny.

You're not town. Not even close.

[Callandor]

I double clicked, sue me.

even mafiascum couldn't lie about your red truth lololol

[Callandor]

Yet you're vote is on town. Funny.

You're not town. Not even close.

OH, OKAY. That's convincing. Except everything you've said so far this game has been terrible. You'd probably be doing a slightly better job as scum so far though, since it wouldn't be particularly hard.

[totallynotmafia]

No, I completely agree that if you were town, and your reason for suspecting Plum was "gut", you wouldn't have said "I'll explain later".

Unless of course you're a jester, in which case gg.

[Callandor]

No, I completely agree that if you were town, and your reason for suspecting Plum was "gut", you wouldn't have said "I'll explain later".

Unless of course you're a jester, in which case gg.

[Callandor]

MY EYES, MY EYES. dat post.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Yet you're vote is on town. Funny.

You're not town. Not even close.

OH, OKAY. That's convincing. Except everything you've said so far this game has been terrible. You'd probably be doing a slightly better job as scum so far though, since it wouldn't be particularly hard.

You're scum because of:

1) The resistance to getting rid of the time skip.
2) Refusal to answer TNM's question
3) Your reaction to my pressure
4) Your attempt to deflect my pressure, instead of answering it.
5) Trying to pass off your "reasons" as "gut" when I said that WOULD be acceptable, but not in your case. (I.E: Much too convenient)
6) When faced with an argument you couldn't fight your way out of, you resorted to discrediting me.

[Callandor]

1) The resistance to getting rid of the time skip.
2) Refusal to answer TNM's question
3) Your reaction to my pressure
4) Your attempt to deflect my pressure, instead of answering it.
5) Trying to pass off your "reasons" as "gut" when I said that WOULD be acceptable, but not in your case. (I.E: Much too convenient)
6) When faced with an argument you couldn't fight your way out of, you resorted to discrediting me.

F- would read again but very reluctantly.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Yeah, if you think you're going to deflect my arguments by attempting to be witty, you've got another thing coming.

[totallynotmafia]

Well the deflecting through questions didn't work out so well, so I guess it's the next logical step.

[Callandor]

What other thing do I have coming???? Oh my god I fucking *love* surprises.


See the thing about your case is, it's objectively terrible. 1) wasn't a scumtell untill you made a case, which quite clearly shows your confirmation bias. 2) is newbie game level stuff, actually 2/3/4/5 are all the same thing pretty much but your random.org of case making must have told you to make 6 points. The actualy 6 point is factually incorrect since I called you dumb 2 pages ago.

I'm glad we had this discussion, because I've been entertained as fuck.

[Callandor]

Well the deflecting through questions didn't work out so well, so I guess it's the next logical step.

Actually that's clearly not a logical step at all, but given you've already jester speculated it's probably best you disagree with me.

[xRECKONERx]

2007 (4 to lynch)

Plum (2): dramonic, Callandor
dramonic (1): Plum
Callandor (1): Lady Lambdadelta

Not voting: springlullaby, TheJakalope

1954 (4 to lynch)

Albert B. Rampage (1): jasonT1981
totallynotmafia (1): Elsa von Spielburg
jasonT1981 (1): Darox

Not voting: UncertainKitten, Albert B. Rampage, Ironhead, totallynotmafia

[Callandor]

LLD should be added to the not voting pile, really.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

LLD should be added to the not voting pile, really.

Keep flailing, scum. Makes this so much easier.