NY 183 - Apocalypse Mafia

[Errantparabola]

1. Favorite game of mafia you've played here or elsewhere and why?
2. What is your dream or ideal mafia role? Why?
3. Favorite season?
4. In an actual Apocalypse what is the first thing you would do?

1. None.
2. None.
3. Fall.
4. Cry.

Don't vote me, I'm VT

lol

Also, grib why you townread someone based on the RQS?
Okay looking back on it you did tr someone because they asked for it but I got the impression that your third tr was more serious.

Pointy and Nero are town, I think.

VOTE: Boonskiies

baa

[Grib]

I don't rolehunt.

Why do you feel the need to mention this? Creative didn't ask you if you were rolehunting, just how many power roles you'd generally expect to see in a large normal. This seems like an especially defensive answer to a relatively harmless question.

I'm sorry you feel that way.

[Grib]

Errantparabola: elusive is pretty easy for me to read.

[bewilderbeast]

Sorry I'm late in.
VOTE: elusive

[bewilderbeast]

Would be interesting if there was a SK or Vigilante.
Hmmm...

[Errantparabola]

Errantparabola: elusive is pretty easy for me to read.

What tipped you off out of her two posts?

[Rubicon]

elusive has started well for her town meta, but two posts isn't much to go on.

[Grib]

As town, she's a fan of firing off questions, her play style is floaty/carefree, she isn't afraid to get in people's faces, and she uses pet names and cutesy metaphors a lot.

In contrast, she tends to lurk as scum and has trouble consistently answering questions directed at her.

Once you've completed a town game with her (and I believe she is very likely town in this one), you'll see what I mean.

fake edit: Give the flower time to blossom. I'm just calling it as I see it.

[Ricastle]

74 seems desperate for some motive or another.

Klingon, mind giving some thoughts on the game instead of just popping in to answer the random questions?

[Errantparabola]

I don't see it as "desperate" as much as "discussion inducing." I see where you're coming from but I don't agree.

[elusive]

Rubicon, you break my heart.

Boonskiies has not posted yet, is he being voted because he is doing his usual llama dance of lurkerness until faced with the edge of a cliff?

[Ricastle]

Blowing currently irrelevant things out of proportion isn't discussion inducing more than it is misdirection. Conjuring up arguments out of nowhere isn't going to further our town's interests.

BagelS also instantly assumed Rubicon's VT joke claim was legit earlier, so I'm viewing their behaviour based on that as well.

Elusive, would you say Grib's meta read of you is accurate?

[Klingoncelt]

74 seems desperate for some motive or another.

Klingon, mind giving some thoughts on the game instead of just popping in to answer the random questions?

I've had about 6 hours sleep in the last 3 days, so I'm just putting in an appearance right now before I crash. Tomorrow (Tuesday) I'll post a bit more.

Why are players voting for Elusive if they think she's Town?

[Nero Cain]

Why is boons not dead yet?

Castle's Grib vote isn't horrible but a Boon vote would be better.

How about your game!life instead.

*shrugz*

I don't rolehunt.

Why do you feel the need to mention this? Creative didn't ask you if you were rolehunting, just how many power roles you'd generally expect to see in a large normal. This seems like an especially defensive answer to a relatively harmless question.

TBF, I actually disagree with you here. I mean in an 18 player game there's going to be like 4-5 scum but there's absolutely no way to tell how many scum prs there are unless town knew the set up.

[elusive]

Ricastle,

Yes, Grib's read of me is accurate. The only thing I would add is that sometimes scum and rarely town will see my fluff as an easy mislynch target and then things can turn very aggressive and or set me off on a tunnel. Oh and moodiness in general.

Rubicon's joke claim is a little strange but he has his tells as well.

[Nero Cain]

The sooner Boons is dead the better.

[elusive]

Why? Boonskiies is one of those frustrating players who I keep reading as scum because he's lurkery and\or like a silly fluffy llama but then he ends up being town. What is the difference between town Boon and scum Boon and is there a way to even tell?

[Nero Cain]

What is the difference between town Boon and scum Boon

one has a red pm and one has a green pm.

[elusive]

That doesn't give us much to work with. I think even the best (or worst) players have slight difference at least between their scum and town games. In the newbie game I was in, the player was fantastic but on research she was playing her scum game and the "voice" was all wrong for her town game so she got caught that way.

[Nero Cain]

yes but lets stop the discussion about his meta stop here for now.

[PointYBagelS]

Blowing currently irrelevant things out of proportion isn't discussion inducing more than it is misdirection. Conjuring up arguments out of nowhere isn't going to further our town's interests.

Ehh, it's still very early. Basically everything is out of (mostly) nowhere at this point. I thought that response was a bit odd so I called it out.

Kitz, you haven't weighed in yet. What are your thoughts on the game so far?

[Errantparabola]

Blowing currently irrelevant things out of proportion isn't discussion inducing more than it is misdirection. Conjuring up arguments out of nowhere isn't going to further our town's interests.

BagelS also instantly assumed Rubicon's VT joke claim was legit earlier, so I'm viewing their behaviour based on that as well.

Elusive, would you say Grib's meta read of you is accurate?

Whoa whoa whoa. Doesn't meta analysis fall immediately when the person you're analyzing is aware of it?

[Grib]

With elusive? No.

[Grib]

Ricastle, why are you attacking Bagels while voting me?

[Shinobi]

bump