512: Bojack Horseman Season 2 (Over)

[AngryPidgeon]

Vote Count 1.1

Wisdom(2) - EspeciallyTheLies, Firebringer
Firebringer(2) - Kaboose, Polar Vortex
EspeciallyTheLies(1) - Wisdom
Kaboose(1) - Wingback

Not Voting(3): Metal Sonic, Sekai no Ki, sthar8

-----------

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

You know, its funny. When you look at someone through rose-colored glasses, all the red flags just look like flags.

-Wanda

[Wingback]

@ ETL, what's your read on Wisdom? I'm confused about whether you have an actual scumread there.

[Kaboose]

inb4 Wisdom and ETL are scum team

[Firebringer]

I didn't even notice I had two votes on me lol.

[Polar Vortex]

inb4 Wisdom and ETL are scum team

I'm actually thinking this is a legit possibility. The interaction really doesn't make sense to me. And it does ping as bussing imho

-Bearbert head

[Wisdom]

great, help me bus her

[Polar Vortex]

Firebringer, how many themed games have you completed?

I'm feeling ETL's overreaction to Wisdom scummy. Initially found it town, but the way he continued with it doesn't seem genuine IMO

-Bearbert head

have you played with ETL before?

does your other head have an opinion?

I don't think ETL's reaction is scummy. I'm actually more worried about Wisdom because I don't understand what he's aiming at with this push.

[Kaboose]

Wisdom seems off to me from other games we've played together.

VOTE: Wisdom

i like this vote, others do this

[Wisdom]

ive been scum in all games with you i think, doesnt that mean im town?

[Kaboose]

What about the game that just ended? The one where you were NK'd N1 and I told Vig to shoot the scum?

[Wisdom]

i didnt even get to post there :/

[sekai no ki]

I think wingback might be town. also maybe Firebringer. maybe.

I think Firebringer is likely town if I'm interpreting his posts correctly. If your reason is anywhere close to mine, you should also see why I have a problem with Kaboose's rolefishing accusation.

In general, how likely is it for mods on this forum to provide safe fake-claims in themed games? I've seen a lot of variation across various forums.

In general quite likely, thoughit does vary by moderator. I've played a few AP games, but have never drawn scum so I can't say for sure. IIRC ETL has been scum in one of his games. She could say pretty definitively.

You made no comment on the other part of my post. Was that intentional?

To some extent. I don't want to walk through your line of inquiry regarding kaboose. But I"m also not sure I follow you re Kaboose at all.

[sekai no ki]

Wisdom seems off to me from other games we've played together.

VOTE: Wisdom

i like this vote, others do this

Off in what ways?

[Wisdom]

yeah just confirmed - in all games I've played with Kaboose I was scum

i am off in comparison to my scum games so im scum - makes sense!

[Firebringer]

You are out if the game wisdom! Time to throw in the towel, you are too old for this game now.

[Wisdom]

damn

[Wingback]

Here's what rubbed me the wrong way about Kaboose's post:

Firebringer made a post where he soft-claimed Bojack. As far as I know, Bojack is the only one who was in a 90s TV show. Firebringer then asked people if they were in a 90s TV show.

a) Kaboose if town could have caught on to the reference and thought Firebringer was fishing for Bojack. If Kaboose understood the reference, he would also notice that Fire was soft-claiming Bojack himself so a rolefishing accusation there doesn't make any sense - you can't fish for your own flavor character.

b) The other option which was my initial gut-reaction was that Kaboose completely missed the reference to Bojack and was just stretching to make an accusation. A lot of the time, I see awkward scum accusing people in RVS to appear pro-town and make it seem like they are contributing something. The fact that Kaboose never asked Firebringer any follow-up questions or tried to develop a read on him makes me think his initial accusation was just a throwaway comment.

Post 56 doesn't do anything to change my opinion of him.

As a caveat, I may be wrong about Firebringer softclaiming Bojack but it doesn't affect my Kaboose read.

Not especially, don't think wagoning her would give us more info. We've seen the reactions we need. More votes would mean more of the same.

Would rather wagon

VOTE: Firebringer

If you find ETL scummy, why vote Firebringer over ETL? I don't follow what you mean by "seen the reactions we need" so expand on that. And what's your read on Firebringer?

I like wisdom playstyle but I kinda think could be scum given his thoughts just on flavor for this theme.
VOTE: Wisdom

What's the scum motive to lie about thoughts on flavor?

[Wingback]

@ AngryPidgeon

, do we have a deadline? If so can you include a countdown in the votecounts?

[Polar Vortex]

There are other prominent characters who've been in a famous 90' TV show.

[AngryPidgeon]

(expired on 2015-08-21 12:00:00)

August 21st at Noon. I'm going to have this one be 2 weeks. I may lower it on future days when there are fewer players.

[Polar Vortex]

Kaboose, are you familiar with the flavor?

[Wingback]

Did not realize that there are multiple people on 90s shows. It nullifies one of my reasons to suspect Kaboose.

I still want an explanation from Kaboose for: a) The complete lack of reaction to my vote, and b) no follow-up on Firebringer. Also want the Wisdom scumread explained.

[Firebringer]

I was not making a soft claim I was referring to intro song to show. >.>

[Polar Vortex]

I found ESL scummy, but thought Firebringer was scummier. Like I thought he was softclaiming some flavour to appear town(like he'd think we'd assume Bojack would be a town person. I didn't get the reference at that point, but thought it was obvious he was softclaiming a character) and also somehow fishing for roles like Kaboose was saying. I also don't like 78 which looks to me like a "look at how I don't care about these votes" type of post which scum sometimes do

I'll also trust Snowstorm's opinion on ESL. I was waiting for it before going that way and he seems cool with her play+at this point wagoning would be more to get a reaction and judging from her interaction with Wisdom, I don't think her reaction would lead us to get a better read on her.

-Bearbert head

[Polar Vortex]

I was not making a soft claim I was referring to intro song to show. >.>

Ok, got that. Cool
UNVOTE: