mini 1410: mafia in the unknown (game over!)

[captaineddie]

Hi, how's it going boys. Sorry, was in Quebec this weekend. Let me catch up here at work (bleh) and I'll post.

Btw, anybody disagree with my reads I posted yesterday before the hammer?

[captaineddie]

And btw, did I miss something? Is it confirmed we have three scums and one SK?

[CooLDoG]

i'm pretty sure zhero is the sk but we need to be lynching mafia to remove nightkills entirely

dude, pay the fuck attention. Zhero has not gun.

read the wiki. sk returns a no gun result to gunsmiths.

That can't be right because that would be bullshit. The whole fucking idea of a gunsmith is to find killing roles. Goddamn fucking retarded roles giving sk too much of an advantage. But yeah, you are right, looking at my role pm I have found that THE SK DOES NOT HAVE A GUN.

It wouldn't clear me even if one scum could perform only one night action since I didn't neighborize anyone last night.

If gunsmith doesn't clear Zhero, then that blows. I think it still should though; it's dumb that "bulletproof" saves you against someone with no gun.

We would force you to neighbor tonight and nl today.

The only way that zhero could be lynched is if we think he is a maf doc...

@cap, basically yes.

unvote

[Zhero]

It wouldn't clear me even if one scum could perform only one night action since I didn't neighborize anyone last night.

It wouldn't clear you, but if you can only perform one action a night, it could explain why you didn't neighborize.

But yeah, you are right, looking at my role pm I have found that THE SK DOES NOT HAVE A GUN.

Your role PM says that specifically?

[CooLDoG]

yes.

[Zhero]

RF - Scum, Simply due to the apparent change of heart on eddie for no apparent reason. She was bussing him hard yesterday. What changed aside from the slot actually posting... in a really scummy way. This looks like day 1 distancing that you attempted to recant day 2.

Scum-Book says scum-Rest was 'bussing' Eddie, instead of 'attacking' or some other term. Guessing based on his scumreads, or a slip of the tongue?

[Quilford]

“Faith and doubt both are needed - not as antagonists, but working side by side to take us around the unknown curve.”
― Lillian Smith

Mod: can one scum perform multiple night actions (e.g. nightkill and neighborize)?

Yes.

Revenus

(1) roflcopter

roflcopter

(1) Revenus

Not Voting (3) captaineddie, Zhero, CooLDoG

===

deadline hits in (expired on 2013-03-09 03:24:19).

with 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

[Revenus]

RF - Scum, Simply due to the apparent change of heart on eddie for no apparent reason. She was bussing him hard yesterday. What changed aside from the slot actually posting... in a really scummy way. This looks like day 1 distancing that you attempted to recant day 2.

Scum-Book says scum-Rest was 'bussing' Eddie, instead of 'attacking' or some other term. Guessing based on his scumreads, or a slip of the tongue?

Certainly something to consider now that both book/rest have flipped scum, yea?

[Revenus]

Also, as far as Zhero goes, no way is he mafia doc since...it'd be useless due to the nature of the daykilling sk.

That is, unless somehow the save is applicable to the following day, but I'm not going to entertain that possiblity since it's dumb.

Unvote

I'd rather hit the last mafia dude today over the sk, so zhero's findings give me pause

[Zhero]

Mod: can one scum perform multiple night actions (e.g. nightkill and neighborize)?

Yes.

That clears up my main concern there. I'd prefer a CE lynch, willing to compromise on a rofl lynch, and would like to hear more from both of them, really.

Rev isn't cleared by any means, but I don't feel he's a good lynch today.

Idle thought: would Day Serial Killer/Neighborizer even be Normal?

[CooLDoG]

yes. Neighborer is a normal role. Day-sk is just a slight variation to a normal role. I could go for a CE lynch.

[Zhero]

^I mean both at the same time.

[roflcopter]

at this point i think rev is way more likely to be the last mafia than ce

[Revenus]

as scum neighorizor why wouldn't i just have recruited my own team for daytalk?

[roflcopter]

as scum neighorizor why wouldn't i just have recruited my own team for daytalk?

because that would be super frickin' obvious, terrible defense is terrible

[Revenus]

why exactly would it be obvious?

[CooLDoG]

gar, the scum is either rofl or rev. one of those two. Don't know which though.

hay rev, why no scum hunting in the neighbor thread?

[Revenus]

I wasn't able to access it for most of february and neither of you have posted since last time I checked, so what's the point?

[captaineddie]

why exactly would it be obvious?

At this point it's a WIFOM argument. I'm still wondering why didn't you recruit last night, you just didn't feel like it? It's not like that thread is busting with activity.

[Revenus]

I didn't feel like it.

[roflcopter]

because if you were like 'i claim neighborizer, i neighbored restfermata and fitz' and then they both flipped scum it would be hurr durr duh

that's why you didn't do that, and that's why saying that you would have if you were scum is a terribad defense

[roflcopter]

gar, the scum is either rofl or rev. one of those two. Don't know which though.

please feel free to try and gather evidence that my push on rest yesterday was a bus, because lol

[CooLDoG]

yeah, it isn't. I'm going with my gut. Scum neighbor..

vote:rev

[roflcopter]

well that leaves it up to eddie to hammer again, unless zhero wants to come around and see the light

[Zhero]

Cooldog, why is CE town?