Red Wine Mafia: Game Over

[Natirasha]

I only joined this game because you told me to.

Tammy, I'm twice the man Empire will

ever

be.

[Natirasha]

Well first page tells me Pjovek+Chamber are town lol.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Redwiiiine. Soon. Cabd will get his wish.

[Cabd]

As ffery mentioned i have some Carmel Whiskey shots lined up for this evening as well, so I suppose we'll have some fun discussion this evening.

[Natirasha]

But seriously, there's gotta be a reason this is a theme game. Lord Patator had hidden cults, but we know this game doesn't. You wanna talk about possible themes, Cabd? Or do you think this was more a sneaky way for mykonian to skip the normal queue line?

[Natirasha]

Empire (or whoever replaces him), Tammy, Pmatt:

Quick recap on your scum read on espeonage, please.

Quickly skimmed his ISO. Not terrible, not good. Decidedly meh.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

sneaky way for mykonian to skip the normal queue line?

As ffery mentioned i have some Carmel Whiskey shots lined up for this evening as well, so I suppose we'll have some fun discussion this evening.

I look forward to it. I have some things I wouldn't mind going over with you.

p-edit: okie dokie natiroshi. When you finish your full read, let me know how you feel about it at that point.

[Natirasha]

p sure 1 of cabd/ffery is scum trying to pull a fast one on the other

[Natirasha]

TSO can I steal Cabd's line about in thread masons?

[fferyllt]

cabd - scumfuck, role pm matters not

You clarified you townread me, so hey, 1 right so far!

Your read comes with a 200pt font footnote.

empire (now nati) - null/scum

I didn't see any parallells to Boatgame, personally. You'll have to walk me through those some more. That said, nati should be able to give us a good show either way.

I can't call him town based on what's in the game. And I feel like I should be able to, even with my smidge of experiential meta. Will probably pretend he never posted and see what Nati puts down in the thread.

chamber - probtown

I think you're underestimating Chamber here, but I will admit I find him naturally scummy; he felt like scum in Macbeth up until trollie flipped him as town in endgame.

I'm not getting a scum sense. More of a curmudgeony town than anything.

tammy - probtown

I would ask you if you're under-estimating tammy's scumgame; but after rereading parts of Chosen this morning, I concur.

Did you focus on the exchange that tammy and I had in that game? I did.

fferyllt - half of morph what do you expect?

I expect you to

die

dance.

meh

bbmolla - null

You know, his play this game calls me back to my very first game here, where he was town that got mislynched. (The one with sex jokes and then nacho replacing into obvscum slot)

The only completed game I have with him is Rach's Half Baked Curse mini. He lurked the hell out of that game before he was lynched at...MYLO? There was no personality at all in his posts. Reminded me of Empking's style of minimalism.

TSO - town

Well... I don't know on this one. I'm not nearly as strongly townreading TSO as you seem to be.

I admittedly don't have any experiential meta with scum-TSO. I did a recent meta dive in for another game. My sense from that was that scum-TSO doesn't put as much reasoning into his posts. His tunneling Katsuki reminds me of the way he tunneled you in 1436.

Llamarble - I dunno maybe? want to say null because based on reputation I would have expected him to have the game solved by now.

BoP ruins reads. Here you go using that "want" filler again.

It's a very weak read. This is my first game with llamarble.

projectmatt - where did he go? null at best.

I'm leaning scum here, compare chosen vs wingate.

Yeah he reminds me of Chosen.

Tammy? thoughts?

pjovek - probtown

Annoying as fuck, but agreed on probably town.

As you can imagine, this was not a quick decision.

EspeciallyTheLies - null/town?

I'll be totally reading her from her drunk posts, I can tell the scumdrunk and towndrunk apart. (For drunkscum, see Antihero mafia and sabotage mafia)

What's your read, then?

Katsuki - town

See TSO read response, mix in some of what I said about chamber and naturally scummy read.

Welp. If they're both scum then this is some damn silly scum theater.

Albert B. Rampage - null/scum

Your vote is here, so this is your strongest scumread despite it being nullscum?

I don't have a vote down. The fact that he's doing absolutely nothing to dispel his wagon doesn't feel like scum tactics somehow.

espeonage - probtown

Do you think is wagon is icky, or that it's town getting wagoned for the wrong reasons? What did you make of the tammy-espionage hairball?

I just think he's probably town. His stances are kinda dumb in places, but they come off town to me. He voted me instead of ABR at a point where voting ABR would have taken him out of the lynch lead iirc.

Cephrir-Town

Concur for now, but I never underestimate cephrir's ability to switch heads to townceph when his role PM is scumrir's.

Maybe. Still think he's town.

[fferyllt]

p sure 1 of cabd/ffery is scum trying to pull a fast one on the other

The thought has occurred.

[T S O]

TSO can I steal Cabd's line about in thread masons?

Of course you can, baby.

[Natirasha]

Up to page 11, I think you're on to something EtL.

[Natirasha]

#269 seems important for later once we get a flip from those two.
#271 sounds like Towmmy though.

[fferyllt]

How about that reads discussion?

I'll reads discussion with you!

Well?

[Natirasha]

Page 15. Really wish GIF had posted some before leaving me with the inscrutable Cephrir.

Agree VERY strongly with Espeonage-scum
Agree slightly less strongly with ABR-scum

[fferyllt]

Nati have you played with Espeonage before?

[Natirasha]

Cephrir's opening is the boringest boredom I've ever seen.\

PEDIT: No, have you?

[fferyllt]

No.

I was leaning scum on him at first. Curious to see if you keep that read intact as you catch up.

[Natirasha]

I want to sort out ffery/Cabd tomorrow. The tones in those two's posts are different from Feirei's game(which was town-town) and I don't like it.

[Natirasha]

okay i see why espeon's wagon dismantled.

fferylit, I need you to answer me on why you're being so defensive here.

[Natirasha]

I actually like ABR's posts on page 22.

[Cabd]

I want to sort out ffery/Cabd tomorrow. The tones in those two's posts are different from Feirei's game(which was town-town) and I don't like it.

Bad coimparison given that moid error had us confirmed to each other by like my third post.

[fferyllt]

okay i see why espeon's wagon dismantled.

fferylit, I need you to answer me on why you're being so defensive here.

Why I am being? Or why I was being? Because, I don't really feel defensive at this point.

The game pace was slow and the actual content by several players has been pretty low throughout. I had trouble getting stuck into the game.

[Cabd]

Forcing a false comparison... nati might be scum independently of empire's posts.