Mafia 97 - Day Night Mafia, Game Over

[Platypus_Dude]

EBWOP:

Reck: I looked back over your post after rereading a bit, and I don't really know which post you were referring to (I assumed it was my last one, but it could have been 1210 or 1211). Could you clarify?

[Kise]

All of the above, lol. J/K

[xRECKONERx]

1210.

Why does that matter? Both are just as non-commital.

[Platypus_Dude]

The purpose of 1210 was to say that I needed to catch up and that I would reread. For 1211, I just felt like posting.

[Platypus_Dude]

Bekk

: I went back and forth on your alignment after my reread. Sometimes your lurking felt genuine, and others you came back and repeated things that were said. Then, there is Kise. Kise-scum would have an easy time looking townie when replacing in. Reck already claimed day-scum so the lynch was semi-setup for tomorrow. Despite that, I read him as town. I’m going to say more pro-town for Bekk/Kise.

Reck

: I read you as town most of the game. I liked your early play and into the middle, however, near the end you get a little sloppier, and I'm not sure why. You’ve been on

every

lynch, which irritates me to death.

What has changed since post 1151?

TOWN
BloodCovenent
xRECKONERx
Sando
Platypus/iPeanut

SCUM
Bekkatha
DTMaster
iPeanut/Platypus

You had Bekk as scum, and I’m assuming that you had me as town if iPeanut was scum, which he was.

Another factor is whether I think scum-Reck would claim day scum and argue well enough to get the lynch away from him so he can win. Whereas I think it was too risky for town-Reck to do it. Tell me if I’m wrong, but I think people playing as scum are more likely to take a risk than if one was town.

Overall, I think you’re scum. I’m willing to let you respond before I decide to vote or not.

[xRECKONERx]

@Plat:

To bring up past alignment reads in a LYLO situation seems rather misguided, don't you think? No matter how strong you feel about someone throughout the game, all of that goes out the window in a LYLO situation. My read on Bekk was a lurker-induced read, anyway. But she wasn't actively lurking, she was just straight up inactive.

And how is me pulling a gambit which drew the day kill away from one townie and increased the percentage of night scum getting killed anti-town? Sure, I had to claim day scum to do so: but seriously, look at my play yesterday, and the day before. I was a sure-fire town read to mostly everyone in the game, whereas BOTH of you two (Bekk/Plat) have gotten mixed reads the entire game. I didn't think I could trust the other townie to claim or improvise like that, so I had to do it myself.

[xRECKONERx]

I think it's interesting that Platypus says his read on Bekk is either lurking or posting regurgitated information... and he also says that Kise-scum would

easily

be able to play town after replacing in... yet, he "reads him as town". How the hell do you get that jump in logic?

And then... the thing that irritates him about me is that I was on every lynch? Oh, you mean the ones

where we lynched day scum and night scum, too

? How is it anti-town to be on every scum lynch so far?

[Platypus_Dude]

I absolutely hate myself right now for being this stupid and lazy.

I couldn't find anything against Bekk so I just listed her as town. So, I needed to make a 'case' against Reck so I would have someone as scum.

I miscounted the number of scum lynched because of how many townies died. I feel more confident about Reck looking at his 'arguments' and the stupid things I said.

[xRECKONERx]

...seriously? I'm so ready to vote you right now, Plat, but I'd like to see an extensive post from Zito first.

[Kise]

Zito?

the thing that irritates him about me is that I was on every lynch? Oh, you mean the ones

where we lynched day scum and night scum, too

? How is it anti-town to be on every scum lynch so far?

Yeah... we pretty much haven't lynched a townie since Day 1. Not sure what you were going for with that, Plat, but it makes RECK look a helluva lot more convincing.

I'm ready to make my decision. I just screwed the game for my town elsewhere [LyLo], so I'm not going to out think myself again.

Any questions you guys have, ask away. My next post will likely be a vote if there's nothing left to discuss.

[Kise]

Actually, that just goes to show that you weren't paying attention to the game, Plat. If you took the time to see that RECK was on every lynch, you should have noticed he was lynching anti-town.

[xRECKONERx]

I meant Kise, sorry. I don't know why I said Zito.

Kise, can you state your reasons for thinking I am town?

[Kise]

Being on every lynch. Weeks ago, I told you it was because you lynched two different kinds of scum. And now, you've lynched 4 damn scum.

Plat voted for night scum (lobster) and pretty much pioneered the foundations for a case against him. His next vote for DTM served as the hammer, when everyone pretty much figured out that DTM was the only miller and that he was lying. What's funny is that DTM votes for Plat and says either Plat or Peanut is night scum.

[Kise]

Do you think I'm town, or do you just think Plat is being scummy?

[xRECKONERx]

I think Plat is being scummy. I think Bekk was scummy, but you've alleviated some concerns.

[Kise]

Anything else, guys?

[Platypus_Dude]

I personally feel that most things I've done wrong could have been avoided with some more effort. However, I also think that I've mostly been careless and not scummy. There is a difference.

Seeing how the voting is going to start, I might as well get mine out.

Vote: Kise

You've definitely played well since you replaced in, but you're up against someone who has contributed to lynching nearly the entirety of both mafia teams.

[Kise]

Okie dokie.

Vote: Platypus_Dude

[xRECKONERx]

Vote: Platypus

There's the hammer. I just hope I was right. Plat's wishy-washy stance pisses me off to the point of voting, so if Kise/Bekk is the last scum, I sincerely apologize to the rest of town.

[DTMaster]

Bah! /Delayed Post.

[xRECKONERx]

Modmodmodmodmodmodmodmodmod.

[BloodCovenent]

who won :X

Reck, you can be honest now... were you dayscum :X

[xRECKONERx]

Nope. I was town.

[BloodCovenent]

Good. My night investigations totally got me xD

Plat was who I investigated. He wasn't night scum. Thats fo sho.

[xRECKONERx]

Did you investigate Bekk?