kmd wrote:It was my assumption.
This does not sound like it was an assumption:
Kmd4390 wrote:elvis_knits wrote:
There are exactly four scum in this game? ORLY?
4 scum plus a traitor.
I asked you if there were EXACTLY four scum in the game. You did not say, "uh, that's what I assumed." You said "4 scum plus a traitor." That is not an assumption. You told me it was fact.
My understanding after looking at the rules/roles was that the list of roles may all be in the game, but we don't know which and how many. That tells you nothing as to how many scum we have. And even if you were going by the sample role PM's, I think there are 5 mafiates listed.
Role Name: Mafia Godfather
Group: The Mafia Family is: XXXX (Mafia Godfather), XXXX (Mafia [?]), XXXX (Mafia [?]), [XXXX (Mafia [?])], [XXXX (Mafia [?])].
^^ that would suggest 5 mafia if you were going to assume the sample PMs are literal. If you were assuming you should assume 5, but I think we shouldn't assume anything.
So you definitively stating four is evidence of extra info. Info only scum would have.
THIS IS A SLIP, PPL.
unvote, vote kmd
There is a strong possibility that Xyl is scum too because KMD tried to tie him to three other people, but it'd not as much a sure thing as kmd.
BNB wrote:Scum very often vote eachother. Especially RVS. I think some people actually consider it a tell (if, for instance, Xyl turned up scum). Secondly, it makes no sense. How could I possibly know my vote would turn into a wagon? I could have easily just made one vote and switched it.
I actually don't see scum vote eachother that often in rvs, but whatever. It was the combination of you random voting xyl and then asking for bandwagon on him that made me think you're not buddies even if one of you were to flip scum. I wouldn't expect a scum to random vote and then push for their buddies lynch. Maybe that's just me. I just don't think it's that productive to lynch your buddy if you don't have to.
Talk nerdy to me.
"We must be willing to let go of the life we planned so as to have the life that is waiting for us." -Joseph Campbell