Robo: I wasn't expecting anyone to discuss with me what mason pairs they see as possible, I was explaining why I was confused because I found myself with no viable pairs. I have no intention of discussing any finds I may have.
You're not scum. I've seen scum stick to some ridiculous guns, but not when they are being called out on doing nothing and mudslinging at the same time. No one who has strong concerns with their self-preservation will sit on something that isn't even the pretense of hard work.
Riss_ makes no sense with anyone, she's too lost and the only person who could fit in with her was the person she was happily RVSing for most of the game.
CES isn't scum. I freely admit I have no idea what he's doing most of the time, but I
think
he's going through the game in terms of viable scum pairs.
Voidedmafia works well with both Equinox and Rainbowdash. Moreso with Equinox than with Rainbowdash, but it might be too obvious. I've seen scum DeasVail be completely oblivious to a consensual obvtown read and stick to wagoning it, and there are points here that I feel are similar (see: pretense of hard work by going all-out against someone who won't be lynched). However, in that game scum didn't have daytalk, so I find it hard to believe that Voidedmafia would keep up the pursuit on Robo when it was clear his partner had no interest on the lynch (i.e. one of {Equinox, Rainbowdash}). With the scumteam being less isolated than they were in Mafia with the Kitties, I'd expect him to be more acommodating.
I've seen Rainbowdash make that kind of hardline defense as scum-on-town before. It's pretty obvious that I was considering a Rainbowdash/Robocopter mason pair until recently, which caused me to treat it as a mason defense, but now I think the behavior is pretty similar to Rainbowdash-on-Xalxe on PYP Redux, for example (my internet speed is pathetic so I can't check
the earlier Days to see what he actually did; I'd be grateful if someone could lend me a hand and go through those files for a meta-read on recentish scum-Rainbow).
If Rainbow is scum and my read on you is there for the right reasons, he had a very easy read to give on you, and it didn't cost him anything in terms of likely lynches. Basically, what I'm saying is that defending you didn't cut any potential mislynch for an hypothetical scum Rainbowdash.
That leaves Equinox. If the scumteam is two of {Equinox, Rainbowdash, Voidedmafia}, and I can't see a working Rainbowdash/Voidedmafia pairing, it means that Equinox must be scum with one of them.
In post 255, Equinox wrote:Tierce posts a case against Cogito Ergo Sum in
post 136; she includes evidence and analysis of Cogito Ergo Sum's behavior. I respond to that entire thing with only a single line
post 163, and it's not even a direct response to any point of Tierce's case. The next time she references Cogito Ergo Sum is a complaint about the wagon going nowhere in
post 194; when I point out she didn't pressure me for my scummy rebuttal, she gives a weak response in
post 199: I raised flags, but I'm not worth pursuing.
Tierce-town is proactive and aggressive, and she would have given me a more substantial response. If not pressure, at least an attempt at more persuasion, since we'd both lost to Cogito Ergo Sum-scum earlier in the year.
Tierce was more concerned about not seeing Riss_ lynched than about lynching Cogito Ergo Sum. If Riss_ is a townread of mine, there is a clear priority here, and it is not "lynch CES":
In post 201, Venmar wrote:[L-3] Cogito Ergo Sum: Tierce
[L-3] Equinox: Riss
[L-1] Riss: Voidedmafia, Equinox, Cogito Ergo Sum
Not Voting
Robocopter87, Rainbowdash
