NY 159: RUST game over

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: Reverend

Ok, Im actually fairly confident in this one.

But AP, we demand a wall post! Rofl, gimme some of your mary jane : (. then maybe.

VOTE: TheReverend

I hate his stupid avatar with the heat of 10,000 volcanoes. That's reason enough.

[AngryPidgeon]

Actually this is good work pyro. I think it's likely that scum helped lynch BC, and ckd wasn't part of that wagon.

[DrippingGoofball]

Actually this is good work pyro. I think it's likely that scum helped lynch BC, and ckd wasn't part of that wagon.

Reverend hammered BC, no?

[AngryPidgeon]

Yes.

[Rob14]

I found one thing interesting about Darthe's votes on your analysis DGB:

Why did you not commit to a vote at all on Day 4, Darthe?

[ProHawk]

Why are we all doubting our MVP?

Fuck it, this can be an info lynch.

unvote vote Dcore

^Hammer Bus.

In the words of the late drmy: "lynch this Vader".

For those of you with doubts, you should really re-read posts #574-#587

[AngryPidgeon]

No its revered, He is blatantly agreeing with the wagon analysis done by someone he thinks may be scum despite that meaning he is the scum on the wagon if darthe flips town? And he doesn;t give a singular shit about that? Hes literally that confident in a darthe scum flip? Not buying it.

[ProHawk]

No its revered, He is blatantly agreeing with the wagon analysis done by someone he thinks may be scum despite that meaning he is the scum on the wagon if darthe flips town? And he doesn;t give a singular shit about that? Hes literally that confident in a darthe scum flip? Not buying it.

Stupid play cause he loses if Darthe flips town and we lynch him next.

All Darthe can say is "I will flip town, I will flip town, just you see".

[AngryPidgeon]

No its revered, He is blatantly agreeing with the wagon analysis done by someone he thinks may be scum despite that meaning he is the scum on the wagon if darthe flips town? And he doesn;t give a singular shit about that? Hes literally that confident in a darthe scum flip? Not buying it.

Stupid play cause he loses if Darthe flips town and we lynch him next.

All Darthe can say is "I will flip town, I will flip town, just you see".

Exactly. He cant be scum can he.,

[AngryPidgeon]

It was a very thinly veiled ploy for "I wouldn't seal my own fate as scum would I?"

I just got out of a town game that I was in a PoE pool with like that. I was paranoid as fuck that the other guy wouldn't flip scum (despite thinking he would)

[Rob14]

It was a very thinly veiled ploy for "I wouldn't seal my own fate as scum would I?"

By this logic, when I flip town will you volunteer to be the lynch candidate for tomorrow?

Oh, I see your logic here. So Rev is committing a thinly veiled ploy of "I wouldn't seal my own fate, would I?" but the Darthe post above is a town-tell. It's not like it's the exact same thing or anything.

Meanwhile, ProHawk is buddying me to get a Darthe lynch.

My god, do we have options today. Let's think about it this way. If Rev flips town, what do we have to go on from there? Nothing, that's what. If Darthe flips town, what do we have now? We have PH trying to buddy me, someone who ALSO happens to have a town read on PH, to get the lynch of Darthe. And then it's simple. We lynch the ProHawk.

Yes, I just flip-flopped like crazy on ProHawk. I read my old wall on him and a bit of it is irrelevant because it speculated that BC was scum. Also, his recent play is not so good.

[Rob14]

Also, ProHawk late bus on CKD and quickly moved from a Mal wagon losing steam to a Cheery wagon gaining steam in the last day. Hard bus of Zab on Day 1, though.

[Rob14]

Here are my reads, from most town to most scum. Lynch from bottom to the top.

Me
AP
DGB
Mal
Rev
PP
ProHawk
Darthe

Ask if you have any questions.

[ProHawk]

Lynch me today. It will be quicker.

[ProHawk]

Allow me to make this easy for you, since you feel my play today has been bad.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Rob13

Just speed lynch me so you can quit stalling and kill the scum Darthe tomorrow.

[DrippingGoofball]

WHY bicker when we can lynch Reverend?

[DrippingGoofball]

I really don't want to see that stupid avatar anymore.

[AngryPidgeon]

Reads list:

Very upset with these people
Rob13
Prohawk

Moderately upset at these people
DGB
Malp
Darthe

Scum
TheReverend

Ok, PLEASE let me have this one. I guarantee you Rev's reaction is not town. I recently got out of an open game (as town) and I was in a pool of 3 people, one of which was scum. I thought it was disturbed but I kept poking Mhork and being edgy as hell because I wasn't 100% certain of Disturbed=scum so I kept preemptively accusing Mhork and declaring my intent to vote him if Disturbed flipped town. (We had already settled on the Disturbed lynch).

Point being, Reverend is acknowledging that he is in a similar pool and using it as justification to vote Darthe. He is acting 100% confident that Darthe is scum. There is no way town Rev would be that certain of his Darthe read. I guarantee it. I was so paranoid in that open, and I was even pretty sure that Disturbed WAS scum. And yes, my comparison is a little loose, but the basic premise is identical: He should not have so much faith in his Darthe read.

"But, AP, if Rev is scum, then Darthe is town! So he must be town to think that Darthe could be scum so strongly"
Wrong: he is posturing. In fact, he is outright avoiding a position that a lot of people would find scummy (Preemptively backpedaling on the Darthe read) but should be totally natural for town.

So you 2 need to stop outright disappointing me and vote Rev.

@Rob: Its not the same thing. Darthe is just appealing to emotion and fear. Not the same thing at ALL.

[DrippingGoofball]

I second AP's post.

Let's get this done.

[Darthe]

Rob is actually pinging me now. AP, DGB, lets get this shit done. Fuck it, speed lynch me tomorrow if I am wrong.

unvote vote reverend

[Rob14]

Rev is now at L-1. I do not agree with this wagon at all. He seems pretty obviously town to me. Not as much as AP, but still. I seriously doubt he's scum. Darthe is the last scum, as I've been saying for a long time. I don't think I'll have time to wall him before Thanksgiving. Some stuff has come up IRL. If we can hold the day until then, at least, please do. It doesn't hurt to check some more things out before we do this mislynch.

[AngryPidgeon]

Wrong. Vote him. Ill vote your scum list in order if you die

[Darthe]

Why do you feel that he will die if you wholly believe that rev is the last scum?

[malpascp]

I am fucking here and not willing to hammer.

Also I will be V/LA until Saturday

Prob posting once a day or less.

[Paid Pyro]

Can someone finish of theRev please? Let's get the flip, hopefully he's scum and finish this thing. Otherwise at least we can move on.