I need some more time to look at the game BC linked where he was a miller. I have homework tonight, so please hold the lynch until mid-day tomorrow at least when I can analyze more thoroughly. A quick look shows that he claimed miller later than RVS and suspicion was thrown because of it. Knowing that, I would expect miller-BC to claim miller in first post in the future, which he did. I wouldn't expect him to claim miller as scum because claiming miller in the past hasn't worked for him. If it was a gambit, it was an extremely risky one. I suppose we knew this already, but his linked game shows that he would be fully aware of the risk. That deserves looking at. At the same time, I do want to note that BC played significantly differently in his linked miller game than he did this one (at least the bit that I read). He seems to more actively and logically scum-hunt in the linked game.
BC, please link your most recent finished scum and non-miller town games if you could.