So my thoughts
–I think Town generally did a good job, all things considered. Shamrock shooting both Bitmap and director was I think the best Pro-Town result you could expect from shooting two Town. Neither were a PowerRole and both were generally going to draw attention away from actual scum with their play. Had Klick not pulled his 1v1 stupidity I think Nekoko probably would have taken the Rope Day 1 and things could have gone even better for Town.
Dayplay wise I think Guile did the best job of the three scum as he drew by far the least pressure in thread. Also I think he did a good job being the ‘jockey’, as it were, who took the reins in organizing the QT. That’s very important. The decision to pre-emptively claim JK Day 3 probably was Guile’s worst decision.
The Nightplay from scum was So-So. Copping Cheery turned out well but as far as I can tell was just a lucky break. I still can’t piece together why you thought killing Greygnarl was the best choice Night 1. Frankly I think that helped Town more than it helped you. And choosing to not kill me is never a good scum decision. Although I do appreciate you choosing to not do so and letting me
--
@Distrubed
– I think in the Mafia QT you overestimated how Town I felt you were. The only reason I didn’t pressure you when I replaced in was the relative ease with which you got a large wagon and your join date. Your unvote of Nekoko Day 1 obliterated that shield for me given my read on her.Guile wrote: So I had to come up with a plan to save the game. I figured I had to get Cheery Lynched. But then I paniced and Said I blocked Disturbed. 10 minutes later I realized my 2nd fatal mistake in which I should have said that I blocked Cheery instead. That would have gotten us a better chance of winning.
That would not have mattered. With you and Cheery ending up claiming against each other the worst outcome for Town is to give scum the chance to get their hands on the Jailkeep without using the Nightkill. Had you claimed to have jailed Cheery we still would have lynched Disturbed for the same reasons we did yesterday.
I think really a better choice might have been to not Counter-claim and see what Cheery did first. It might have been the case that he didn’t claim immediately in which case you might have been able to push a mislynch on Potato’s slot. Now if he claimed you were screwed but I think once he claimed you were screwed by PoE anyway.
Om wrote: I agree with this.
Well in the future I will definitely check to see if you are in games I replace into because your whiny emo attitude is a pain in the rear to deal with.
