Open 42 - Friends and Enemies - (Game Over) before 495

[Shanba]

Mod Post: End of Day Vote Count

The Fonz[3](Sikario8, Shanba, Phate)

Not Voting[2](Samruc, The Fonz)

---

The Fonz, mafia

, was lynched.

Send in night choice(s) within 48 hours max, I'll start day tomorrow if I have everything by then

Well, at the very least, if you're scum so is fonz

[Guardian]

You awake to find

Shanba, mason

in a pool of blood and urine. Catch the vile bastard that did this!

[Guardian]

Mod Post: Vote Count

Not Voting[3](Phate, Samruc, Sikario8)

---

I have imposed a roughly three week deadline, ending on December 5th. That should be ample time for the final day. Get to it .

Also: I will likely not be doing vote counts this day. With three alive, I'm confident you all can keep track .

[Shanba]

Alas.

Time to join my siblings in paradise, I guess.

[Phate]

Vote: Samruc

[Samruc]

Sigh.

We're at LyLo. It's three *weeks* to deadline, and you have nothing more to say than a vote? You will have to work harder than that...

Vote: Phate

[Phate]

Sigh yourself. We're at LyLo, it's 3 weeks to deadline, I've been an avid supporter of the lynches of the two dead scum from the early stages of their wagons. Think my votes pretty much speak for themselves

I know you're scum, Samruc. Now it's just up to Sikario to hammer you ftw.

[Samruc]

Think my votes pretty much speak for themselves

Sure, but the only thing they say for sure is that you nailed two scum.

I know you're scum, Samruc.

Obviously you can't. Especially since you're wrong.

[Phate]

*pats Samruc on the head*

And they also say that I was on their wagons from the beginning, pointing out every scummy thing they did.

But I have to go now, and there's really not much you can do to cloud the issue. I don't need to defend myself. Sikario just needs to hammer.

[Sikario8]

Happy holidays, everyone.

A WEEK OUT OF SCHOOL!

[Samruc]

Uhm...

Happy holidays, everyone. A WEEK OUT OF SCHOOL!
...
no posting due to school break

Are we going to wait one

week

for this guy?

[Phate]

.....lame.

[Guardian]

Patrick replaces Sikario8...

[Patrick]

Vote: Samruc

[Guardian]

Mod Post: End of Game Vote Count

Samruc[2](Phate, Patrick)
Phate[1](Samruc)

---

Patrick, the most efficient replacement ever, ends the game.

He was

mafia

!

Samruc and Phate die! They were townies.

Mafia win!

[Simenon]

weird.

Also, shanba, you didn't quite make the nomination, sorry. ):

[Guardian]

Mason discussion here: http://www.quicktopic.com/40/H/3mgsBT5sgPg

I don't have any mafia communication, mafia night choices were obvious.

I thought Shanba and Per both played pretty well. Per's townishness won the mafia the game, pretty much. It was fun to mod, and I thank all those who were able to stick through with the game. I can't believe it took so long to lynch Lemming. Also, it seemed to me that masons claiming without threat of lynch was a bad idea.

I'm sorry I stopped doing flavor... life got busy . I hope you all enjoyed! I welcome any suggestions/comments. Thanks for playing!

~Guardian

[Phate]

...Well, that sucks.

[The Fonz]

I think you let finding scum go to your head there, Phate. Certainly, I know that, replacing in, I was firmly of the belief that if I did nothing to tie myself to Per or Samruc, we'd win the game. Like I when i replaced in, all you need to do as scum in a copless game is to convince one town player that one scum is obvtown.

[Phate]

Yeah, I think you're right. After my own analysis and Shanba's analysis, I decided that I knew who the scum were.

[Sammich]

I hate you Shanba.

[Shanba]

I hate you Shanba.

Charming. Hey, at least I got you some scum eventually :\

[Shanba]

Thoughts:

Town was essentially hindered by two mislynches that were completely unavoidable from the way the players had been playing up until that point. If I saw that same behaviour again from another player, yes I would lynch it. Maybe not so much crub, who I wasn't sure on, but deffo Sammich. As such, we were in lylo before we even started.

Lemming/CO as a scumgroup was virtually a given. My analysis stating that was nothing really new - it was the third party that was crucial. As such, it failed. Per did well to avoid being linked to his scumpartners. Phate was overly hasty once he thought he knew, but I'm fairly sure it wouldn't have made any difference if he'd sat down and thought it over anyway. And at least the endgame wasn't long and dithering.

I'm surprised there wasn't more pressure put on my analysis. There were some flaws in it, but noone really looked at them - Sim pointed out one as did Fonz. I suppose the fact that it came to the wrong conclusion mean the scum didn't need to attack it. Hrm. Well, nevermind.

I managed to breadscumb simenon but not Jex. Funny that. Also, the night Jex died we thought that if anyone it was going to be me. Eh. I think I'd have liked Jex alive those last days, if simply because I think her analysis would have been useful.

I seriously had no idea who was scum going into day 3. I literally built up all my suspicions from scratch in that one post. It was quite fun, really. Heh. In future, I would do it differently - first player by player, then pairings, then groupings then rbeak it down to pairings again and then individuals.

That's the second time Friends and Enemies has gone to a 3p endgame. I really like it as a setup. The two scum wins could not be more different, though XD.

[The Fonz]

I'm surprised there wasn't more pressure put on my analysis. There were some flaws in it, but noone really looked at them - Sim pointed out one as did Fonz. I suppose the fact that it came to the wrong conclusion mean the scum didn't need to attack it. Hrm. Well, nevermind.

Not being funny, but I've NEVER seen that kind of analysis work. It's most commonly associated with mneme, who at the end of every game makes a big long self-justifying post on how how his analysis WOULD have worked had scum bussed just a little less, or if he'd read that post a little differently, of if he had managed to avoid getting lynched.

Rest assured: I'd have been all over it if town. As scum, there was no point, since I couldn't possibly get you lynched, and what's my argument gonna be: No, REALLY, I AM scum with Per?

[Shanba]

I'm surprised there wasn't more pressure put on my analysis. There were some flaws in it, but noone really looked at them - Sim pointed out one as did Fonz. I suppose the fact that it came to the wrong conclusion mean the scum didn't need to attack it. Hrm. Well, nevermind.

Not being funny, but I've NEVER seen that kind of analysis work. It's most commonly associated with mneme, who at the end of every game makes a big long self-justifying post on how how his analysis WOULD have worked had scum bussed just a little less, or if he'd read that post a little differently, of if he had managed to avoid getting lynched.

It was Per's inactivity that mucked it up. Obviously <.<

Rest assured: I'd have been all over it if town. As scum, there was no point, since I couldn't possibly get you lynched, and what's my argument gonna be: No, REALLY, I AM scum with Per?

See, the thing is I had no idea how else to get myself back in the game again. I wasn't expecting it to be taken as gospel. Not that I was unhappy, but there we go with the ego thing <.<