Micro 551 — Vanilla-Free Greatest Idea Mafia — Game Over!

[EspeciallyTheLies]

i asked aphix and lucky because i know them and felt i might be able to get a read based on how they reacted to being asked that. i'm usually not around too much on the weekend. i had some trouble following the reads on vedith but had otherwise not really gotten out of RVS myself.

i agree with you about suzune but it's not strong enough yet to add them to my list.

[Bowser]

DAY 1. VOTECOUNT 02.

(1)

Hinduragi

—

Soren

(1)

Chaotic Neutrality

—

Suzune

(0)

gummmybear

—

(1)

aphix

—

EspeciallyTheLies

(0)

Soren

—

(3)

Vedith

—

aphix, gummmybear, Lucky2u

(L-2)

(1)

Suzune

—

Chaotic Neutrality

(0)

EspeciallyTheLies

—

(1)

Lucky2u

—

Vedith

(1)

Not Voting

—

Hinduragi

With

9 alive

, it takes

5 votes

to lynch.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2015-12-04 15:30:52)

(Fri Dec 4 @ 3:30:00 PM EST).

NOTES.

If this is wrong, let me know.
Hey, look at that, everyone's posted now.

[Lucky2u]

Hey, look at that, everyone's posted now.

thanks mod.

i asked aphix and lucky because i know them and felt i might be able to get a read based on how they reacted to being asked that. i'm usually not around too much on the weekend. i had some trouble following the reads on vedith but had otherwise not really gotten out of RVS myself.

are you really confident enough to develop a read on me based on the "are you scum?" question?

[Suzune]

The three you are fishing about apix, gummy, and chaotic. To be fair my vote is sitting on chaotic right now. however I do not think any of the three mentioned have really done enough of anything to read them, just posted one random comment. To be fair there is something to say about voting inactives like gummy complained about and there is also something to be said about going for the policy lynch like apix. So if I had to extrapolate reads bass on those fsctors I could but for now they are all kind of null.

[aphix]

Actually Vedith. If I policy lynched everyone that called me scum when I wasn't scum ... I'd be lynching everyone. No one calls me scum when I'm scum. So that's fine. Policy lynches are for people that I think are better off lynched, then playing the game. That's why I policy lynch.

ETL. No, pay attention to what I've written.

Also pedit, there is a bunch of crap since I started typing this. I'm busy at work didn't get finished. I am working all night. Might be on after 11 PST. Still think policy lynching Vedith is right.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I'm not interested in lynching vedith at this very moment. he's not on my policy lynch list either.

[aphix]

I'm fine with Suzune too at this point. I'd lynch that. Like, I wouldn't spend too much time on the noose but some barbed wire should be fine right?

[EspeciallyTheLies]

nah. pick someone else.

[Hinduragi]

Yeah. That's not gonna happen.

[Hinduragi]

Mod: I'm not voting currently

[Bowser]

Mod: I'm not voting currently

Will fix, but please note that it's easier for me to see them if you put them on their own line.

[Chaotic Neutrality]

Are we really just setup speculating? There's a wagon on Vedith already and scum is almost guaranteed to be on it.

[Hinduragi]

Are we really just setup speculating? There's a wagon on Vedith already and scum is almost guaranteed to be on it.

Noone's setup speculating. Who do you think is scum?

[Soren]

at least 5 people must be town for the game to be valid, correct?

hm. i suppose i'd be fine lynching from {chaotic, gummy, aphix, soren, suzune}. let's narrow this down a bit. vedith, lucky, hindu - what are your thoughts on those people?

According to the special notes, it is at least two town players.

[Hinduragi]

Lol scum vs scum arguments where everyone knows what side the other is on. I'll now be taking bids to buy my vote.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

at least 5 people must be town for the game to be valid, correct?

hm. i suppose i'd be fine lynching from {chaotic, gummy, aphix, soren, suzune}. let's narrow this down a bit. vedith, lucky, hindu - what are your thoughts on those people?

According to the special notes, it is at least two town players.

Has marquis changed it? Wiki says no valid game unless at least half the list is town.

[Hinduragi]

at least 5 people must be town for the game to be valid, correct?

hm. i suppose i'd be fine lynching from {chaotic, gummy, aphix, soren, suzune}. let's narrow this down a bit. vedith, lucky, hindu - what are your thoughts on those people?

According to the special notes, it is at least two town players.

Has marquis changed it? Wiki says no valid game unless at least half the list is town.

I checked right after that was posted because I, too, thought town had the majority of votes. All we need is for no single anti-town faction to hold a majority of votes and at least two town and one anti-town roles to be picked. Also, apparently daytalk is active.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

blaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah. that doesn't help me at all.

[Soren]

Hindu is pretty town. Though I don't like him pressing on Lucky for taking 10 minutes to make another post instead of 5. People have other priorities. Regardless he acknowledges that it is a dead end and moves on.
I'm okayish with what Suzune is doing so far. But not enough for a town read.
Vedith is mainly just cheekily responding to people who wants to lynch him.
Aphix' policy lynch seems to be based on a personal grudge. Yeah, not following that.
ETL seems to be keeping a level head in all this.

Lucky discarded a mafia card and claims to have gotten a werewolf and compulsive childkiller card. Looking at how anti town the compulsive childkiller is, I can see how Lucky would choose that for his alignment instead. But that would only be the case if his other card is town. But since he got a werewolf card I can easily see him taking the werewolf alignment and taking the compulsive childkiller card so that he gets a free kill if there is an innocent child.

Anyways this is just speculations at this point as I would need to know what his werewolf card is first to determine whether his werewolf role/ability is more favorable.

[Hinduragi]

Vote: Chaotic Neutrality

In all honesty, I want to see how this game's night phase plays out. Is it usually chaos? Sounds fun.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Lucky discarded a mafia card and claims to have gotten a werewolf and compulsive childkiller card. Looking at how anti town the compulsive childkiller is, I can see how Lucky would choose that for his alignment instead. But that would only be the case if his other card is town. But since he got a werewolf card I can easily see him taking the werewolf alignment and taking the compulsive childkiller card so that he gets a free kill if there is an innocent child.

from my POV i don't see the second situation as a choice lucky would likely make because it's not useful compared to his discard, if he really wanted to be an anti-town faction. he could have taken mafia and used the ww card as the ability. compulsive child killer is a risky card to claim, and his claiming it makes him more likely to be telling the truth.

[Hinduragi]

Lucky's town. That tree isn't even worth barking up anymore.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

ok, i dont really expect to make it to endgame here, and my usual scum hunting methods are useless. i probably should have taken mafia but meh.

i'm a dayvig

and bowser says my shot wont end the day. so how about we make this useful and yall tell me whose flip you think would be the most helpful.

[Hinduragi]

Uhhh, vedith's flip would be most helpful but I'm not confident about any reads right now, man. You should've saved that shit for later LOL. Do you have infinite shots?

[Lucky2u]

oh... I guess we're moving to the speed round then...

I'd say Vedith's. it ends that conversation right now and there is a chance he is scum.