Open 626: Pick Your Poison(TOWN WIN)

[Lowell]

Also FWIW I like antihero and ranger, and dislike titus. she's trying hard to put the brakes on KAAG wagon even though she's on it, and wants me to get into a meta-discussion. Both are diversions.

[KickAssAndGiggle]

Discrediting posts from KAAG

Examples? Oh...no...that would be asking waaaaay too much.

[KickAssAndGiggle]

There is a guy who has one post, total, with zero votes.

I, the center of attention, put there by myself willingly, am "under pressure".

My scum motivation is?

[KickAssAndGiggle]

All I want to do is save the mislynch,
I'd sacrifice myself, in a pinch.
But not going to make scum's job easy,
Doing that would make me queasy.

[KickAssAndGiggle]

(If I am scum...imagine what my partners will say to me if I survive today!!! Gotta be worth keeping me around just for the Mafia PT at end of game...)

[Titus]

Discrediting posts from KAAG

Examples? Oh...no...that would be asking waaaaay too much.

Literally just quoted one.

[Titus]

Also FWIW I like antihero and ranger, and dislike titus. she's trying hard to put the brakes on KAAG wagon even though she's on it, and wants me to get into a meta-discussion. Both are diversions.

No, I am not trying to put the brakes on the KAAG wagon. I know you haven't played with me much, but I want to verify if my reads are right. Reaching out to players I respect is a good way to do that. As scummy as KAAG is, People have told me my confbias ruins games. I have had flaws such as Machina and I don't ever want anyone to think avoiding the mistakes of the past = attempting to derail a wagon.

[Voidedmafia]

...what...?

voided you're not a newb don't pull that shit w/ me

Not talking to you, Anti.

This is an awful vote.
VOTE: voidedmafia

The purpose was to get reactions, so it's not like I did this willy-nilly. If I had actually hammered, then I'd get it, but KAAG's panic is rather telling, and it doesn't look like town-panic to me.

The facepalm post after KAAG's claim is a problem for me. Frankly, my thought about KAAG's claim was "okay, who gives a shit" or "great, now I actually have to think about this." If he's VT, so what, it limits scum targets by one? when they already have to kill the IC anyway? If he's scum, then good, I'm glad he claimed VT. Your reaction is of someone who immediately believes the claim and feels the need to be theatrical about its harmfulness. Both are scummy.

that's nowhere near the most theatrical reaction to a panic claim. I thought it was reasonable fairly reasonable. Why do you think it's theatrical?

There is a guy who has one post, total, with zero votes.

I, the center of attention, put there by myself willingly, am "under pressure".

My scum motivation is?

So, what exactly is your point here? Other than being a rather terrible deflection away from yourself (the truthfulness of the statement is irrelevant) because this mention of someone else nothing having any votes while you do isn't really an argument.

[Smudger]

Going to read and catch up tomorrow. Busy day today

[Not_Mafia]

Kickass is on L-1? Awesome

VOTE: Kickass

[Flying Cake Punch]

So help me I actually think KAAG is town based on these last few posts

UNVOTE: kickass

VOTE: flying

The facepalm post after KAAG's claim is a problem for me. Frankly, my thought about KAAG's claim was "okay, who gives a shit" or "great, now I actually have to think about this." If he's VT, so what, it limits scum targets by one? when they already have to kill the IC anyway? If he's scum, then good, I'm glad he claimed VT. Your reaction is of someone who immediately believes the claim and feels the need to be theatrical about its harmfulness. Both are scummy.

There's nothing theatrical about a facepalm emote. It's an appropriate reaction to someone claiming on page 3. And I don't "immediately believe the claim", that's why the vote is still on Kickass.

-SC

[AlwaysInnocent]

Why are people in such a hurry to lynch KAAG?

[Not_Mafia]

{Flying Cake Punch, Lowell}
{acryon, Titus}
{Smudger, Karnage, Antihero}
{BROseidon}
{Voidedmafia}
{KickAssAndGiggle}

VOTE: KickAssAndGiggle.
To those not voting KickAssAndGiggle: shame on you.

based on what... treat me like a six year old ... spell it out for me????

VOTE: Smudger

[AlwaysInnocent]

VOTE: Not_Mafia

[Not_Mafia]

Whoah

[AlwaysInnocent]

First trying to hammer someone this early and then voting someone for asking a reasonable question?

[AlwaysInnocent]

Also FWIW I like antihero and ranger,

and dislike titus. she's trying hard to put the brakes on KAAG wagon even though she's on it

, and wants me to get into a meta-discussion. Both are diversions.

I agree with this part. It's a little odd.

[Antihero]

oh jeez ralph wiggum and i are not going to get along this game are we...?

[Antihero]

actually liking titus so far

Not talking to you, Anti.

well i'm talking to you

claiming is a pretty appropriate reaction to being at l-1. i'll give the flying hydra the benefit of the doubt here w/ them thinking it's somehow incriminating, but i can't figure out why you think it is. the whole "panic" thing isn't really doing anything for me either; it feels similar to the "flail" buzzword that was all the rage a few years ago (it sucked as a thing to base reads on then and it sucks now).

Antihero, convince me your obvious town today. Discrediting posts from KAAG make it really hard for me to vote elsewhere.

yeah... aside from ranger's implicit scumread of kaag's first/early posting, this is actually the only legit criticism i've heard of kaag so far.

So, on a scale of 1 - 10 Ranger, how embarrassed will you be when:

A) I flip town,
B) Everyone sees your D1 reads are twaddle?

7? 8?

shitting on ALL of rangers reads instead of just her vote is kind of weird given he's voting voided and he hasn't rly specified reads of many other ppl. that said i still think the odds are in favor of kaag being town and the angles everyone else is taking are just crap.

[AlwaysInnocent]

Well, I think KAAG doesn't know Ranger. The first time I played with her, her early read lists bothered me too. Then you figure out she drops them mainly for reactions.

[Varsoon]

VOTE: Kickass
I'm passing IC judgment here; this guy could use a lynch.

[Not_Mafia]

Is KAAG scum or annoying>

[Varsoon]

Doesn't matter.

[AlwaysInnocent]

Is KAAG scum or annoying>

Annoying is not a valid reason to lynch someone.

[AlwaysInnocent]

Besides, I disagree about that. I don't think he's that annoying.