Ok, can you lay out what you actually think is scum about mastina? She's being silly, but there's definitely no scum motivation in it.
I did earlier, I'll restate the highlights. Her "theory" of who Pine picked is pointless and scummy because for all we know, Pine RNGed his picks. And her pick to go for nacho seems like scum trying to pick off a good town early, or bussing (which I now doubt).
Fate's push on Nacho is pretty garbage, I think that's a safe bet for buddies with mastin scum. Which would make Nacho town, but nothing he's posted has given me a townvibe, so null for now, town if either fate or mastin scumflips.
I think fate would be a better candidate than mastina is, for actually jumping onto the Mastina bullshit train as a supposedly veteran player.
Abstract: Beginning scum lean for fence sitting behavior
Post 187, Para 1: My first impression is a subtle distancing with dreal. I mainly don't like the fact that that the way Jin i setting up his reads in a way that they can change quite easily. With Dreal, he says that normally he'd look scummy but he'll null him until he comes under heat. This reads to me as a set up to a bus if the situation arises.
Post 187, Para 3: To continue the idea that formulated in my head, here he said Mastin would have been a town lean but he's willing to not read town and say she's scum. I think again that it's just early game set up to allow him to sway his opinion on a player to follow what the town thinks so he doesn't come under much suspicion.
Post 187, Para 4: To answer Jin's question, he answers it in the prelude to giving the question. Jin specifically stated that he believed what Mastin was doing so the purpose of asking if Mastin's post being genuine or fabricated has me puzzled.
Post 187, Para 5: This paragraph, I don't believe in because Mastin's reasoning is basically focusing on Nacho as the main threat and if he's not scum, then ergo Mastin is scum. That's a dangerous gambit to put oneself as scum and makes her the center of attention. I don't doubt that Mastin can handle being center of attention as scum but she's right in saying that as scum, it's not smart to make yourself prime lynching material.
Post 208: I'm looking at this post as a reason to not give a definitive statement as to what he thinks about Mastin's alignment. You can attempt to come to the conclusion that she's town for saying to lynch her on D2 if she's wrong or push an angle that it's scum making it all for info manipulation latter down the road. Either way, either option has to sound better in your mind and not giving a statement about what you actually think is continuous fence sitting like I've pointed out earlier.
02. BTD6_MAKER
Spoiler: Big Truck Driver 6_
Abstract: Beginning Scum Lean
Post 104 and Post 115: Together I'm not seeing genuine concern in thinking Mastin is scum but is finding an excuse to vote mastin. First he votes at 7:03 AM EST and says she's most likely to be scum with Pine because they've played together a long time ago. Then after 100 posts and 12 hours later, he continues to vote Mastin in light of all the discussion that has occurred, he doesn't put in further input continuing to prove his theory, it's a simple vote and he bounces.
03. TheRealGin-N-Tonic
Spoiler: The Town Drunk
Read that name lmao
04. Nachomamma8
Spoiler: NachoDaddy
Abstract: No Read
One Post saying he'll check in tomorrow, will update once a sufficient read can be produced.
05. Fate
Spoiler: Karma
Abstract: Confused
I remember talking in the queue that playing a game with Fate was a pain and I'm starting to understand why.
I'll be honest and say I'm having a hard time getting a read from his slot.
Only thing that spiked my mind is him saying he had no history with Pine when after what was probably a waste of my life, he had these games he played with him:
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=21228
viewtopic.php?f=54&t=19615
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=19355
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=18662
06. drealmerz7
Spoiler: The Real Dreal
07. Monokuma (Nahdia + Road Kamelot)
Spoiler: Didn't even know this was a hydra lmao
08. mastina
Spoiler: Mastin Infinite
09. Aeronaut
Spoiler: Astronaught
10. Prism
Spoiler: Pink Floyd
11. SirCakez
Spoiler: Why America has a weight problem
12. Vaxkiller
Spoiler: Unvacinnated
13. pisskop
Spoiler: kisspop
So you have two reads total? And they're both slight scum reads?
In post 480, TheRealGin-N-Tonic wrote:If scum!Mastin, I'm seeing that she would have continued to justify a vote by saying I'm a lazy player or just a scum 'faking town behaviour' by producing a reads list and not finishing it, but I think the most damning thing that obliterates that accusation is that I was able to pull up a saved draft and hit upload in a mere two minutes.
There is also no way I could have written all those spoiler tags, formatted all my posts from before and came up with the puns for the other half of the player list without having done this beforehand with the intent of continuously filling out my book of reads.
LAMIST
Also, are you saying that Mastina is scum here? Because in your readslist thingy, she was one of the empty spoilers that made me die a little inside every time I opened them.
In post 422, Aeronaut wrote:So one of BTD6 is probably scum, and one is probably town. Curious how mastina reacts to this, since she's the all-powerful pine-whisperer.
I'd say you're full of shit, and think it's scum shit not town shit.
I feel as if nacho!scum could have very easily pushed the opposite narrative as mastina, and tried to push it back on them instead of doing what he's doing here and trying to pull them out of their fixation and onto actual scum hunting. E.g Nacho is p clearly town in this post.
That would've been a scumclaim from Nacho, so no. He's not clearly town for the post.
What is he?
Well I just gave my word to not say.
I actually don't see how it would be a scum claim from his perspective. I know there's no way I could possibly comprehend the narrative you have going on in your head, but please try. I don't understand how you've ruled out the idea that you and nacho could both be town. If you say no, you haven't ruled it out, then him scumreading you would not be a scum claim.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 3:19 pm
by SirCakez
Fate jumping on lurkers is terrible
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 3:27 pm
by camn
In post 605, Fate wrote:Wait is camn allowed to post freely too or is that just flavor <_<
Um, this is MY FREAKING CHALET. I do what I want.
And right now I want microfiche.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 4:08 pm
by Pine
Little fish. Got it.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 4:56 pm
by camn
It's RECORDS you fool.
I have very detailed files on everyone here.
I will discover who has betrayed me.
In post 611, camn wrote:It's RECORDS you fool.
I have very detailed files on everyone here.
I will discover who has betrayed me.
I don't understand...I'm not sure you could even fit a sentence on that fish, not even with the tiniest pen. You must have murdered an entire lake's worth of guppies for your files on these saps.
Monster.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 6:22 pm
by Prism
I don't have time to catch up today but people are going to have to start explaining these townreads on drealm. I don't see it at all.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 6:26 pm
by Pine
Actually, I'd be SRing him pretty hard. He isn't raging at anything yet.
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2017 6:27 pm
by Pine
And come on, people. This game has slowed down enough that I'm not actually ignoring my other games.
