Potentially Chosen (Scum win)

[Ether]

Day 2, Votecount 5

---

2 BigYoshiFan (nancy, Firebringer)
2 nancy (BigYoshiFan, DeathRowKitty)
1 DeathRowKitty (Treesort)
1 Firebringer (RadiantCowbells)

1 Unvote (Equinox)

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
The deadline is in (expired on 2017-02-20 22:37:00), or at :37.

---

[BigYoshiFan]

Sigh... what did I say?

[Firebringer]

Eh, me thinks it's slightly weird that you think you're chosen and townread RC despite them voting you.

like why do you think this is weird Yoshi?

[Equinox]

Eh, me thinks it's slightly weird that you think you're chosen and townread RC despite them voting you.

How so?

(ELI5.)

[nancy]

not sure yet rc tbh

if he's town i think it's a safe mislynch though

[Treesort]

DRK, can we talk about your nancy read?

I'm concerned because the thing you seem to be scum reading her for is exactly the thing that I thought was the most town about her; I first thought she was just trying to play a "hyperactive flood the thread with reads" game and thought that her lack of justification for anything (not the way she did justify her reads when she got around to it) was what made her scum.

[Treesort]

like why do you think this is weird Yoshi?

Scum has to get a chosen townie lynched to win the game, this means pushing on one of them; if you're chosen someone pushing on you and not explaining the read is certainly an issue.

Pretty much down to lynch inside DRK/BYF/RC.

[Equinox]

if he's town i think it's a safe mislynch though

*twitch*

[DeathRowKitty]

since nancy is seemingly definitely not getting lynched today and i'm in no sort of building-a-case mood i will give my vote to anyone who knows how to make me beg~

[Treesort]

I also don't really think she would have said "this wagon is scum motivated", referring to herself.

[BigYoshiFan]

Cuz, makes sense for scum to want to lynch the chosens at this moment, and if you're so convinced you are chosen... I dunno, I'm not getting much outta these posts and I don't want to look like I'm lurking or not giving a crap.

[RadiantCowbells]

This firebringer chosen thing feels really dumb to me.

[RadiantCowbells]

I think Fire's just scum and we're wasting our time with this.

[nancy]

if he's town i think it's a safe mislynch though

*twitch*

if you're not aware that mislynch might end the game right here then you're not playing to win

[DeathRowKitty]

DRK, can we talk about your nancy read?

I'm concerned because the thing you seem to be scum reading her for is exactly the thing that I thought was the most town about her; I first thought she was just trying to play a "hyperactive flood the thread with reads" game and thought that her lack of justification for anything (not the way she did justify her reads when she got around to it) was what made her scum.

i'm having trouble figuring out what you want me to respond to this with, unless you want me to just like fully explain everything about my read in response to it

[Treesort]

I think Fire's just scum and we're wasting our time with this.

Then explain and sell the read to me.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Firebringer

w/e if he flips chosen you can lynch me for it. I think this is way more likely to be scum than anything else in game.

[Firebringer]

like why do you think this is weird Yoshi?

Scum has to get a chosen townie lynched to win the game, this means pushing on one of them; if you're chosen someone pushing on you and not explaining the read is certainly an issue.

Pretty much down to lynch inside DRK/BYF/RC.

I know this.
I know how chosen works.

I want him to read why me think its weird that I would think RC is town for pushing Chosen over everyone else.
RC instantly loses if I flip chosen, so why would he push that super hard when Wheme already tried that?

Like.....I don't know, RC is ballsy but I don't think he would go to that FIRST.

[Treesort]

as far as reads go BYF picking up on the Fire thing feels good to me even though I don't agree with Fire being scum.

[RadiantCowbells]

like why do you think this is weird Yoshi?

Scum has to get a chosen townie lynched to win the game, this means pushing on one of them; if you're chosen someone pushing on you and not explaining the read is certainly an issue.

Pretty much down to lynch inside DRK/BYF/RC.

I know this.
I know how chosen works.

I want him to read why me think its weird that I would think RC is town for pushing Chosen over everyone else.
RC instantly loses if I flip chosen, so why would he push that super hard when Wheme already tried that?

Like.....I don't know, RC is ballsy but I don't think he would go to that FIRST.

this doesn't make sense taking refuge in audacity is my life story as scum.

[Firebringer]

Cuz, makes sense for scum to want to lynch the chosens at this moment, and if you're so convinced you are chosen... I dunno, I'm not getting much outta these posts and I don't want to look like I'm lurking or not giving a crap.

No it doesn't, a flipped chosen immediately applies pressure to those who primarily pushed the chosen.

[Treesort]

i'm having trouble figuring out what you want me to respond to this with, unless you want me to just like fully explain everything about my read in response to it

that'd actually be pretty amazing, if you're up for it.

[DeathRowKitty]

I also don't really think she would have said "this wagon is scum motivated", referring to herself.

i don't think it would have made sense for her to basically quickhammer and then say that as either alignment

i think it makes more sense from scum panicking to bus than town rushing to switch votes though

[Equinox]

if you're not aware that mislynch might end the game right here then you're not playing to win

I am. I'm simply ~going with the flow~ because I don't know what else to do -- I definitely did not join a Mafia game to pick my brains apart and that is exactly what's happening.

[Treesort]

also good lord, Regfan immediately disagreed with what I pointed out about BYF.

this game