In post 473, Wonderwell wrote:
This is the correct play to make today.
FA claiming Percival made this game harder by several orders to magnitude. The good news is that Chemist is morgana, it makes no sense for chemist to be anything else than morgana, and a chemist flip will allow us to gamesolve immediately.
-Farkran
To be even more clear, if you are referring to this post - which i think is the only one where i addressed you specifically - it did not imply that you played poorly. It was part of the wifom to let the PR stay hidden, because at the time we had you as either persival or VT and we didn't want the info to be safely published.
Note that, if scum were to pay any attention to our play, it would have been impossible for us to be persival and therefore our counterclaim is completely void. I still don't know how scum could possibly believe that Wonderwell as a persival made any sense, but before shooting in the dark note that we have been considered as merlin just slightly less than klick and we still lynched all scum, so i wouldn't describe this town as a group that played "badly" overall. Scum had a 20% base chance to guess merlin randomly, they managed to narrow the pool to 3 people and raise their chances to 33% but i also don't know why they ruled out of chemist.
pedit: if we can restart our discussion on neutral ground, without any offense given or taken from both sides - i know that our reads weren't perfect, but i mean, we were VTs and you were merlin. Of course we could be way more accurate with our reads, but i think you could have had a bit more faith in the town lategame instead of drawing attention, that's the "biggest" mistake you made in this game imo and it's not such a huge mistake to call you a gamethrower, not nearly enough
