Normal 2302: Magical Girls Magical Mafia Thread

[Elements]

I wouldn't be surprised either if efp is gated somehow and there's another gated vig somewhere?

[Save The Dragons]

i think elements is probably toast d2 if not the vig shot

vig is probably gated whether or not there's another vig tbh though i don't want to get too much into setup spec, i could see an ungated vig vs. 3 ways to protect ourselves. (1bp 2doc shots)

im fine with an HPE kill.

[Morning Tweet]

To be honest, not sure who Emperor will shoot

He expressed that he wont shoot curiousdog/Oopsie/Tweet/Towwl.

he voted Elements, and Elements was the CW

To be honest he's probably going to shoot you

[Morning Tweet]

I don't think there'll be two vigs cause that'd borderline be bad for town, but I'm just guessing

I'm definitely hoping you werent supposed to be the godfather for a gunsmith but that was my first guess

I agree, the vig (or if theres multiple) is probably gated with something

[Morning Tweet]

Morning kills HighPrincessErinys

Elements heals .... ? Dragons

I'm not really sure if it's even worth to heal Dragons. It probably is cause the risk is negligible. I doubt we're going to get punished with a tracker/watcher or some nonsense if our only PRs are gated doctor + bulletproof. It'd be kind of odd. I don't think Dragons will get shot though

You could heal someone else in the hopes a watcher sees it and it looks bad lol, I don't know. You being gated (and the lack of us having much power) hopefully means there won't be too many bullets flying or strong investigative results.

To be honest, Erinys' results makes 2 of us look really bad I have decent hopes that it holds a lot of town's power

Let me know if you have input on who should kill and Ele's action. I don't think there's much reason not to use the gated doc action. I don't think Elements should do the kill in the case of rbing/jailkeeping, probably. Dragons or me could perform the kill i dont really have a preference

there's definitely not a watcher, it'd be a strange fit. Watch, vigilante.. rolecop.. our doctor.. and just the kills. Maybe it's gated and watcher is meant to be the protective.

TLDR:
I don't think HPE is going to get protected. I think Ele could reasonably get interfered with, but not much reason not to use the action

[Morning Tweet]

Could be woefully wrong and HPE gets watched or bodyguarded or healed but it felt to me like they were on the brink of elimination to the point where people would be surprised to see it turn up dead

Ele probably could get shot at or investigated. its not likely that they get roleblocked or jailkept but its probably within the realm of possibility

[Save The Dragons]

i think the risk of a watcher is almost enough to make me not want to do the doc protect but maybe that's too town powerful?

[Thestatusquo]

Night actions are locked as of this post.

[Morning Tweet]

M eh you can def blame me if watcher

If we get punished for the only active PR we have i'd be surprised. But i dunno whats in the setup so possible. meeehhh

[Morning Tweet]

Oh ok Ele shot yeah predictable

This is going to be interesting to wiggle out of

Uhhh

[Morning Tweet]

I'm not really sure killing Emperor would be more helpful, kind of need him to shoot town. He can't do anything on D2 whereas Erinys could guilty.

Yes, I could have just let Erinys live and killed in the Ele wagon. I didn't reeeally want Erinys to live though.

Idk

My nightkills always make people surprised

[Morning Tweet]

We couldn't reeeeallly respond to or stop Ele dying I guess I should have mentally prepared more for having to deal with how hard half the game scumread them. I was mostly hoping Ele didn't get shot immediately and limmed the next day instead, pretty bad plan on my part, now we're both just hard defenders out of 4 of Ele and ele is dead

DGB's comment is more or less right, scum mastermind

[Morning Tweet]

Lol sorry for teaming up with Elements to create the perform storm of bad day and night play in order to crash and burn at speedrun pace

[Morning Tweet]

Lol sorry for teaming up with Elements to create the perfect storm of bad day and night play in order to crash and burn at speedrun pace

[Morning Tweet]

I think it was probably correct to kill Emperor by virtue of "he will be confirm town" but I honestly felt the same way about HPE where i think they would have gotten progressively more townread and their role would eventually guilty. I should have just let it ride though i guess since it only hurts me to be fair. Didnt really matter if it guilties ele

Sorry

[Morning Tweet]

I still have this lingering feeling where I don't want to shoot Emperor which makes no sense considering he gives town 2x liminations, I don't really know whts wrong w/ my mafia brain. It's probably a lot worse to give town +1 vig shot over leaving HPE in. Probably should have shot him first.

I wasn't holding my breath on Emperor shooting HPE but technically he could have helped there, didnt catch that of course. I just dunno, I don't pay enough attention to the right things

[Morning Tweet]

Starting to think getting clowned on for your night actions isn't part of the scum experience and is just part of the "terribly mechanically inclined" experience, in which i reprise my role as lead actor each and every time as scum

[Morning Tweet]

Yeah I guess Emperor shooting slots is more helpful that HPE potentially guiltying me. I kind of wanted Emperor to holster/shoot town at some point in the game but my dumbass forgets that Emperor shooting town is actually better for town than Emperor not shooting, that's just free eliminations

[Morning Tweet]

How do you even forget something like that??

my feelings hurt critically

I was hoping Ele lives a little longer? Lol. I dont know mate

[Morning Tweet]

If Ele lived longer it'd have been better to shoot Emperor then still though so

[Morning Tweet]

DGB thinking im a master strategist is just insult to injury oooooooooooooooooooowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

[Morning Tweet]

So probably goes without saying but bussing Ele probably would have been workable (Although bussing not my thing so i probably would've been super obvious about it and gotten nowhere anyway)

We had the hint of "Bullets probably coming" and "we can't protect Elements out of the three of us" so i guess, yes in hindsight could have just played around that

I'm not sure why i was married to the idea of hard townreading Elements and continuing that fight..... if Ele had a vest or wasn't the doctor i think we mightve had a case to keep them going (Everyone thinks there's a roleblocker threat for example), but should've known Ele was going to get shot

..

The nightkill is bad but had Ele lived and all three of us kept going... well it's still bad, cause that's an extra chance to shoot Ele on N2. I still think HPE would have survived for a long while and gotten a result in time, but that was not nearly as immediate a problem as half of the town eating Ele alive

Emperor shooting a townie n1 then getting killed n2 I don't even rlly know if that is more beneficial than killing Emp n1, its still lowering the PoE, more vig shots = good and i forgot that for some reason. Maybe I was hoping he was gated and just let Emp live all game? I was definitely very prepared to just never shoot Emperor tbh. Just not a good strategy here at all

although the nk obv didnt really have any real impact on the rest of the game (other than maybe HPE being a problem if it lived)

..

Sigh sorry Dragons

I feel like admitting you're bullshitting your reads is certainly a ballsy approach

Go big or go home

we seem to have sprung for the latter

[Save The Dragons]

kill emperor

I'm gonna pretend I missed the deadline

I think I'm drawing dead here anyway

[Save The Dragons]

I'm sorry to the team I wasn't very helpful this game