Cheese Thief | Game 1 Over

[Mizzytastic]

The Night

NDMath wakes at 1am, steals the cheese and picks a follower

No one wakes at 2am

mallowgeno, DragonEater70 wake at 3am, see no cheese, see each other

camelCasedSnivy wake up at 4am, sees no cheese and checks when someone woke up

No one wakes up at 5am

Silverclaw, Skygazer wake up at 6am see no cheese, see each other

---

Thanks for playing everyone. I feel like this is about the worst roll the Cheese Thief could have gotten.

I'd like to apologise for my modding this game. I've been dealing with a family death, leading to me having to look after the house myself while having a bad cold, and I've not been able to do it to my usual standard. I also should have realised changing how voting worked like that resulted in a game breaking scenario. I'd be interested to hear any suggestions for the future.

[camelCasedSnivy]

i was afraid silverclaw was a townie who would vote against me if i called them out on math + silver so i revoked the possibility lol

also mallow what u doing

[camelCasedSnivy]

mizzy was a good mod anyway, i was skeptical about the voting system but glad it was a fair game in the end!

[DragonEater70]

Okay I didn't throw

My initial read of Math was actually perfect.

[DragonEater70]

I literally KNEW Math woke up at 1 AM based on his response to my strategy.

[DragonEater70]

mizzy was a good mod anyway, i was skeptical about the voting system but glad it was a fair game in the end!

Yeah, thanks Mizzy for being a good mod!
And thanks for modding in general, too.

[camelCasedSnivy]

if theres next game ill play again

[Skygazer]

Mizzy your modding was great! I hope stuff gets better soon

uhh I'd like to apologize for suggesting an absolutely breaking strat and messing your game up lol

[DragonEater70]

Mizzy your modding was great! I hope stuff gets better soon

Absolutely agreed

[Mizzytastic]

if theres next game ill play again

I'd like to keep running this if I can get enough players for sure.

And no worries about game breaking strategies, I made a decision to try and bring voting more in line with how this site does Mafia games, but the tie rule makes it very different. It's my first time running it and now I've learned!

[NDMath]

And no worries about game breaking strategies, I made a decision to try and bring voting more in line with how this site does Mafia games, but the tie rule makes it very different. It's my first time running it and now I've learned!

If you want to do public votes you need to both
a) turn majority on and
b) have nobody die if there is a three or more way tie

The biggest problem with the original voting system for this game was that the follower could be forced to vote for the cheese thief & be unable to do anything about it. (and that the game would never end before deadline was reached because it would require somebody agreeing to a loss)


don't think the rand was that bad for me just got unlucky with player's actions (DE picking to RT me, ccs clearing mallow, mallow's activity not bouncing back up).
also the other voting system being in place hurt me in terms of people making reads of what people did on it, but I don't think that changed the outcome of this game at all.

[NDMath]

I literally KNEW Math woke up at 1 AM based on his response to my strategy.

It turned out I should've just truthful claimed but I was very fearful that you woke up at 2am with a peak on me with the way you were phrasing stuff / had the list pointed at 1am
so then the best counterplay I could think of was to claim to have woken up at 2am with you

[DragonEater70]

Btw Snivy for future refrence - mechanical analysis and strategizing like I did this game is absolutely town indicative for me. I can't fake it as scum for the life of me, it's just too hard.

I'm saying this because I thought you should have had an easy TR on me but for some reason you were paranoid of me during the middle of the game.

[DragonEater70]

I literally KNEW Math woke up at 1 AM based on his response to my strategy.

It turned out I should've just truthful claimed but I was very fearful that you woke up at 2am with a peak on me with the way you were phrasing stuff / had the list pointed at 1am
so then the best counterplay I could think of was to claim to have woken up at 2am with you

Lol that makes sense. I WAS trying to trap you, jsyk.

[Skygazer]

oh ya i went with math instead of snivy purely on an instinctual whim

[Silverclaw]

Yeah I felt absolutely trapped and like I could do jack all for that entire game frankly

[mallowgeno]

i was afraid silverclaw was a townie who would vote against me if i called them out on math + silver so i revoked the possibility lol

also mallow what u doing

I refused to be going with consensus on the chance I was correct about Sky/Silver.

Good games, sorry I didn't chat as much as I did