In post 797, halfasleep wrote:
i'd also like to add that a ming red flip like 90% clears black in my eyes based on 37, 70 and 71 since i know cee mirage and myself are both town.
Umm what
putting a pin in this for later
when's later? considering we've got just over a day left on this night phase and you've claimed cop, you should probably just say what you wanna say.
Later is "once I'm home from work" which I am now
And my elaboration is that I have absolutely no idea of how your premise (black = locktown) is supposed to follow from ming saying that her and two other players look towny, in the first couple of pages and with no elaboration. Why is it impossible or even unlikely for scum!ming to fake a TR on scum!black, especially considering that so many people rely on who flipped scum distanced from in the first few pages to look for their buddies?
In post 797, halfasleep wrote:
i'd also like to add that a ming red flip like 90% clears black in my eyes based on 37, 70 and 71 since i know cee mirage and myself are both town.
Umm what
putting a pin in this for later
when's later? considering we've got just over a day left on this night phase and you've claimed cop, you should probably just say what you wanna say.
Later is "once I'm home from work" which I am now
And my elaboration is that I have absolutely no idea of how your premise (black = locktown) is supposed to follow from ming saying that her and two other players look towny, in the first couple of pages and with no elaboration. Why is it impossible or even unlikely for scum!ming to fake a TR on scum!black,
especially considering that so many people rely on who flipped scum distanced from in the first few pages to look for their buddies?
i think people do this because it's often right. speaking for myself, as scum my early posting isn't likely to have much strategy behind it. i'm finding something to say to look involved in the main thread while still getting my bearings and figuring things out in the PT. how often do you say anything about a partner before you've had time to clear it with them behind the scenes, especially when you're still finding your footing in how you're going to be working as a team? i think it's pretty reasonable early scumposting to give 'good vibes' style reads on townies, mostly as tentative hooks for future pocketing if the townie ends up being receptive (but nothing you need to commit to if they're not). it's the kind of thing that can superficially look good - since it's not in scum interest to make any townie too hard to lim - but doesn't marry you to anything solid. sure, scum!ming
could
throw a partner in there in hopes of producing exactly the read i'm making now, but i think it's less likely due to the early thread scum dynamics i was talking about and sometimes the simpler explanation just is the right one.
brief notes since the night'll likely end before I clock out tmrw
provided that CSF dies first (CSF is always the lim if she is still alive), I am still set on eliminating awesomeming
townblock rn is daisy and imaginality for mindmeld, prob also experience/rh9 too
halfasleeps last post seems fair and maybe I was harsh but I don't think people should rely on occam's razor that much, scum can and do choose to focus on buddies and clearing black that quickly still feels v presumptive for me. I don't think it's scummy though and I appreciate the attempt at townhunting
elements cld be low energy scum and her scumpool earlier tonight was surprisingly massive
Oops hi. Prod acknowledged.
This weekend has got away on me a bit.
light_ganski's #807 above is pretty much where I'm at also. Not so sure about experience being town but I'd have them above the neutral line sure.
I'd probably put my current reads as:
light_ganski
OopsyDaisy -, halfasleep ^
Black v, DoctorDrew ^, experience -
---neutral line
Thomith v, Elements v
awesomeming327 -
Cat Scratch Fever
(Trying out a new thing here where ^ means they've become more townread by me since earlier (say just after the cop guilty claim), v means they've dropped and - means no change)
"holy shit this entire time i thought imaginalitys profile was a purple seahorse" - camelCasedSnivy
In post 804, halfasleep wrote:
how often do you say anything about a partner before you've had time to clear it with them behind the scenes, especially when you're still finding your footing in how you're going to be working as a team?
all the time that shit's free townreads. if you let the people on your team control what you say it's gonna become obvious very quickly who's on your team. i'm not saying don't talk to em i talk a lot to my mafia buddies in the pt about overall strategy and the like, but if every comment you make about a partner gets filtered through the mafia pt surely that's not good?
also for those who do think el & i are scum together we've got a game where we were a scumpair together on-site (it's on my wiki page). i use meta as a shield in that game too but in a much more complex overworked way that made it so i could scumread her slot on the condition that another slot would have to be scum in that world.
In post 812, OopsieDaisy wrote:
also for those who do think el & i are scum together we've got a game where we were a scumpair together on-site (it's on my wiki page). i use meta as a shield in that game too but in a much more complex overworked way that made it so i could scumread her slot on the condition that another slot would have to be scum in that world.
Omg Daisy, stop using meta as a defence. Everyone knows that's your red tell!
I agree with everything Elements is posting - Papa Zito
It's scummy as fak tho - Gamma Emerald All my completed games
In post 812, OopsieDaisy wrote:
also for those who do think el & i are scum together we've got a game where we were a scumpair together on-site (it's on my wiki page). i use meta as a shield in that game too but in a much more complex overworked way that made it so i could scumread her slot on the condition that another slot would have to be scum in that world.
Omg Daisy, stop using meta as a defence. Everyone knows that's your red tell!
wowww el are you tryna scum theatre with me again smh
In post 812, OopsieDaisy wrote:
also for those who do think el & i are scum together we've got a game where we were a scumpair together on-site (it's on my wiki page). i use meta as a shield in that game too but in a much more complex overworked way that made it so i could scumread her slot on the condition that another slot would have to be scum in that world.
Omg Daisy, stop using meta as a defence. Everyone knows that's your red tell!
wowww el are you tryna scum theatre with me again smh
If we were going to theatre we'd need to discuss it in the pt first
I agree with everything Elements is posting - Papa Zito
It's scummy as fak tho - Gamma Emerald All my completed games
In post 812, OopsieDaisy wrote:
also for those who do think el & i are scum together we've got a game where we were a scumpair together on-site (it's on my wiki page). i use meta as a shield in that game too but in a much more complex overworked way that made it so i could scumread her slot on the condition that another slot would have to be scum in that world.
Omg Daisy, stop using meta as a defence. Everyone knows that's your red tell!
wowww el are you tryna scum theatre with me again smh
If we were going to theatre we'd need to discuss it in the pt first
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}