Nomic - Codename Phoenix

[Ircher]

VOTE: Nay 327, 328

There's a huge problem w/ 327 and that is that the Standing Committee would surely award one of themselves the points.

[McMenno]

ircher are you against parliamentary democracy

[Ircher]

Well, I am a US citizen.

[Drench]

Well, I am a US citizen.

to be honest this was half the point, to give the elections some stakes
of course there are three members and only one winner......

[Drench]

amendment to 328:

A player wins the game when they have 100 points, unless there is at least one other victory condition in the rules, in which case this rule is superseded.

100 points is dreary but i'm all for having a dreary wincon until we get another better one

[Ircher]

Separation of powers my friend.

The same body that handles dispute shouldn't also decide who wins.

[Drench]

tru

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE: Nay to 327
VOTE: Abstain from 328

[Allomancer]

/in

[Allomancer]

VOTE: Yea: 321, 323, 327
VOTE: Nay: 328

[McMenno]

amendment to 328:

A player wins the game when they have 100 points, unless there is at least one other victory condition in the rules, in which case this rule is superseded.

100 points is dreary but i'm all for having a dreary wincon until we get another better one

amenable

[Ircher]

VOTE: Abstain 328

[StrangerCoug]

Proposal 329: A currency separate from points, called Nomic Dollars and whose symbol is N$, is hereby adopted. Each player starts with N$100 and gains a salary of N$10 every midnight UTC that they are considered active. The salary is not retroactive to the beginning of the game. If this proposal is defeated and there are other proposals that rely on the existence of Nomic Dollars, said proposals are also defeated automatically.

The last sentence is because I can't think of anything else good to do with Nomic Dollars right now.

[StrangerCoug]

Actually, slightly amend Proposal 329 for clarity:

Proposal 329: A currency separate from points, called Nomic Dollars and whose symbol is N$, is hereby adopted. Each player starts with N$100 and gains a salary of N$10 every midnight UTC that they are considered active. The salary is not retroactive to the beginning of the game. Proposals may be made that rely on the existence of Nomic Dollars while this proposal is pending; however, they are defeated automatically if this proposal is defeated.

[Ircher]

Amendment to 329

: A currency separate from points, called Nomic Dollars and whose symbol is N$, is hereby adopted. Each player starts with N$100 and gains a salary of N$10 every midnight UTC that they are considered active. The salary is not retroactive to the beginning of the game.

Proposals may be made that rely on the existence of Nomic Dollars while this proposal is pending; however, they are defeated automatically if this proposal is defeated.

Players pay fines in Nomic Dollars for breaking the rules. The default amount is N$5 (subject to amendment) if unspecified.

Underline is added, strike-through is removed.

[StrangerCoug]

Accept Ircher's amendment to 329

[Ircher]

VOTE: Yea 329

[Cheery Dog]

VOTE: yea 328, nay 327, yea 329

althoguh they hould totally be haschalbux <_<

[Ircher]

Proposal 321 passed (5-2 with 2 A).

Note that Lowell is currently inactivity abstained.....

[StrangerCoug]

Mod: You missed my abstention from 328.

[Drench]

VOTE: aye 329

[Vijarada]

(I meant, why did people elect McMenno....)

#notmypresident

[Vijarada]

Petition the Standing Commitee

Questions presented

1. Should The Standing Committee rules, subsection XI, require 20% of players rounded up or rounded down?
2. Are Combo Points, provided for by rule 321, the same entity as points, provided for by rule 325? Did the moderator have inherent power or power under rule 326, after the election of the Standing Committee, to so rule?
3. Does the provision of rule 314 that states that "if a party ever falls below two players, active or inactive, it is automatically disbanded." mean that a player that falls inactive disbands their party, meaning that at the time of their election, McMenno and Fellisan were not party members, thus changing their treatment under Standing Committee subsection XII?

[Vijarada]

Petition the Standing Committee

no editing LOL

Question Presented

1. Does rule 325, which uses the word "henceforth" as it's timing qualifier, apply to itself, so that Vijarada has one point? Should the moderator be given deference for so ruling?

[Vijarada]

VOTE: No 327
VOTE: Yes 328. 329