In post 169, inspiratieloos wrote:I think Charles had all the information needed to win on his turn, NM also should have had the info, they were the only players who knew RC had the knife in hand before Katy's guess and could have POE'd the rope, everyone should have known the answer after Katy's guess.
I guess? From back reading and looking at the guesses from different POVs (using my same note taking strategy):
From Charles's POV, he knew it was the conservatory and can very safely guess it's the rope (Technically I could have shown RC Peacock on the first suggestion, but then RC guesses Peacock a second time so it's unlikely), but he would have had to guess between White/Peacock to make an accusation. (He should have known it wasn't Green unless he stuck with the possibility RC guessed Peacock after being shown that card, since on the 6th suggestion TGP/Sudo could have only been shown Green if we assume the Rope was the weapon).
TGP had the game solved from his POV though since my guess (Peacock/Revolver/Conservatory) basically told him everything he couldn't figure out by being directly shown a card, but it required a lot of logic to work through that most people would miss unless they kept track of every single guess in addition to the normal detective sheet.
RC only knew the location, but his safest guess was Peacock/Rope/Conservatory anyway (He knew I had the revolver and didn't have the conservatory before his Plum/Knife/Conservatory guess, so guessing Peacock gave him more information. Rope is safer to guess than Wrench since if he's shown the wrench he gets less information about whether or not I have Peacock)
From N_M's POV he also knew it was the conservatory and that I didn't have the revolver, but it could have been White and/or Candlestick. Probably would have been safe to assume that Candlestick wasn't the weapon for the same reason Charles could have, but he still doesn't know the suspect (And before his last guess it could have been Green as well unless he was going with the assumption).
Assembler was probably the furthest from getting sadly, even if he made the Candlestick assumption he still had to solve White/Peacock and Knife/Rope.
so basically to win, Charles, Assembler, and N_M had to correctly assume I had the Candlestick, and RC had to make a lucky (but optimal) guess. TGP should have won technically I guess?
I feel kind of stupid overanalyzing a Clue game though >_> - Thanks again for modding SC!
btw i did find the assets I was talking about so I might set that up later this week (midterms lmfao)