[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 12239199 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Newbie 2037 - Game Over - Mafiascum.net
For those that don’t know, RQS is called Random Questioning Stage and it has its advantages. And this is for everyone in the playerlist. Non answers get scumread.
1. What is your overall mafia experience? Not just on this site.
2. Do you prefer playing scum/wolf or town/village?
3. In your opinion, what are some of the top things to look for when scumhunting?
4. When townhunting?
5. Is it easy or difficult for you to lie?
1 Eh it’s okay I guess not exactly experienced but I know how the game works lol
2 Really depends on my mood but most of the time I like playing town as I like picking who I think the scum is
3 Reactions to posts directed at the certain player
4 How well they try to solve the game
5 Difficult extremely difficult lol
Post
Post #39 (isolation #3) » Tue Oct 20, 2020 8:23 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
Also Italiano I’m not gonna say it’s a scum read on you but the questions on what people look for when town hunting/scum hunting pings me as something a scum would ask to try and play to the townie way each person describes
Ehh, I don’t prefer it. I’d rather jut get to the scumhunting; Actually I don’t like Day 1s cause there’s not a lot to go on and you usually have to get lucky to get scum on the first day.
Italiano do you feel you can scum hunt easier with RQS instead of RVS?
In post 39, MiniMegabyte wrote:Also Italiano I’m not gonna say it’s a scum read on you but the questions on what people look for when town hunting/scum hunting pings me as something a scum would ask to try and play to the townie way each person describes
Is the RQS the basis for your vote or did it influence it at all?
Nah nothing influenced my vote generally a vote that’s made in RVS isn’t influenced by much if anything at all
Post
Post #65 (isolation #8) » Wed Oct 21, 2020 11:30 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 49, ItalianoVD wrote:My take on it is that both RQS and RVS are ways to get to know the players. I think RQS is a more direct way and RVS a more indirect way, but to answer your question yes. I feel RQS helps me understand the players better than RVS, which in turn helps in scumhunting and also townhunting.
Okay that’s a pretty fair point but I just think RQS can be dangerous in terms of telling the scum what you’re looking for in a town/scum person but that’s just my opinion
In post 69, MiniMegabyte wrote:Padwag any chance you could please set an avatar? Just makes it easier to identify your posts
I don't really know how.
Up the top left of the screen next to the private messages there is “user control panel”. Click on that and then click on the tab that says profile and scroll down until you see edit avatar.
In post 49, ItalianoVD wrote:You really think I’d be asking the town how to scum?
You have a good point there I don’t think you would but I would say the same thing to anyone that asked those questions
Can you explain your comment then?
It seems scummy to do but I’ve played with Italiano before so I don’t think they would need to ask for their benefit
What is your read of Italiano at the moment?
Italiano so far is trying to get the game moving in my eyes, even if it is through weird ways like his RQS so as of now i would say they are pretty townie
Post
Post #211 (isolation #25) » Sat Oct 24, 2020 8:57 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 210, Facebones wrote:I'm new to this kind of game and strugglong to reads on everyone, these people seem a lot more experienced. I'm trying to learn what to look for
Thanks for the answer but that question was directed at Padwag as I quoted his posts
Post
Post #276 (isolation #28) » Mon Oct 26, 2020 1:11 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 268, Billy Pilgrim wrote:You realize that wasn't the first wagon to get to E-2 this game right? At 78, I put a wagon to E-2. What happened there?
That one happens later in the game though around the time its happened in a couple of my games
Post
Post #277 (isolation #29) » Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:08 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 262, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:Also, I have no problem with being eliminated, but lets be sensible and give it another calendar day or 2 before we go through the E1 process.
In what universe is town ever okay with being eliminated? Being okay with being eliminated is not game solving at all
Post
Post #296 (isolation #30) » Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:36 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 290, Billy Pilgrim wrote:I dont understand this. Are you saying that the bakslash wagon that you commented on at 97 was the first E-2 wagon of the game? Because my vote was 78, and it put someone to E-2. I just didn't announce it. So im curious why you commented on this wagon but not the one I voted.
I didn’t realise there was one before that one I don’t go back and count votes all the time
Post
Post #354 (isolation #35) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 12:14 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
Sorry I’ve been busy all day and I have an early start in the morning I will get on at some point tomorrow but until then I apologise for not being around
Post
Post #366 (isolation #36) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 11:04 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 351, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:both are still voting for a claimed town PR despite nobody offering a counter.
Well iirc I don’t think I’ve played with you before if I have it’s been a while. I just can’t wrap my head around the thought of a PR that is actually valuable to have to help track down scum being okay with themselves being eliminated especially on D1. And before you go on about explaining the game to me again, I have never played a game with a PR being okay with being eliminated at all let alone a D1 elimination. You say you’re leaving enough information behind for us other townies to work with but Wouldn’t it be better for us to have your help aswell? Until I get an answer to this I am not unvoting
Post
Post #368 (isolation #38) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 11:15 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 351, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:mini RVS votes italiano and they have a chat - excellent distancing posting to make it look like they haven't spoken in a while (posts 15, 36, 37)
We haven’t spoken in a while! And because this is a fairly new player list for me it was good to see someone on there that I had played with before
Post
Post #370 (isolation #40) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 11:19 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 369, MiniMegabyte wrote:Also In regards to post 351 could you please do post tags so I can actually go back and look at them without going through the entire game. Thanks
God dam I hate mobile this post I have fixed up the mistakes
Post
Post #373 (isolation #42) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 10:39 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 372, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:We have played together before, but I don't think you were able to play for long so subbed out early. That was the game I referenced a couple of times where someone was E2 within 20 or so posts.
Right! that does make those references make a bit more sense now. Also yeah wasnt in a good place at that time
Post
Post #374 (isolation #43) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 10:48 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 372, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:Obviously, it's better for town that i'm still involved, but you have to remember that at the time, it was 24 hours to deadline, lots of slots were silent and I was E1 (and don't forget who put me there). I had to claim and I had to explain. I've subsequently been proven right because whenever in the game I flip, there's loads of information to go on.
Right so now that you are starting to make sense to me I am going to start with unvoting. UNVOTE: Norfolk
I am going to say it still amazes me about how you went about it, however if that is the way you play (and like you said you have been proven right before), then who am I to make you change. I just really hope you are right this time
Post
Post #375 (isolation #44) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 10:48 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 372, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:As for the post tags, i'll try to do that, but i'm exclusively playing on mobile and using anything other than Quick Reply takes me an age. I'll try to do it from now on, though.
Also thank you. I know its hard on mobile trust me. It just makes it easier is all
Post
Post #377 (isolation #46) » Sun Nov 01, 2020 11:35 pm
Postby MiniMegabyte »
Current Reads List (Updated since my most recent posts)
Spoiler:
Town
Norfolk
(Non-CC Claim Tracker)
Billy
(AT the beginning it was a bit strange that they had their votes everywhere but as they got further into the game they are probably one of the few people that I know of actually giving the game a kick forward. I see this by them asking a lot of questions and attempting to engage others.)
Facebones
(Asks a lot of questions and tries to get the game moving. Again one of the few people to do so and just seems townie atm)
Rockhopper
(Makes a lot of comments and asks people to gain information through reactions and this to me seems like a pretty townie move along with their post of the unlikely pairings from what they think. It seems as though they arent afraid of sharing thoughts which is pretty townie in my eyes)
Null
Backslash
(Very few posts but there is two of them that really contradict each other one of the posts being the answers to Italiano's RQS 46 and 116 - Though this could just be the truth but to me their answer to question 3 really contradicts their next post after that. While they are contradicting I do think that post 169 is a townie post as they are throwing their thoughts out there. This is why they are null for now because i am just not sure.)
Italiano
(I dont really know what to think about them something seems weird to me but I cant really explain it. Its bad I know i am going to do a full ISO dive on them to see if anything can give me some real direction)
Wiyvern
(Not many posts so really cant get anything from what they have said apart from their read list and its not really somethign i would like to go off of at this point but it is good they shared their reads with everyone.)
Scum
Dunnstral
(Very few posts and barely any content. Now this is going to seem very OMGUS but really look at their ISO they vote Norfolk outta gut-which isnt too bad- and then unvotes Norfolk because of no CC which is fair. However they dont give any reason as to why they vote me apart from the points made from two other players are "good enough for a vote". These are the only content points and one of them is sheeped)
Based on this read list i am going to put my vote here
Post
Post #389 (isolation #49) » Mon Nov 02, 2020 1:30 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 351, Norfolk Boy1 wrote:I'm liking the look of a mini/italiano scum team and these are worth reading again:
*mini RVS votes italiano and they have a chat - excellent distancing posting to make it look like they haven't spoken in a while (posts 15, 36, 37)
*mini 'questions' RQS and italiano doesn't grill the responses as he did with the Town Tracker (posts 40, 49, 64 and 65)
*both call out Dunstrall in sync (posts 61 and 66)
*mini tries to wriggle out of her earlier 'questioning' (post 98)
*both pressure Rockhopper in sync (posts 99 and 102)
*Italiano chucks out a townread on mini with no reasoning beyond "she's always been town before" (post 171)
Also, both are still voting for a claimed town PR despite nobody offering a counter. Billy at least offered a reason for not believing my claim, even though my claim has a 50/50 chance of being immediately uncovered (which it won't, because it's the truth, as they both know).
Post
Post #390 (isolation #50) » Mon Nov 02, 2020 1:31 am
Postby MiniMegabyte »
In post 346, wiyvern wrote:MiniMegabyte- Scum. I flip flopped on her originally, but after I read through the game more and more, my scumread on her grew more and more. It's mostly because I don't feel like they've contributed much. A lot of their posts(iirc) have been more like fluff posts and/or not related to reads and game advancing stuff.
Current Reads List (Updated since my most recent posts)
Spoiler:
Town
Norfolk
(Non-CC Claim Tracker)
Billy
(AT the beginning it was a bit strange that they had their votes everywhere but as they got further into the game they are probably one of the few people that I know of actually giving the game a kick forward. I see this by them asking a lot of questions and attempting to engage others.)
Facebones
(Asks a lot of questions and tries to get the game moving. Again one of the few people to do so and just seems townie atm)
Rockhopper
(Makes a lot of comments and asks people to gain information through reactions and this to me seems like a pretty townie move along with their post of the unlikely pairings from what they think. It seems as though they arent afraid of sharing thoughts which is pretty townie in my eyes)
Null
Backslash
(Very few posts but there is two of them that really contradict each other one of the posts being the answers to Italiano's RQS 46 and 116 - Though this could just be the truth but to me their answer to question 3 really contradicts their next post after that. While they are contradicting I do think that post 169 is a townie post as they are throwing their thoughts out there. This is why they are null for now because i am just not sure.)
Italiano
(I dont really know what to think about them something seems weird to me but I cant really explain it. Its bad I know i am going to do a full ISO dive on them to see if anything can give me some real direction)
Wiyvern
(Not many posts so really cant get anything from what they have said apart from their read list and its not really somethign i would like to go off of at this point but it is good they shared their reads with everyone.)
Scum
Dunnstral
(Very few posts and barely any content. Now this is going to seem very OMGUS but really look at their ISO they vote Norfolk outta gut-which isnt too bad- and then unvotes Norfolk because of no CC which is fair. However they dont give any reason as to why they vote me apart from the points made from two other players are "good enough for a vote". These are the only content points and one of them is sheeped)
Based on this read list i am going to put my vote here