Newbie 976 - Game Over.

[RazorStar]

Thanks for the intro Zorblag. This looks like fun.

[RazorStar]

I want to see Oxide post a bit more, before I change my predecessors' vote. The one I'm most suspicious of is Gandalf, but that's more of a baseless hunch at this moment.

[RazorStar]

I started reading from when I was introduced by Zorblag. That's why it took me so long to get a post in, but yeah I've gone through the whole thing.

[RazorStar]

There really isn't much to defend, he was barely around and wasn't really an active part of discussion. It's really hard to say what a lurker is, but for his few posts he explained himself somewhat well. I'd be suspicious of him, but he's not really being as suspicious or as threatening as Gandalf is to me.

[RazorStar]

He strikes me as someone hungry for a lynch. He's using the discussion in the day phase to weed out the players who would be the biggest threat to him and wants to take them out. It could be why he's waiting for 0x1 to make a 4th vote so he get a quick lynch in.

[RazorStar]

On Page 9 you can see he's voted for NS, even though he's said his belief is that someone else is part of the scum team. The excuse he used is that he was a little paranoid. If he wanted to get rid of scum, why wasn't he voting for scum?

That's all I've got, it's not much but it makes me incredibly suspicious of his motivations.

[RazorStar]

If we prolong the game enough, we will eventually see the mafia slip up. It's the mafia that has the harder task here so we shouldn't be so quick to lynch our own.

UNVOTE:

[RazorStar]

Well I need to look into you, 0x1de, so it's good that we're both here. I'm curious about the player you think is most likely to be scum.

[RazorStar]

hahaha that's so dirty.

VOTE: Gandalf

[RazorStar]

I want to put the heat on him, since he's virtually vanished. He must know that the best way to prove his innocence is to get back on here and explain a few things like why he wanted a lynch so badly on day 1. I'm pretty sure at least one of the players who lynched NS is scum, so I just want to see what Gandalf says. Either way Friend feels like town, I'm neutral on David, and ST is claiming cop, that leaves two I'm really suspicious of, 0x1 and gandalf.

[RazorStar]

Oh damn, he's at L-1 now... wow yeah sorry.

UNVOTE:

[RazorStar]

Do you want me to think you're scum?

[RazorStar]

Well alright David...

VOTE: 0x1de

[RazorStar]

You should think what you want. I think we need information, and this is the best way to get it. So I'll take the risk here to drag the scum out later. In any case, I'm prepared to stick my neck out right now. If it does turn out he is scum we have a bit to go on, potential scum buddies, we can see whether ST's cop claim is true or not, and if gandalf is really a target to worry about. If he isn't it opens up another can of worms, but can ultimately bring us closer to the truth. At this point right now, it doesn't harm town to be aggressive here, at least that's what I think. Please tell me why you think it's a bad idea.

[RazorStar]

Yes I'm interested to hear what ST has to say. If he is the cop, he should have some news for us.

[RazorStar]

I thought it was a good idea... I realize now that I wasn't thinking all that clearly, and well I think I just boned us.

[RazorStar]

Whatever works, me dying means us losing.

[RazorStar]

Oh sorry, I thought ATE meant appeal to ego.

[RazorStar]

Alright, it's time to get rid of the head of this operation. There can only be one, so I need some more time to feel this out.

Vote: StarTran

There's still 2 mafia left, and the way I see it, Gandalf is unlikely to be the brains of the operation, so that leaves ST and DP as the most likely to be scumbuddies. Of course, ST and DP could be working together and Gandy could be innocent, but I feel like that is unlikely with the way DP is knocking ST.

[RazorStar]

Doctors can't protect themselves anyway. Tp I don't think you're the head of any operation, but my level of suspicion towards you is only a bit less than the other members in this game.

UNVOTE:

I do want to hear why DP and Gandalf can't be scum together though.

[RazorStar]

Exactly as I saw it before, thanks David, but I was asking Tp. You know how telephone works,

[RazorStar]

Just wanted to see if you would have said anything different, like a slip up or something. but whatever. I'm sure there is a third option there, (ST is town, lying about cop to protect himself) but that's just unlikely. Which is what I was wondering about, but it didn't seem like you were considering it David. That's all.

[RazorStar]

All you're saying is my actions make me seem scummier, but I'm just considering the options here. To me looking at all the possibilities doesn't seem anti-town at all.

[RazorStar]

This is a newbie game though... and you completely lost me.

[RazorStar]

Yes but my considerations are in the realms of plausibility, I'd consider that worth considering.

VOTE: Gandalf

[RazorStar]

Yeah I do tend to do that huh... well even though David is acting in a suspicious manner, at least he's not flat out ignoring what's going on and making the effort to prove and defend himself. So yeah, that's a marked improvement over just ignoring this game completely.

[RazorStar]

sorry, theperson made a post in the bottom of the last page, and I'm still figuring out this forum system.

[RazorStar]

Whoa wait, we won? That's a surprise, I thought I blew it for sure on the second day, still it was a lot of fun and a lot of pressure. Thanks for being a good scum buddy theperson. I don't mind at all that the quick topic was posted, it's good learning experience for everyone and it'll make it that much more fun in the future. Seriously, we got so lucky here. Thank you all for an excellent game, I haven't played mafia like this before so it was a good experience.

[RazorStar]

I have the charisma of a face that launched a million ships.