Things that I found relevant on rereading day one
-------------------
28 - Maxous votes for scum JediKnight. Makes him look town.
35 - jediknight accuses Maxous based on a very tentative, semantics driven argument. This doesn't seem like a bus at all to me, but rather one mafia trying to pick up a bandwagon, which suggests Maxous is town
42 - I don't like this post by wredfar at all. I don't see why Nobody's Special contradiction (the disliking the RVS and then placing a random vote thing) is remotely relevant. Fine, it's a contradiction, but people contradict themselves all the time regardless of whether they're town or scum. I don't see how placing a random vote as mafia would benefit him at all; if anything it just draws more attention to him, which scum don't want. As for Maxous, he didn't contradict himself at all; he just worded something fuzzily. wredfar then goes on to to say he suspects Nobody Special more for a reason that doesn't make sense to me. If Nobody is more experienced, then surely he's less likely to make mistakes like that, and therefore his 'mistake' is less likely to be a genuine mafia mistake than simply a misunderstanding.
47 - Akira's vote on Maxous seems more like a rage vote than anything else. Don't really know what to make of this, but I don't think mafia would be this clumsy.
51 - I like this post by wredfar. ConSpiracy asks him a question that has nothing to do with anything, and wredfar points out that it's irrelevant and expresses a desire to go back to scumhunting.
52 - jediknight fosses Maxous again. Now we know jediknight was mafia, Maxous looks really really town here.
65 - Still don't like ConSpiracy fossing me for refusing to answer an irrelevant question
73 - Don't like this. Nobody Special tries to point out a non-existent contradiction between ConSpiracy calling him scum and not wanting to discredit him as an IC.
81 - wredfar is still suspicious of NS for something that happened like two pages ago, and contributes nothing else.
84 - Huge filler post. This reads to me as mafia wanting to contribute but not really knowing what to say.
86 - LordChronos starts bandwagon on jediknight
100 - wredfar is still suspicious of NS for something that happened like four pages ago, and contributes nothing else. Makes a kind of OMGUS argument against Nobody Special.
110 - Again, don't like this from wredfar. NS points out he's lurking, and wredfar effectively goes 'I don't care because nobody's gonna lynch me for it'.
114 - Given how haphazardly wredfar's been playing up until this post, I don't think he'd suddenly come out with a clever and cunning fos on jediknight. Makes him look a hell of a lot more town.
125 - jedi's main fos is ConSpiracy. This suggests CS is town.
127 - Akira doesn't want to vote for ConSpiracy, but instead votes for his second suspect, who is jediknight. No way mafia would bus like this.
155 - Very protown post.
157 - bacon hammers on JediKnight. No way bacon's mafia, considering that he could have easily not posted and forced a no lynch, or pushed for a CS lynch.
-------
So, at the end of day one:
Town
Maxous
Akira
bacon
Trendall
Probably town
ConSpiracy
wredfar
Probably not town
Nobody Special
To be honest, I never found Nobody Special all that scummy day one, but by process of elimination based on who looks town to me, he's my top suspect right now. Plus, as far as I can find from doing an iso of jediknight, he didn't make any mention of Nobody Special or his opinion on Nobody Special once during day one. Looks to me like mafia trying to avoid each other. I need to look through what's happened today, and then I'll be caught up.
