Newbie 1663 - Floridian Mafia (Game Over)

[Punkweight]

Vote: JasonWazza

For making things semi-real.

[Punkweight]

Vote: JasonWazza

For making things semi-real.

Hi Punkweight! I hope you can post more. Was this a serious vote or RLS vote?

RLS, don't have any actual reads atm.

[Punkweight]

I don't think Smithereens is scummy, the outing was odd but the logic for doing so is there. The fluff appears to be coming from frustration.

[Punkweight]

VOTE: Unvote

[Punkweight]

Two questions.

1. What's your reason?
2. Why didn't you give a reason for your unvote the first time?

Oh, and also, do you have any more reads now?

1. I don't have any reads strong enough to justify voting for someone.
2. I thought it was self explanatory.

I still read Smithereens as town. Rubidium looks like town because they've done nothing progress things along. Jason could go either way for the arguing point brought up earlier. No one screams scum at me.

@Punkweight Why aren't you requesting replacement? If you're town, you're dragging us down with your tardiness and lack of participation. Can you replace out if you don't feel like you can play to your optimum?

I'll try to post more, just a little overwhelmed and confused at the moment. I know that's a garbage excuse but it's the truth.

[Punkweight]

2. Unvoting someone without an explanation. How is that self-explanatory? You could have unvoted Jason for a number of reasons.

It was a random vote in the first place, and I had said before that I had no real reads.

I'm Town because I've done nothing to progress things along? How does this make any sense?

How could Jason go either way?

1. Typo, there was supposed to be a but in there.
2. I could see his interactions with smithereens as honest or an attempt to waste time.

[Punkweight]

VOTE: notscience
After re-reading, basically everything NS has posted has pandered to smithereens and not done a whole lot else. Given smithereen's position, it's pretty scummy.

[Punkweight]

So, question: why is it scummy if NS panders to smithereens given that NS generally does this as town? You take it as indicative of alignment without first checking to see if this assumption is valid. The assumption is invalid, so why are you voting against NS?

You voted NS for basically the same reason last page. Why is it suddenly an illogical reason?

[Punkweight]

So, question: why is it scummy if NS panders to smithereens given that NS generally does this as town? You take it as indicative of alignment without first checking to see if this assumption is valid. The assumption is invalid, so why are you voting against NS?

You voted NS for basically the same reason last page. Why is it suddenly an illogical reason?

The assumption that this is not typical of a town NS is false, is what I'm saying. So why don't you tell me why you think NS is scum?

It still looks scummy in the context of this game. You claimed and cemented yourself in a decent position, then put heat on notsci. Notsci responded by sucking up to you. You said that it happened yourself.

[Punkweight]

We might as well. We're pretty much out of time and clearly out of patience, and its a safe lynch. I wouldn't hammer until everyone says their piece, though.

[Punkweight]

I want to see a full refutation from Rub before I make a decision on this.