Newbie 51 - Game Over

[Save The Dragons]

THERE ARE ALWAYS DRAGONS TO SAVE!

Actually, they're pretty good at saving themselves, making my job a lot easier.

For the reasons stated above,

Vote: Bleeding Agony

(yes, it's random)

[Save The Dragons]

Heh...I've did that bracket thing on my first game.

[Save The Dragons]

And I guess I am a little curious why you're putting a second vote on me this early.

[Save The Dragons]

Oh! I was wandering what retal was. Stupid me.

[Save The Dragons]

Not really...

[Save The Dragons]

I want to hear from Bleeding Agony.

[Save The Dragons]

Cya King!

I like strawberry!

Why does everyone hate it when people talk about things besides mafia?

[Save The Dragons]

Traditionally, when there are 4 to lynch, that's how you play.

And if you were a normal townie, I'd think you'd let it go. OMGUSing people is not going to get you anywhere.[/b]

[Save The Dragons]

Well...unless you've played mafia somewhere before and it has worked...

It really doesn't show you are really thinking because you're doing the obvious. All it will do is make people suspicious of you, because all you are doing is defending yourself, and usually people who defend themselves too hard have something to hide.

[Save The Dragons]

Let's see...spork hasn't given us much...he gave the final vote for BA...so

Small FOS Spork

BA's posts...were...unique...I've never seen anybody play like that before, just countering what anyone else said.

Drummer placed a third vote...but he died.

Drummer's like, "whoa! FOS!"

And FD's like, "whoa! Not cool!"

And Drummer's like, "dude! FOS for realz, man!"

and now drummer is dead. I really doubt FD would kill him because of this, so I really don't know.

But FD was a little over the top.

FOS FD

SO didn't vote for BA...considering he was the doc I don't think this really proves anything. Although I could make up a conspiricy about SO not voting the doc and being mafia because he knew BA was innocent but I dunno...that's just kinda wierd.

So my mafia picks are FD and Spork. But I can't be sure at this point.

[Save The Dragons]

I'd guess a combination of first game and, as he said, retaliation.

Random Vote: drummer97531

I really don't like how FD's reacting here.

Unvote: drummer97531, Vote: Flying Dutchman

.

Alright. Yesterday I was confident that FD was scum. The only thing that would've changed my opinion would be if Bleeding Agony was scum. Thus,

Vote: Flying Dutchman

Going after BA like that and not willing to accept that he's a newbie, retaliating to drummer's FOS... I'm quite confident I'm right here.

Spork, if I get your post correctly, SO is doing at least one of the following:

1. Being random
2. Not liking how he is reacting
3. Still not liking how he is reacting and going against anti-newbieness I guess

So...uh...care to clarify?

FD, I have been making that point against you too...

SO, they would have if they got online at the same time...but I guess they wouldn't have one at a time; that would be too obvious.

Also you seem a little overconfident. I agree, FD has been rather rash, but I dunno if your confidence is 100% well founded.

And lastly, Spork, please post more than just your one line posts. Never posting very much will only get you lynched and people will be a little pissed at you. Please add at least some information along with your posts.

[Save The Dragons]

I'm going to take that to the next level.

WT fricken F?

Who are you talking to?

And why?

And don't you have any answers? NONE of your posts make any sense.

No...wait. Seriously, what compeled you to write something like that? I'm starting to want to just vote for you for even saying that post.

Forget BA. Spork, you're the most unique poster I've ever seen.

[Save The Dragons]

Ok...since you think no one was posting:

I'd guess a combination of first game and, as he said, retaliation.

Random Vote: drummer97531

I really don't like how FD's reacting here.

Unvote: drummer97531, Vote: Flying Dutchman

.

Alright. Yesterday I was confident that FD was scum. The only thing that would've changed my opinion would be if Bleeding Agony was scum. Thus,

Vote: Flying Dutchman

Going after BA like that and not willing to accept that he's a newbie, retaliating to drummer's FOS... I'm quite confident I'm right here.

Spork, if I get your post correctly, SO is doing at least one of the following:

1. Being random
2. Not liking how he is reacting
3. Still not liking how he is reacting and going against anti-newbieness I guess

So...uh...care to clarify?

And lastly, Spork, please post more than just your one line posts. Never posting very much will only get you lynched and people will be a little pissed at you. Please add at least some information along with your posts.

[Save The Dragons]

Eh-hem...

What if you are the mafia and FD is some innocent?

I'm go to wait for everyone to post just in case KE or FD are the cop and they claim...

IMO Spork is most likely mafia. He's been dancing my questions which would probably be easy to answer, or even lie about. But no, repeated dodging, various obscure comments, and now, this last post...sheesh...

Look at that. I'm going to miss ya sinister? The tone of that is really cheesy, and just the lack of skeptism in general makes me feel uncomfortable. I agree, FD is suspicious, and he probably is the one...but if you think about it, if mafia claims cop right now, all they have to do is lynch the real cop, and they won. If we lynch wrong today, we lose!

I'm inclided to believe that both Spork and SO are possibly mafia...I've had enough.

Depending on what others say, I may change my mind. But for now I don't even care if I knew SO is the cop; I just can't take it anymore.

Vote Spork

[Save The Dragons]

FOSFOSFOS: SPORK

SKEPTISM MY FRIEND! SO could be lying...which I highly believe now

[Save The Dragons]

Eh...that was pretty rash...SO, if I want to lynch you, I will try to make sure I have more than what Spork says.

[Save The Dragons]

Right now I'm believing SO more.

Spork: STOP VOTING AND START POSTING! thank you.

[Save The Dragons]

FD just took the only course of action that could possibly mean his survival. Without a counterclaim, the town will accept my investigation, and lynch him. He had to claim cop, cause 1) either his scum buddy already posted and thus any cop claim would be unbelieveable or 2) he wanted to keep his buddy hidden, so that even if they do lynch him the other's more likely to avoid tomorrow's lynch.

You'd probably take the same action regardless of roles if he claimed first.

All these questions have one answer: I consider Save The Dragons to be the most experienced player in this game if I'm not counting myself. One of the newer players could likely be trapped in a lie or in defence of his scum buddy, but STD can't be caught that easy. It's what I do every game as a cop: Starting with the most experienced player and working down the list. Only if I have a VERY solid reason not to I'm investigating someone else, and that wasn't the case in this game.

Flattered.

Even were I scum and spork my partner, faking a claim wasn't my only option. The scum only need to lynch one more townie to win. My best course of action were I scum would be to distance myself from spork, accuse him with everyone else, and hope to lynch an innocent tomorrow. Doing what I did would mean that if it didn't work, the town would have as good as won. Your logic has very large holes in it.

There's hypocracy in that statement. You're best course of action is to lynch spork, nightkill, and

hope

to kill someone when there are three people left? You do realize that this

would mean that if it didn't work, the town would have as good as won.

?

Again, flawed logic. If that were the case, why would he unvote? Plus, I wouldn't have suggested such a strategy, it looks far too suspicious. I agree on that spork looks suspicious... perhaps this was your strategy? When two factions form, have each scum polarised to opposite sides, so one definitely survives?

WHY DID HE VOTE IN THE FIRST PLACE?!? He following blindly! He's not even paying attention.

UNVOTE FD

FOS STD/SO

Let me get this straight. You follow someone blindly, then FOS me when I say I don't believe everything what people above me tell me, then YOU UNVOTE AND STILL FOS ME?

Wow. You've managed to be a hypocrite in

4 LINES OF TEXT

.

And until you answer my questions, I will not unvote you, spork.

[Save The Dragons]

I hope i'm not wrong but

vote so

ANSWER MY QUESTIONS ANSWER MY QUESTIONS ANSWER MY QUESTIONS!

[Save The Dragons]

I'd appriciate it if KE showed up before the deadline, because we're only get 3 sets of thoughts.

I'd also appriciate it if Spork actually posted information.

[Save The Dragons]

Spork, it was so damn obvious you were mafia. You have nothing to be proud of. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but if you think you can just get by by ignoring other people's questions and posting mediocre ammounts and think that you actually played well, I'm sorry, your wrong in my opinion. I would have loved to see more effort on your part.

I really wished we had more time, because I felt we had more discussion going and a lot more to say even before the deadline expired. So I am a little upset but I won't hold it against Nanook, but I would hope that more discussion = less deadline. Now that I think about it, I actually am pretty curious why it wasn't extended.

But I should have paid a little more attention to it, because I kinda ignored it, and I probably should have kept it in mind.

And I'm realizing all this now, so I probably should have earlier and said so.

Anyway, thank you Morpheus and Nanook for modding. I appriciate you picking it up, Nanook

Good game everyone, and despite the first paragraph, good job both FD and Spork.

I was so wrapped up trying to get rid of spork and trying to continue the cop thing later, but I guess I should have been more vocal about it, and probably would have gotten myself nightkilled. Oh well.

[Save The Dragons]

All other players: If two people are claiming cop and you're not sure who's lying, why not lynch Spork!? It was obvious he was scum, and you could've solved the problem tomorrow!

Ermm...that's what I was doing, I just should've been more vocal about it.

[Save The Dragons]

Hey...you were...damn you...

Will spork answer my questions now? I'm kinda curious...

[Save The Dragons]

Err...looking back, it was just one question and a request for you to post more. This was the question though.:

I'd guess a combination of first game and, as he said, retaliation.

Random Vote: drummer97531

I really don't like how FD's reacting here.

Unvote: drummer97531, Vote: Flying Dutchman

.

Alright. Yesterday I was confident that FD was scum. The only thing that would've changed my opinion would be if Bleeding Agony was scum. Thus,

Vote: Flying Dutchman

Going after BA like that and not willing to accept that he's a newbie, retaliating to drummer's FOS... I'm quite confident I'm right here.

Spork, if I get your post correctly, SO is doing at least one of the following:

1. Being random
2. Not liking how he is reacting
3. Still not liking how he is reacting and going against anti-newbieness I guess

So...uh...care to clarify?

Because you said this:

Sinister you are doing exacly what you are voting others for.