Dance of the Title Fairy: A Froggy Fandango

[Kublai Khan]

crucial waukesha voter

I support this for Drench.

[Gamma Emerald]

for the mish mash community drench is iconic for this exact reason
im not sure there is another member of the MM community who is as easily identifiable by their posting style & obsession with voting/elections/voting systems

so i appreciate the non-mish mash people giving feedback but you're v wrong

This exactly why it’s bad: no one else gets it

[Kublai Khan]

A punctuation eccentricity doesn't feel like a hill worth dying on.

[xRECKONERx]

because drench's posting is pretty much limited to mish mash & the politics threads.
so if you don't frequent those, you won't see it or get it

there are plenty of titles given out that i dont get but i dont come in here going WAHHH IM NOT PART OF SITECHAT SO I DONT GET IT

[xRECKONERx]

for me drench is immediately associated with:
- voting obsessions/politics
- being really gay
- survivor
- musical theater

[Shadoweh]

nth crucial waukesha voter

Unfortunately can't get other things I associate with Drench into a title because of -rules-

[SleepyKrew]

nth crucial waukesha voter

[Mathdino]

nth crucial waukesha voter

Reckoners reasoning is good

[Alchemist21]

for the mish mash community drench is iconic for this exact reason
im not sure there is another member of the MM community who is as easily identifiable by their posting style & obsession with voting/elections/voting systems

so i appreciate the non-mish mash people giving feedback but you're v wrong

This exactly why it’s bad: no one else gets it

I think mish-mash based titles are perfectly fine; mish-mash is a significant part of the site and a lot of people post there almost exclusively.

This specific case just seemed like everyone had all the pieces for making a title but were struggling to come up with one. A lot of people who know Drench better are supporting one if the suggestions now so I guess that one works better than it seemed at first.

[Psyche]

i think the waukesha joke works better as a location

[Vijarada]

drench posts a bit in the speezy about voting stuff as well. it's defo his most distinctive attribute as a user.

[Elbirn]

speezy

No don't

[xyzzy]

"I don't get this title because it's a reference to Mish Mash/LSG and I don't go there" is a very bad reason to anti-nom a title

[Vijarada]

I don't like just "crucial waukesha voter", though. swing vote?

[Shaziro]

Crucial Waukesha County is the thing I most associate with Drench.

[Psyche]

bro's title is out of date by the way

[Randomnamechange]

nth crucial waukesha voter

i think this combos nicely with the location if fact as well as the reasoning behind it as a title being really solid

[DeathRowKitty]

I thought more about my concerns with the possible Drench title (as expressed here). I do think the crucial Waukesha reference loses some of its flair as a title rather than a location, but it's strong enough that it shouldn't ever become just a location reference, even if his location were to change. Other concerns about the title (forced/inaccessible) have been heard, but I disagree with them.

I'll leave 24 hours mostly just as a formality in case anyone wants to nominate Drench for something else, but

crucial waukesha voter

is otherwise approved.

[DeathRowKitty]

bro's title is out of date by the way

did u figure if your title should lose the period

im not going to require it to go through a whole process or anything if you want that its just punctuation

[DeathRowKitty]

OTHER THINGS THAT WERE HAPPENING IN THIS THREAD BUT HAVE NOT BEEN HAPPENING IN THE LAST PAGE OR SO:

-Elbirn was being nommed for titles related to

quality assurance

. I would not have approved any of the nominations that were proposed so far, but let's not forget about Elbirn just because we remembered Drench!

-I guess I never explicitly said this but

Gives a Duck

for the worst received enough of the negative feedback I was looking for to not be willing to approve it. I tried to think of other duck-related title directions that would make sense and came up blank, but maybe someone more clever or witty has an idea they think would work?

[hiplop]

Risky Waukesha voter? Emphasis on risk

[hiplop]

Also definitely no caps on whatever the title is

[DeathRowKitty]

Yeah sorry I don't know why I capitalized it in that post, I knew better and just autopiloted I guess.

[Randomnamechange]

also btw i know its already been approved but just to add a point the crucial wakuesha thing was a running joke before drench made it their location

[SleepyKrew]

bro's title is out of date by the way

give it to wraith and bring back shade brigade for bro