This is almost certainly broken, but I'm interested in how.
Can town get a 100% win rate?
What's town's best strategy in trying to get a
Right, which is why I marked this as an EV thread ("solve the puzzle"), not as a setup thread ("I'm planning to run this").In post 10, Mathdino wrote:It's pretty funny but like dethy, it's more of a logic game than a mafia game
I don't think it'd be super fun to play
I think this is a good idea. It reduces the number of scumteams that B or C can be on (depending on the answer to the question) to 225, meaning our next question can eliminate 333 more possibilities. Perhaps we would then proceed with that second question splitting the D/E cases similarly (and the next F/G, then H/I, then J/K, then L/M).In post 15, callforjudgement wrote:Well, you can do something like putting all the setups where B is scum (and A is not scum) on the same half of the split. That gives you a good advantage in scumteam elimination if A says that the other half of the split is correct (because now you know that either A is scum or B is town). It's less useful if the split goes the other way, though, and there's limits to how much you can do this for two players B and C using A's question (as they could be scum together). Perhaps you want all the scumteams where B is scum and C isn't on one side of the split, all the scumteams where C is scum and B isn't on the other side, and to split the both-scum and neither-scum cases equally.