[REVIEW] Open Setup Reviews

[Sirius9121]

Mafia Odd-night Roleblocker x1
Mafia Even-night Role Cop x1
Mafia Goon x1

Town Vigilante x1
Town Doctor x1
Town VT x8

[Sirius9121]

random setup made by me for fun, setup name AlternateKP

[Sirius9121]

Mountainous Vengeful

7 vengeful townies

3 mafia goons

The night death flips AFTER the vote flip.
if a Vengeful Townie gets venged they also get to venge

probably worst idea but i want opinions
either 7/3 or (5/2)?

[Sirius9121]

hmm...

feels townsided

an interesting consequence is that MiLo isn't actually risking town to lose

how would u suggest balanc

[Sirius9121]

feels townsided so add town

logic

[Sirius9121]

Could you clean up the setup wording? I'm not sure how the setup works.

basically the one who gets lynched is scum, the day ends and night kill is announced.
lynched is town, town gets a vengeful.
vengeful player is town, continue venging until hit scum
when hit scum, day ends

[Sirius9121]

Spoiler: This spoiler contains a potentially underthought, quite broken setup. Do not read if you do not like those.

4 x Town 1-shot Doctor
3 x Town 1-shot Jailkeeper
4 x Town 1-shot Vigilante
3 x Town 1-shot Neighbourizer
2 x Town 1-shot Cop
2 x Mafia 1-shot Janitor
1 x Mafia 1-shot Neighbourizer
3 x Mafia 1-shot Role Cop
16 x Town Vanilla

3 votes per person, each day highest 3 players votes eliminated.

[Sirius9121]

exCUSE me but isn't it just a complete copy of this game @gypyx

[Sirius9121]

exCUSE me but isn't it just a complete copy of this game @gypyx

nope other way around

what a thick-skinned face

[Sirius9121]

d1 - maf lim (1/3) :

20% maf winrate

d1 - town lim (2/3):

2 - 3
Chance of vengetown: 60%
2 - (2 + 1)
50 (1 - 3) - (25% maf win) / 50 (ins, maf win)

Chance of vengescum: 40%
1 - (3)
25% maf win

total:
maf winrate = (1/3*20+2/3*60*125/2/100+2/3*40*25/100)% = 38.33%
town winrate = (1/3*80+2/3*60*75/2/100+2/3*40*75/100)% = 61.67%

overly high town wr

[Sirius9121]

Spoiler: 1st elim cop/kill

d1 - maf lim (1/3)

1 - 3
25% maf wr

d1 - town lim (2/3)

Chance of vengetown: 60%
2 - (2 + 1)
50 (1 - 3) - (25% maf win) / 50 (ins, maf win)

Chance of vengescum: 40%
1 - (3)
25% maf win

total:
maf winrate = (1/3*25+2/3*60*125/2/100+2/3*40*25/100)% = 40%
town winrate = (1/3*75+2/3*60*75/2/100+2/3*40*75/100)% = 60%

[Sirius9121]

hot potato

6 vanilla townies

3 mafia goons

Nightstart, blitz timing

At night, mafia chooses a number of passes between 5 and 15 (inclusive) and a player to start with the potato. They have no factional kill.

During the day there is no voting. Instead, if a player holds the potato for more than 12 hours, is holding it when the day ends, or receives it after the predetermined number of passes, they are eliminated.

A player with the potato may pass it to anyone else, except the person that passed it to them.

Passing the potato with less than 12 hours left in the deadline adds 3 hours to the deadline.

If, at any point, the number of town is 1 greater than the number of mafia, the game returns to normal day voting rules. If a member of the mafia is eliminated while in this state, the potato passing rules begin again.

Just wanted to document this somewhere other than discord because I might run it as a memey micro. Could also be a fun marathon game.

this is very unfair in terms of timezones tho
imagine recieving the pootato at 9:30pm and waking up 9:31 am

[Sirius9121]

Who is gonna be asleep for 12+ hours???

me

[Sirius9121]

i once slept for about 15-16 hours without waking up

[Sirius9121]

this is very unfair in terms of timezones tho
imagine recieving the pootato at 9:30pm and waking up 9:31 am

The blitz timing would be made clear in sign ups so people know they need to check in every 12 hours.

During the day there is no voting. Instead, if a player holds the potato for more than 12 hours, is holding it when the day ends, or receives it after the predetermined number of passes, they are eliminated.

Passing the potato with less than 12 hours left in the deadline adds 3 hours to the deadline.

lets assume the timer is 12:01
player passes potato
then after 11:59 the player passes it again
that makes the 'i need to check in' timer 3 hours and 2 minutes.

[Sirius9121]

There's always a need to check in close to deadlines in games if you let it get close, that's a feature not a bug.

my timezone be like BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR and the deadline changes often how are we going to prepare xD

anyway uh ._.