Scummies 2016 - CEREMONY!

[Transcend]

Still honored to have been nominated for something! Excellent story guys.

[Creature]

Who were the writers?

[McMenno]

[Creature]

Okay, who actually thought it was a good idea to put an X after my name?

[Nahdia]

Congrats winners!

[Drench]

that was fun

[Nahdia]

greyICE is memorialized twice in the wall. literally unlookable.

[Firebringer]

writing staff doesn't get paid enough to write this stuff

[Frozen Angel]

Its not two greyIce

another user had his avatar too I checked it again >.>

[SirCakez]

That was interesting.....
Congrats winners!

[Firebringer]

Wait....
Plottin kittens even played a game last year?
Who the fuck nominated them?
And how did they win?

What the fuck?

[Firebringer]

Okay the judges made some serious questionable calls here.

Can we change scummies to a voting thing by community?

[mhsmith0]

Wait....
Plottin kittens even played a game last year?
Who the fuck nominated them?
And how did they win?

What the fuck?

viewtopic.php?f=54&t=64679&start=1675
Game ended in 2016 thus was eligible, and it's a one game award.

[Firebringer]

My sentiments still stand.

[Frozen Angel]

There was a voting we all voted for what we thought was best choice between what was given.

I think its fine that you have another opinion.

I think maybe if community choose the judges somehow this awards will be more - what community want. but democracy in choosing something like this will just end up defeated as people will start doing dirty works and advertising which no one wants. look at scummies as something like oscar.

[Nahdia]

there's no perfect way to do it but yeah, straight up community vote starts to involve lots of undesirable stuff.

[Firebringer]

There was a voting we all voted for what we thought was best choice between what was given.

I think its fine that you have another opinion.

I think maybe if community choose the judges somehow this awards will be more - what community want. but democracy in choosing something like this will just end up defeated as people will start doing dirty works and advertising which no one wants. look at scummies as something like oscar.

People campaign for awards in real life......

[Nahdia]

pls no campaigning.

[Firebringer]

It's a popularity contest no matter how you do it.
That's awards for you in a nut-shell.

[Frozen Angel]

They do yes

but they won't get it based on it in a ceremony like grammy or oscar

people can campaign in the current meta too. They just not directly impacting anything and thats good

[KuroiXHF]

Congrats to everyone involved.
I'm honored for even being nominated.

[zoraster]

okay guys. I have removed all (I think) scummies from last year. New ones will need to be put up. People with more than one will need a unique graphic. Until that happens, I may just select one of their awards as the most impressive

Let me know if someone still has a scummy that shouldn't or if I've messed up someone title.

[Varsoon]

It's a popularity contest no matter how you do it.
That's awards for you in a nut-shell.

Wait, Firebringer, you're telling me that I'm popular?

[zoraster]

Okay I have awarded what I can quickly. A few things:

1. Kitty Mo needs a combo Best General Mish Mash Game and Most Cunning Manipulator award
2. wgeurts needs a combo Kodak Moment/Rube Goldberg Award
3. I think we need the award image input for Best Mish Mash Player (Radja) and Best New Mish Mash Player (SummerInWonderland). I may just have missed it, so if it exists, let me know.
4. Varsoon needs a combination Modfather+Best Mechanic award (I don't believe we award anyone an image for GOTY)

[Cerberus v666]

It's a popularity contest no matter how you do it.
That's awards for you in a nut-shell.

Wait, Firebringer, you're telling me that I'm popular?

Obv.