Rules
At the start of the game, everyone ranks five roles in preference order: Cop, Doc, Mafia, Vigilante, VT
1. Rank the three town power roles by number of players who selected them as their top choice (second choices if necessary as tiebreaker)
2. Add the top two to the game, randomly select from the people who had them as top choice. This is not public knowledge.
3. Add a Mafia power role, depending on the role that the most players chose.
If Cop: Add Roleblocker
If Doc: Add 1x Strongman
If Vig: Add Mafia Doc
Finally, randomly select your Mafia from everyone who put it as top choice (then second choice if necessary, etc.)
Any suggestions/improvements? And does 4:12 seem like a reasonable balance point? I think being able to discuss the lists is a slight advantage to town, but I'm not certain.