[SETUP] White Knight

[singletonking]

How about this:

Black Knight

2 Mafia 7 Town
On Days 1 and 2, every lynch must have a Mafia on it, or town win.
Self voting for town and scum are allowed.

[BNL]

Sorry for double bumping, but I dislike how the original setup incentivises bussing too much. I'd like some discussion on how to improve that aspect.

[popsofctown]

Is it really a problem? Bussing loses you a teammate. If the scum blindly grants you the exact same amount of town cred the move warrants in mountainous that's the town's fault?

[singletonking]

OK, so the big problem is that in case of a mislynch Day 1, you get a pool of 3 players of which one must be town. This is reduced to 2 players on Day 2.

Town get too much information by mislynching.

Compare this to the ome-time pool of 5 players in Coalition Mafia.

If we instead force scum to be

on

the wagon, we get coalition pools of 5 and 4, or 4 and 3 if we permit self voting. This seems to be much better balanced.

[popsofctown]

You could just do the thing where, before the day, the scum get to pick 1 person that can be mislynched in violation of the restriction? I think it was one of your setups that included that. Maybe someone else's. It seems like maybe that helps here.

[Awoo]

eight bALL

[RadiantCowbells]

i think this still kinda favors quickhammering d1 and selfvoting d2