The Resistance - Game 2 (GAME OVER)

[PrivateI]

Can we find the bad people fast bc I want to walk around my neighbourhood playing Pokemon Go and scaring the old people (by walking around, not by like going up to their bedroom windows and exclaiming "Boo!").

[PrivateI]

BPC, only if there's enough to share.

[PrivateI]

I like carrots and I don't like BPC because he wants everyone to get drunk, which will impair our ability to root out the...non-townie people?

[PrivateI]

i actually really don't like that people are suggesting sending afk people when that gives us so little information

This is good posting. Reward Drench with a carrot, plz.

[PrivateI]

Actually, wouldn't spies WANT to go? They'd need it to fail...

Same logic as to why town should never be lynching themselves in mafia games.

Ayyyyyyyy #RelevantMDTopics

[PrivateI]

I'm not entirely sure I'm okay with Cheery going on his own mission.

Do you think that he's scum?

[PrivateI]

PiggyGal, why did you reject?

[PrivateI]

Cierra, your thoughts were the only ones I felt like I didn't understand.

[PrivateI]

Leader chooses three non-them people.

Why the heck would a leader put people besides him/herself on a team?

[PrivateI]

ok preliminary team: me (because not putting myself on the team is literally fucking idiotic); two kinda random people idk i'm thinking pabs and someone else

Drench, as always, I adore your reasoning.

Rejecting teams for the sole reason that they have the leader on them is dumb and bad and should be punished.

[PrivateI]

Can we find the bad people fast bc I want to walk around my neighbourhood playing Pokemon Go and scaring the old people (by walking around, not by like going up to their bedroom windows and exclaiming "Boo!").

this is also suspiciously too much information

so igmeoy BUT


related: i was walking past a mom and son earlier and they were trying to catch a pokemon that i had JUST caught and i was like "heh heh heh they have no idea i play" and i felt all cool and special

im sorry for LIVING ICONICALLY.

But seriously, it's dark here, and the Pokemon go to sleep after awhile.

[PrivateI]

kmd/pabs/{Haschel/Cheery} sounds good to me. Really, I think I'll accept any team that doesn't have zakk or Chev on it.

Why Chev?

[PrivateI]

Drench not wanting to accept teams with the leader on them but makes a team with him on it

This is wrong and you are wrong.

[PrivateI]

ok preliminary team: me (because not putting myself on the team is literally fucking idiotic); two kinda random people idk i'm thinking pabs and someone else

Never asperserate my Drenchy poo.

[PrivateI]

I'm going to say that even though it was a success, there was one scum on the mission. There were only 3 rejects, 2 from proposed members. Scum accepted this proposal because there was one scum on there. Otherwise, there may have been more rejects, no?

This position seems flawed. The only way this would be a legitimate case is if town knew who town/scum were from the get-go, and would know to reject a specific team. But if that information were provided to us, the game would be significantly shorter/easier/less fun.

[PrivateI]

Pick PrivateI for friendship and for resistance #swag.

[PrivateI]

Before I select a team, I'd like everyone to propose at least one new person to add to the team, since I need to pick 4.

I like Drench, and I'm growing to like Piggygal, though I don't know what happened to her.

[PrivateI]

Mission #2+3 requires 4 people. Missions #4+5 require 5 people.

Wait, so for Mission 5, we have a one person margin of error? I guess I've only played odd-numbered games. That's awesome!

[PrivateI]

The three on the mission that succeeded i dont understand how they can be scum

You don't think scum would ever choose to pass the first mission to build favour later?

[PrivateI]

Typically the final mission either has a 0 or 1 person margin of error

I like one much better than zero.

[PrivateI]

zakk, kmd, privateI, and cheery. why did you all accept?

Drench was on the mission, and his star power would keep anything bad from happening.

Real talk, I like Piggygal, and I'm ok with everyone else, especially now. (Plus, it's getting late, and I really do want to play Pokemon.)

[PrivateI]

i'm gonna laugh so hard if there's like 2 bad guys on there and we're just reading shit fucky

send the same team again or i will reject



ALSO, if it fails, add me and kmd to the team and remove drench. see how that works.

Nope, Zakk is scum.

[PrivateI]

Well, fudge-o-rama. I was hoping we were done.

EBWOP: Oh! This is round 4, right?

[PrivateI]

Just add kmd to this mission and it will be a success unless there are two scum in that group.

I don't think kmd is town though.

[PrivateI]

I'm not sending Zakk or kmd. It's not happening, though I wouldn't be surprised if scum reject my team.

I want to hear from Drench to clear up my burgeoning doubt.

[PrivateI]

I'd prefer Cheery for the 5th slot.

Nope.

[PrivateI]

The fact that Private I isn't pushing for himself + the 4 is making me think he's scum.

That's all I want, but as I alluded to earlier, I'm unsure if it'll be approved. As soon as Drench gets back, that's what I'm going with though.

[PrivateI]

So...

Pablito/haschel/drench/me/zakk like zakk wanted should be a win. if not, zakk is scum with a budd in that original 3.

no that's not what i wanted,

i wanted piggygal, not drench

me/haschel/piggy/pablito/privateI

(recently acquired townread)

pls

zakk do you believe that there were two scum on the last mission?

i honestly don't know

i think you're town

i think piggy is town

i am less sure on drench and haschel

i want to be added to team 5 no matter what

and i want drench and/or haschel to be replaced with privateI

which one do you think should be replaced?

You're not getting added. Why do we need a replacement?

[PrivateI]

Ahhhh things are happening quickly. Previous team plus me is what's being submitted and then we win gg. If you're town and you reject this, you are bad and I will feel shame on your behalf.

[PrivateI]

Mods, is Drench back?

[PrivateI]

Oh yeah private as town would want himself added to the same 4. i see chevre's point. it would be a no brainer

Literally I've never suggested that I want any other team. Stop asperserating.

[PrivateI]

brb googling asperserating

It's the verb form of "aspersions".

[PrivateI]

Drench, pablito, Haschel, Piggy, and PrivateI, lock it in, lock it down, gg fam.

[PrivateI]

Im rejecting a team with piggy on it

[11:48:56 PM] Cierra (PiggyGal15): I'mma Reject this actually. I wanna see who all passes/rejects it

And of course, half my scum reads accept and half of them reject :/ this doesn't help me at all.

Cierra, YOU HAD A WIN. RIGHT THERE. YOU COULD TOUCH IT WITH YOUR FINGERS.

[PrivateI]

I rejected because I am scum.

FTFY.

[PrivateI]

Im rejecting a team with piggy on it

[11:48:56 PM] Cierra (PiggyGal15): I'mma Reject this actually. I wanna see who all passes/rejects it

And of course, half my scum reads accept and half of them reject :/ this doesn't help me at all.

Cierra, YOU HAD A WIN. RIGHT THERE. YOU COULD TOUCH IT WITH YOUR FINGERS.

Private your answer was fine and you added yourself in the end. if pablito/drench/haschel was town and you were town, piggy being there was fine. see the rest of my posts after the one you quoted

Oh, yeah, I didn't meant to quote that lol. I understand you a little more now, though I'm still not really wanting you on this team bc we don't need new people.

[PrivateI]

THat's me/zakk/Drench/pablito/PiggyGal.

No. sub haschel for piggy at least

Why is Haschel town?

[PrivateI]

I can't currently envision a team that Chevre would submit that I'd accept unless it's the one that he just rejected, which won't happen.

I'm rejecting this one almost guaranteed.

[PrivateI]

yea chevre changing out more than one person from mission 3 is sketch

it should be drench/haschel/pablito/piggy/me

just do that and i'll accept it

if you don't add yourself, this is what i will suggest, and it will get accepted, so you might as well save us all some time

zakk has been a bit too frenetic and questionable for me this entire time - but I would accept that mission because it puts a huge target on zakk if it fails. his wanting to take this risk makes me think he's town.

It failing should

NOT

be an option.

You not being on it should help ensure victory.

[PrivateI]

Chevre's scum, as is Zakk. Chevre didn't put himself on this mission, and Zakk...was added to it and failed it.

[PrivateI]

previous round was also a failure with PrivateI.

Scum were happy with it gonig through.

3

of the rejections were on the wagon!

. If it was gameover for scum, then three would have been off the bloody wagon.

My first prosopal was therefore all town.

I've never been on a mission, Cheery Scum.

[PrivateI]

Zakk's post sounds like it's five

Racefan... pablito/haschel/drench succeeded the first mission. then they succeeded with piggy. then it started failing. that first three i feel is confirmed town basically. i can't see scum succeeding back to back missions. so do those three plus private and yourself. i bet we don't get a single failure

This is bad logic. There could readily be scum in that first group. Or Racefan, for that matter, who has NEVER been on a mission.

[PrivateI]

previous round was also a failure with PrivateI.

Scum were happy with it gonig through.

3

of the rejections were on the wagon!

. If it was gameover for scum, then three would have been off the bloody wagon.

My first prosopal was therefore all town.

I've never been on a mission, Cheery Scum.

You were placed on the first one in round 4. It was rejected by ONWAGON particpants. therefore it must have contained two of the scum.

This doesn't work? Are you assuming that everyone who ejected that team is town?

[PrivateI]

Have I said that? I don't believe so. It was not rejected solely by scum like some people are proposing.

I mean, no one is proposing that there are five scum, no.

[PrivateI]

Drench, which of Pablito and Haschel is scum?

[PrivateI]

Wait, BPC is scum, right? Unless he firmly believes with all his heart that Cheery, KMD, myself, and Zakk are scum, and was willing to stake his game on it.

So that's one person down.

[PrivateI]

How many rejections are we allowed to have this round?

Four tops.

[PrivateI]

How many rejections are we allowed to have this round?

None

To clarify, we can reject a max of four teams, but should limit it to at most three, probably two.

If one spy goes on the mission and fails it, we lose.

[PrivateI]

yo chevre do you really think those five are all town
edit: apparently so huh

Is Chevre scum, Drench?

[PrivateI]

chevre as town shouldn't have suggested any team that didn't include himself on it

Yup.

[PrivateI]

Based on the votes, I can see PrivateI being town. If so, it would be good to see the proposed team that PrivateI sent:

Cheery: REJECT
Drench: REJECT
pablito: REJECT
Haschel: ACCEPT
PrivateI: ACCEPT
Chevre: REJECT
racefan12: ACCEPT
zakk: ACCEPT
Kmd: ACCEPT
Piggy: REJECT

The team I sent CANNOT go because there is one scum on it.

[PrivateI]

OMG THAT IS THE RIGHT TEAM PLEASE RESUBMIT IT.

I will only accept 5 from {me, Drench, pablito, Piggy, racefan, PrivateI} from this point onward.

What changed, Chev, ol' friend, ol' pal?

[PrivateI]

Having 8 rejections makes me wonder if it was actually right, but I don't know.

Remember, scum won't automatically accept a "bad" team. Don't let a lack of four acceptances lead you to mistakenly believe that a given team is town/scum.

[PrivateI]

Back for now.

Wait, BPC is scum, right? Unless he firmly believes with all his heart that Cheery, KMD, myself, and Zakk are scum, and was willing to stake his game on it.

So that's one person down.

Explain this

Racefan put forward a team that DIDN'T include himself, which means, if he's town, he trusted fervently that the other five people he put on the team were the only town people, and that all of the rest of "us" that I mentioned were scum. Based on posts up to this point, I don't buy it, and I don't buy him.

[PrivateI]

racefan also has admittedly joined halfway through the game and has no idea what's up

he maybe didn't think he could be on his own team

And what's your excuse?

[PrivateI]

Drench, pablito, Haschel, Piggy, and PrivateI probably results in a town win.

Describe for me a scenario in which this team, minus me, plus Zakk, which had TWO failures come out of it during mission four, possibly has zero scum.

[PrivateI]

Drench, pablito, Haschel, Piggy, and PrivateI probably results in a town win.

Describe for me a scenario in which this team, minus me, plus Zakk, which had TWO failures come out of it during mission four, possibly has zero scum.

Spoiler alert, it's impossible. One of the four of you is definitely, no doubt about it, scum.

[PrivateI]

reject thisss

[PrivateI]

Zakk, change of heart?

[PrivateI]

i didn't believe in it

What didn't you believe?

[PrivateI]

My battery sucks ass.

pablito, haschel, drench, kmd, private

I have my 4 scum reads and no one likes racefan. impossible to change this and my phones dead in another 2 min again anyway.

This team is a definite nope, thanks.

I'm thinking scum is Haschel/zakk/race/Kmd with the off chance of race being town and just really disorientated, knowing they'll never be sent, and just basically not giving a fuck. (Could also be scum that also knows they'll never be sent and not giving a fuck, so really, race is super confusing for me) and if race is town, then either private or cheery is scum. I'm thinking Cheery!scum would be more likely? But that requires zakk to have been pushing against a team member this whole time (which is highly possible, I thought zakk coming in and immediately casting Cheery to the side was really weird)

p-edit: ALSO WHY DID KMD SUGGEST A TEAM SO QUICKLY? HOW MANY TIMES DO I HAVE TO SAY THAT KMD IS CONFSCUM, LIKE REALLY.

I'm pretty certain with town!pabs right now, Drench is still iffy, but I feel like if he's scum he's playing a really risky game and I'm not sure he would do that (on the other hand, he's just a replacement so winning isn't as needed as it is for the rest of us, so maybe he'd take more chances? idk)

I've been a Piggy fan for awhile, and this post helps solidify why. Zakk is scum. Haschel proved he's scum last time. Racefan is probably scum. I'm not certain about kmd, but he's certainly acting scummily. Piggy, I trust your judgment, but I'm worried about Cheery. Please bring us a win.

[PrivateI]

I don't like racefan, piggy. His selections were super bad, and he's done nothing since.

[PrivateI]

I'm still not convinced kmd is scum.

But i don't know if I've just been tunneling him as town the whole game or what.

As much as I hate to agree with Cheery Dog, I have similar sentiments. Kmd has appeared very genuine, at the very least. Zakk's desperate posts at this point are just trying to throw the town off.

[PrivateI]

Kmd and zakk are scum.

Me, PrivateI, and Cheery are town.

Pablito>Piggy>Drench in order from towniest to scummiest.

ONE OF PABLITO/DRENCH IS SCUM ALONG WITH YOU

CHEERY IS NOT TOWN WTF

Two scum went on our first two missions and neither of them failed either one, while just one failed the third?

[PrivateI]

what because I'm likely to leave you off?

Cheery, which team will win?

[PrivateI]

I'm still not convinced kmd is scum.

But i don't know if I've just been tunneling him as town the whole game or what.

As much as I hate to agree with Cheery Dog, I have similar sentiments. Kmd has appeared very genuine, at the very least. Zakk's desperate posts at this point are just trying to throw the town off.

a;lfhka;sldfkahjs;ldgahsdflas

NOOOOOOO THATS NOT TRUE.

agh. fuck. we are gonna lose.







piggy. i implore you.
pleeeaaassseeee

no cheery dog
no haschel cedricson
no kmd

do whoever else you want

doesn't have to be me

if you put pablito or drench instead of me, i would understand, but one of them is

DEFINITELY

scum.

but the other 3 i listed above are

DEFINITELY

scum

I wish I could bang on the home keys on my keyboard to create an appeal to emotion. It sounds so...soothing.

[PrivateI]

what because I'm likely to leave you off?

Cheery, which team will win?

I believe there will be a 50% chance of mine winning, unless you're not on the same team, in which case then it's a 0% chance of my team winning.

To clear things up, which five should we send in order to win?

[PrivateI]

Chevre/Drench/Kmd/pablito/Piggy/racefan

pick from there and we win

You have all of kmd, Drench, and Racefan as town?

[PrivateI]

Piggy, I think I would go with that. The one I'm most leery about, as I've pointed out, is racefan, with Chev as a second.

[PrivateI]

zakk is trying to sell privateI as town. that makes me think PrivateI is not town.

Don't let his scrambling ruin us.

[PrivateI]

KMD, if Cheery Dog is scum, this one has to go through for us to win.

[PrivateI]

*for us to have a chance to win