Page 3 of 8

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:08 pm
by xRECKONERx
OLD TIMEY


Spoiler: First Vote
Seafoam Islands
"Wasn't this game won by a Revolving Idol Door? If a mod did that nowadays they'd be shunned."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"i voted for it last time and ill keep voting for it until it is dead. nostalgia =/= good."

Spoiler: Third Vote
Middle Earth
"There were some good characters in this, sure but the game itself didn't DO anything whatsoever. And it also had that one challenge where voted out people sent a tribe to TC, flipping a coin was fairer."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"15 person merge! 32 players! I can't be bothered to read any games in this bracket!"
That's one vote a piece for MK, DI, SI, and AA.

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Mass Effect
"Haven't heard any great things about it and the others are just too good."

Spoiler: Final Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"Toad is kinda rapey"
Mushroom Kingdom, the tribe has spoken.

Image


VINTAGE

Spoiler: First Vote
Season Finale
"Postmerge was a tragic slaughter of the interesting tribe followed by a depressing slog to the most obvious win of all time."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Season Finale
"paglongo"

Spoiler: Third Vote
Doctor Who
"Fucking Time Travel"

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Season Finale
"Does this need an explanation?"

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Season Finale
"again, this game was really tragic"

Spoiler: Final Vote
Season Finale
"literal garbage. are you really asking me why i chose this."

Season Finale, the tribe has spoken.

Image


NEW N HIP

Spoiler: First Vote
Battle of the Bands
"honestly just p disappointing as a season and the cast was meh. like when's the last time anyone brought up this awesome or memorable thing that happened in BotB?"

Spoiler: Second Vote
Eon
"The only reason this game went over well is the fact it had a killer castlist. Without that, it's not special in any way and the main twist of the game didn't even matter at the end."

Spoiler: Third Vote
Pretty Super Vanilla
"This game is nothing special, it was good and so forth I guess. That final 4 round overshadows the rest in my reading-the-season-later-than-it-happened mind and and it wasn't a good round! Mod drama, player drama, spec drama and when it was done there was auxiliary drama."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Eon
"It's a big threat according to Reck's posts, kill it all early!"
That's one vote each for EtU, PSV, BotB, and Eon.

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Battle of the Bands
"An overall underwhelming game. Against the others in this category, it's no question."

Spoiler: Final Vote
Battle of the Bands
"messy as hell"
Sorry, BoB, the tribe has spoken.
Image


MODERN AESTHETIC

Spoiler: First Vote
Ned's
"Solid game marred by the grumpiest jury of all time."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Abridged
"Kawazu lol"

Spoiler: Third Vote
League of Legends
"Modding was pisspoor at best, and modding decisions entirely changed the course of the game."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Medevac Island
"One World improved on this in every way so why keep it"

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Ned's
"I hate everyone who voted for MLS"

Spoiler: Final Vote
Abridged
"bad theme, bad challenges, just no"
...we are tied.


Spoiler: Revote #1
Ned's

Spoiler: Revote #2
Abridged

Spoiler: Revote #3
Ned's

Spoiler: Revote #4
Abridged

We are still tied!

That means... rock draw. ROCKS ROCKS ROCKS. Why? Because I'm making up the rules and an actual dead even tie is gonna result in a rock draw ya bitches.
Image

Entering the remaining games into random.org... we will randomize three times.

Image
Oh my.
Medevac Island... the ROCKS have spoken.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:09 pm
by McMenno
exciting!!!

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:37 pm
by McMenno
love it, keep 'em coming

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:45 pm
by xRECKONERx
RESULTS OMG!!!

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:46 pm
by xRECKONERx
POSTING AGAIN BECAUSE CHEERY DOG DOESNT READ PAGETOPS
OLD TIMEY


Spoiler: First Vote
Seafoam Islands
"Wasn't this game won by a Revolving Idol Door? If a mod did that nowadays they'd be shunned."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"i voted for it last time and ill keep voting for it until it is dead. nostalgia =/= good."

Spoiler: Third Vote
Middle Earth
"There were some good characters in this, sure but the game itself didn't DO anything whatsoever. And it also had that one challenge where voted out people sent a tribe to TC, flipping a coin was fairer."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"15 person merge! 32 players! I can't be bothered to read any games in this bracket!"
That's one vote a piece for MK, DI, SI, and AA.

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Mass Effect
"Haven't heard any great things about it and the others are just too good."

Spoiler: Final Vote
Mushroom Kingdom
"Toad is kinda rapey"
Mushroom Kingdom, the tribe has spoken.

Image


VINTAGE

Spoiler: First Vote
Season Finale
"Postmerge was a tragic slaughter of the interesting tribe followed by a depressing slog to the most obvious win of all time."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Season Finale
"paglongo"

Spoiler: Third Vote
Doctor Who
"Fucking Time Travel"

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Season Finale
"Does this need an explanation?"

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Season Finale
"again, this game was really tragic"

Spoiler: Final Vote
Season Finale
"literal garbage. are you really asking me why i chose this."

Season Finale, the tribe has spoken.

Image


NEW N HIP

Spoiler: First Vote
Battle of the Bands
"honestly just p disappointing as a season and the cast was meh. like when's the last time anyone brought up this awesome or memorable thing that happened in BotB?"

Spoiler: Second Vote
Eon
"The only reason this game went over well is the fact it had a killer castlist. Without that, it's not special in any way and the main twist of the game didn't even matter at the end."

Spoiler: Third Vote
Pretty Super Vanilla
"This game is nothing special, it was good and so forth I guess. That final 4 round overshadows the rest in my reading-the-season-later-than-it-happened mind and and it wasn't a good round! Mod drama, player drama, spec drama and when it was done there was auxiliary drama."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Eon
"It's a big threat according to Reck's posts, kill it all early!"
That's one vote each for EtU, PSV, BotB, and Eon.

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Battle of the Bands
"An overall underwhelming game. Against the others in this category, it's no question."

Spoiler: Final Vote
Battle of the Bands
"messy as hell"
Sorry, BoB, the tribe has spoken.
Image


MODERN AESTHETIC

Spoiler: First Vote
Ned's
"Solid game marred by the grumpiest jury of all time."

Spoiler: Second Vote
Abridged
"Kawazu lol"

Spoiler: Third Vote
League of Legends
"Modding was pisspoor at best, and modding decisions entirely changed the course of the game."

Spoiler: Fourth Vote
Medevac Island
"One World improved on this in every way so why keep it"

Spoiler: Fifth Vote
Ned's
"I hate everyone who voted for MLS"

Spoiler: Final Vote
Abridged
"bad theme, bad challenges, just no"
...we are tied.


Spoiler: Revote #1
Ned's

Spoiler: Revote #2
Abridged

Spoiler: Revote #3
Ned's

Spoiler: Revote #4
Abridged

We are still tied!

That means... rock draw. ROCKS ROCKS ROCKS. Why? Because I'm making up the rules and an actual dead even tie is gonna result in a rock draw ya bitches.
Image

Entering the remaining games into random.org... we will randomize three times.

Image
Oh my.
Medevac Island... the ROCKS have spoken.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:48 pm
by McMenno
can you edit it out of the pagetop because my joke doesn't look like a joke atm

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:51 pm
by xRECKONERx
It's time to... DROP... YOUR... BUFFS...

WE ARE SWITCHING TRIBES!

Everyone... open your buffs in 3... 2... 1...

Spoiler:
Again, randomized 3 times.
Image

FRESH & PRECIOUS

Game of Thrones Survivor
Survivor: Names Are Hard
Survivor: #2016
Survivor: One World
Arkham City
Survivor: Nexus
Survivor: Pretty Super Vanilla
Arkham Asylum
Ned's Declassified School Survivor
Survivor: Hyrule

ON FLEEK

Survivor: League of Legends
Survivor: Conclave
Survivor: Abridged
Survivor: Middle Earth
Survivor: Hogwarts
Mass Effect Survivor
Survivor: Doctor Who
Survivor: Sky Pillar
Survivor: Seafoam Islands
Survivor: Eon

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:52 pm
by McMenno
randomizing thrice doesn't make it more random >:(

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:57 pm
by xRECKONERx

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 12:57 pm
by xRECKONERx
In post 57, McMenno wrote:randomizing thrice doesn't make it more random >:(
no but it proves i didn't just randomize it once until i found the one i wanted

idk it's a habit bc a couple of raffle groups im in on facebook do it this way, sod off

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:06 pm
by Cheery Dog
Medevac island should have used more stamina to prevent the rocks

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:09 pm
by xRECKONERx
oh ho ho

these vote splits are INTERESTING [thinking emoji]

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 1:47 pm
by Shadoweh
Battle of the Bands
"honestly just p disappointing as a season and the cast was meh. like when's the last time anyone brought up this awesome or memorable thing that happened in BotB?"
I feel like this has become a guilty pleasure thinking back on it. I'm more nostalgic about BotB on the whole because every round was twisty and interesting because of players rather then crazy twists or a few too many boring pre-merge boots.

Please don't make another one though.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:16 pm
by DeathNote
Psshhhhh kawazu is also a reason abridged was a good game. Haters gonna hate!

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:38 pm
by Papa Zito
Kawazu was also kindof the only super interesting thing in that game.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 2:47 pm
by grumpy
I'm filing a report. #justiceforMedevac

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 3:27 pm
by DeathNote
WHATEVER!!!! A18 was a boss. Young Trunks had everyone in tangles. The alliances in Merge were freaking ridiculous and inconsistent.

My biggest complaint about DBZA was that I couldn't get some of the challenges to work the way I envisioned.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 3:27 pm
by xRECKONERx
and also the theme sucked :3

[disclaimer: coming from someone who ran a game themed around ice cream flavors]

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 3:31 pm
by xRECKONERx
also we should really decide which of the shit tier games should go out first so another one doesn't get rocks'd

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 4:02 pm
by DeathNote
I in awe that people don't like the abridged series of Dragonball Z or just DBZ itself... yet running a Survivor anything theme is acceptable :(

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 4:11 pm
by Papa Zito
whoa I love the DBZA series

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 4:12 pm
by xRECKONERx
In post 69, DeathNote wrote:I in awe that people don't like the abridged series of Dragonball Z or just DBZ itself... yet running a Survivor anything theme is acceptable :(
we are playing Survivor

i mean i get it. prior to starting to play anon games I thought Survivor themes were lame. i still think they're low energy. but i get the theme.

DBZA is mehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. ive seen some of the youtube videos, they were more cringe than anything to me

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 4:36 pm
by Shadoweh
I was shocked how many people knew nothing about Dragon Ball, nevermind DBZA. >>

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 4:38 pm
by DeathNote
Thank you Zito but... Reck.... I....


Need a moment.

Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2017 5:05 pm
by Cephrir
dbz would have been a better theme, the abridged series is kind of bad. i know, i tried to like it.

that yugioh challenge is a great example of why reviews need to be thorough.

but the game itself was really fun and super unpredictable. both pre and postmerge had plenty of epic blindsides, with the alliance structures changing every damn round. i'm grading more on that scale.