Also, why is farside's time so high? Are you counting her fifth post in the time? Adding that on seems weird if you aren't counting it to the # of balances. Or are you not counting the first balance (which would mean 5 posts = 4 balances, so my score should be at 6, then)? But then, if you were doing that, you shouldn't count farside's last one, because if it's early enough to disqualify her, it shouldn't count towards her total. Including the total time. The way I see it, her time should be at 0:28.30.
My math:
1st post - 4:04.24
2nd post - 4:14.15 (9s early)
3rd post - 4:23.38 (7s early)
4th post - 4:32.31 (7s early)
5th post - 4:39.48 (1m 13s early; disqualified)
4:04.24 -> 4:32.31=0:28.07 (+23s)
TL;DR - how are you keeping score here? I think you screwed up the math.